Republic of the Philippines
SUPREME COURT
Manila
THIRD DIVISION
G.R. No. 168923 November 28, 2008
BIENVENIDO M. CADALIN, ROLANDO M. AMUL, DONATO B. EVANGELISTA, and PETITIONERS: AALAGOS, ROGELIO; ABACAN, GERARDO M.; ABAD, NICANOR; ABADE, RICARDO B.; ABAN, JOSE; ABANDO, ALEX B.; ABANDO, GREGORIO; ABANES, ANDRES A.; ABANES, MARTIN M.; ABANES, REYNALDO A.; ABANES, RODRIGO M.; ABANES, RODRIGO M.; ABANO, JOVENAL A.; ABANTE, ARIEL B.; ABANTE, EDUARDO; ABANTO, GREGORIO M.; ABARCA, FELMON M.; ABARQUEZ, EMIGDION N.; ABARRO, JOSE H.; ABARRO, JOSEFINO Q.; ABELANIO, CELSO S.; ABELLA, HERMINIO V.; ABESTANO, MIGUEL O.; ABILA, FERNANDO J.; ABOY, ERNESTO M.; ABRIL, MODESTO M.; ABUBO, RODRIGO G.; ABULON, JULIAN V.; ABUSTAN, JOSE JR., B.; ACAIN, FELIPE C.; ACAN, NORBERTO G.; ACERES, DANTE C.; ACERO, DANNY; ACHA, ROGELIO B.; ACLAN, EFREN; ACO, ROGELIO A.; ACUPAN, VICENTE A.; ADAJAR, CESAR L.; ADALIN, GREGORIO; ADALLA, GREGORIO; ADANA, MANUEL P.; ADAWAG, ANGEL G.; ADAWAG, CARLITO; ADAWAG, CRESENCIANO; ADAWAG, NOEL P.; ADAWAG, TEODULFO; ADRAYAN, ALFREDO B.; AGAPITO, GENEROSO M.; AGNE, BERNARDO R.; AGNE, FLORENTINO R.; AGNE, RIZALINO R.; AGUADO, ANICETO A.; AGUBA, RESTITUTO A.; AGUDO, GUILLERMO R.; AGUDO, QUITERIO R.; AGUE, FLORENTINO R.; AGUILA, BENJAMIN G.; AGUILA, BERNARDO F.; AGUILA, JOSUE G.; AGUILA, VICENTE G.; AGUILAR, ESPERIDION T.; AGUILAR, FRANCISCO; AGUINALDO, MANUEL P.; AGUIRRE, DANTE; AGUIRRE, HERMINIO J.; AGUSTIN, GALICANO D.; ALABAY, NESTOR M.; ALABAY, AGRIPINO V.; ALAGAD, ALFONSO; ALAGAD, BERNARDO F.; ALAGAD, FERNANDO; ALBERTO, GONZALO JR., D.; ACOJIDO, REYNALDO S.; ACTA, LEOWILIN A.; ACUEZA, EUGENIO C.; ACUNA, MANUEL T.; ACUPAN, ANTONIO; ACUPAN, BENITO; ACUPAN, BENJAMIN D.; ACUPAN, EDUARDO B.; ACUPAN, EMMANUEL; ACUPAN, JUANITO P.; ACUPAN, MAXIMIANO A.; ACUPAN, REYNALDO C.; ACUPAN, ROMEO C.; ACUPAN, SOLANO; ALDOVER, ALFREDO L.; ALDOVER, BENCIO L.; ALEA, DIOSDADO A.; ALEGADA, WILFREDO; ALEJANDRE, ALEJANDRO; ALEJANDRE, BENJAMIN A.; ALEJANDRE, HILARION F.; ALEJANDRE, MAXIMINO R.; ALEJANDRE, NOEL P.; ALEJANDRINO, ANSELMO V.; ALEJANDRINO, ENRICO I.; ALEJANDRO, BENJAMIN; ALEJANDRO, EDUARDO L.; ALEJANDRO, EULALIO V.; ALEJANDRO, MAXIMINO; ALFECHE, INOCENCIO V.; ALFREDO, TEODOLFO M.; ALHAMBRA, CEZAR A.; ALINDAY, TOMAS C.; ALMENAR, ALBERTO Z.; ALMERO, ERNESTO C.; ALMONTE, ROMEO B.; ALMONTE, VIRGILIO B.; ALONZO, ARNALDO; ALORIA, AMADO C.; ALVAREZ, ALEXANDER; ALVAREZ, APOLINARIO A.; ALVAREZ, CAMILO; ALVAREZ, MANUEL C.; ALVAREZ, PABLO C.; ALVAREZ, RAUL A.; ALVAREZ, ROLANDO S.; AMA, PAFICO; AMBAL, EDMUNDO G.; AMBAL, HERMOGENES R.; ALBINO, SEPTIMO O.; ALBO, ALEJANDRO R.; ALBURO, ORLANDO; ALCAIRA, ALEXANDER R.; ALCALDE, ROLANDO A.; ALCANTARA, CONRADO LUIS D.; ALCANTARA, JAIME B.; ALCANTARA, JESUS M.; ALCANTARA, LAMBERTO Q.; ALCANTARA, MARIANITO JR., J.; ALCANTARA, MARIO C.; ALDEGUER, FEDERICO JR., T.; ALDIANO, PONCIANO C.; ANDAYA, JOAQUIN S.; ANDOY, LEOPOLDO R.; ANDRADA, DAN F.; ANDRADA, SIMEON; ANDULAN, REYNALDO B.; ANG, NESTOR V.; ANGELES, GERONIMO H.; ANGLO, ANTONIO T.; ANI, JEOFFREY; ANICETE, BELTRANICO S.; ANICETE, ROMEO S.; ANIS, BARTOLOME B.; ANSALDO, JOSE B.; ANTILLON, ELINIO P.; ANTIPONO, ARMANDO B.; ANTONIO, LARRY T.; APILADO, ANTONIO; APILADO, ARTURO P.; APOLINARIO, PEPITO; APOLINARIO, FRANCISCO; APUADO, VICTORIO C.; AQUINO, ABANES O.; AQUINO, ABNER O.; AQUINO, ANGEL D.; AQUINO, BARTOLOME; AQUINO, GRACIANO M.; AQUINO, ISIDRO; AQUINO, JIMMY B.; AQUINO, PASTOR; AQUINO, ROSENDO M.; AQUINO, RUBEN M.; ARACARIA, ALEXANDER; ARANDELA, PERCIVAL L.; ARANGORIN, ROBERTO A.; ARATEA, BENJAMIN O.; ARAULLO, ARTURO V.; AMBROCIO, BENJAMIN R.; AMBUNAN, JULIAN P.; AMISTAD, MARTIN G.; AMORES, CARLOS; AMPIL, JOSE R.; AMUL, SEBASTIAN B.; AMURAO, CRISPULO JR., C.; AMURAO, CRISPULO SR., T.; AMUTAN, FERNANDO L.; AMUTAN, MOISES; ANANDING, AMORSOLO S.; ANCHETA, BERNARD P.; ANCHETA, TEOTINIO O.; ANDAL, DANILO L.; ANDAMO, CARLOS P.; ARGUELLES, ANGELITO M.; ARGUELLES, EULALIO; ARGUELLES, HERMENIGILDO M.; ARICA, WILFREDO P.; ARIZA, DIONISIO R.; ARLITA, VICENTE; ARONSE, JUANITO P.; ARTITA, ROGELIO S.; ARUELIO, VICENTE; ASEDILLO, JOSE M.; ASPER, RODOLFO M.; ASUNAN, DANILO R.; ASUNCION, ANTONIO; ASUNCION, ARTEMIO M.; ASUNCION, EDGARDO; ASUNCION, REXY SR., L.; ASUNCION, RODOLFO C.; ASUNCION, FELICIANO N.; ATIENZA, CARLITO C.; ATIENZA, JOSE R.; ATIENZA, JUSTO; ATIENZA, RESTITUTO A.; ATUD, LEONELITO M.; AUSTRIA, ANGEL; AUSTRIA, CALIXTO B.; AUSTRIA, OSCAR M.; AUSTRIA, SAVADOR T.; AVELLANA, JOSE; AVILA, VIRGILIO I.; AVUELTA, RICARDO JR., P.; AXALAN, BARTOLOME M.; AXALAN, BARTOLOME M.; AXALAN, LORETO JR.; AXALAN, MARINAO V.; ARAULLO, PRUDENCIO; ARAYATA, ESCOLASTICO; ARCANGEL, MANUEL DG.; ARCARIA, ALEXANDER; ARCIAGA, FRANCISCO P.; AREVALO, JOSE; AREVALO, JUANITO; AREVALO, MARIO A.; AREVALO, RAMON; AREVALO, RAMON A.; AREVALO, RODOLFO D.; ARGETE, GAVINO M.; ARGUELLES, ALFREDO; BAGASIN, LAMILO A.; BAGTING, VICENTE G.; BAGTING, VICENTE G.; BALABALO, LUIS; BALANTE, GERONIMO; BALATAZO, SILVERIO M.; BALBICRAN, GERARDO R.; BALBIERAN, ANATALIO B.; BALBIERAN, MAXIMO C.; BALBIERAN, ROMEO B.; BALBIERAN, ROMULO R.; BALBIERAN, VICENTE D.; BALBIN, RODOLFO C.; BALBIRAN, FERNANDO B.; BALCOBA, FEDERICO B.; BALINAS, PABLO G.; BALINGIT, RODOLFO F.; BALITBIT, RODOLFO; BALIWAG, CESARIO H.; BALOBO, ALFREDO S.; BALOBO, TEODORO V.; BANAAG, FALCONERI; BARASARI, RIZAL; BARBA, DANILO M.; BARBOZA, RAMON T.; BARCENA, FIDEL F.; BARIN, RODOLFO; BARLENA, FIDEL F.; BARLENA, FLORENTINO; BAROLA, ABDON V.; BARRIENTOS, BENJAMIN; BARRO, BERNARDO C.; BARTIDO, LEONARDO; BARTOLOME, MARCELO; BARZAGA, VIVENCIO T.; AXALAN, VICENTE R.; AYO, HERBERT; AZAGRA, JAIME A.; BABAEL, SHERLITO S.; BABAGAY, CONRADO T.; BABAGAY, GERARDO; BABASA, WILHEM S.; BABILONIA, ALFREDO C.; BACAL, FELIMON; BACAMANTE, VIRGILIO A.; BACANI, JOSE L.; BACARAT, PAISAL G.; BADUA, EMERITO M.; BAES, FILOTEO A.; BAGADIONG, GUILLERMO T.; BAGADIONG, NOEL S.; BAUTISTA, IRENE P.; BAUTISTA, JOSE D.; BAUTISTA, LEONARDO; BAUTISTA, MAMERTO S.; BAUTISTA, RUPERTO B.; BAUTISTA, RUSTICO; BAUTISTA, TEODORO S.; BAUTISTA, VIRGILIO O.; BAYA, INONCENCIO; BAYA, JESUS R.; BAYACAL, VENANCIO JR., V.; BAYACAL, WINEFREDO; BAYLON, LOLITO F.; BEBIT, WENNIEFREDO B.; BELEN, ENRICO P.; BELIR, BEN G.; BELTRAN, DIEGO; BELTRAN, EBRULFO G.; BELTRAN, ERIC B.; BELTRAN, LARGION G.; BENITEZ, RAUL B.; BENSON, PERFECTO F.; BERGONIO , IRENEO G.; BERMUDEZ, ISABELO; BERMUDEZ, ROLANDO; BERNAL, VICTORIO; BERNALES, EMILIANO JR., L.; BERON, DANILO; BERSAMIN, BENJAMIN A.; BERSAMIN, BENJAMIN A.; BERSAMIN, DINDO L.; BERWITE, RENATO P.; BICOL, LARRY C.; BASILAN, JUAN L.; BASMAYOR, ARTEMIO A.; BASTRO, REYNALDO U.; BATACLAN, MARIO; BATAIN, ROMEO; BATICA, ERNESTO SR., S.; BATICA, HOBINO O.; BATICA, ROBERTO S.; BATINGA, ELUETERIO P.; BATITIS, CEFERINO; BAUAN, VICTORIANO A.; BAUAN, VIVENCIO C.; BAUTISTA, CEFERINO O.; BAUTISTA, EMEGDIO P.; BAUTISTA, GAUDENCIO S.; BLAS, ROGELIO; BLAY, NESTOR M.; BLAY, RODRIGO M.; BOADO, ELPIDIO A.; BOBADILLA, CESAR; BOBADILLA, DANILO A.; BOBADILLA, LAUDICO A.; BOBIER, FELIX M.; BOBONGO, DIONISIO O.; BODADILLA, CESAR A.; BODADILLA, DANILO A.; BOLANTE, GERONIMO E.; BOLANTE, GIL I.; BOLISAY, CARLITO M.; BONDOC, AUGUSTO; BONDOC, BENITO U.; BONDOC, DOMINGO; BONGT, DOMINGO S.; BOOC, PEPE S.; BOQUIREN, ARNULFO JR., M.; BOQUIREN, ARNULFO M.; BORDILLA, ERESTO J.; BORJA, JAMES SR., V.; BORNALES, RICARDO C.; BRACAMANTE, BAYANI S.; BRACAMANTE, VIRGILIO A.; BRACEROS, WILFREDO; BRAGAIS, DEMETRIO B.; BRAGANZA, NORBERTO E.; BRAVO, TINIOSO S.; BRECINO, ANGELES; BRIONES, EURECLYDON G.; BRIONES, ROMEO B.; BRIONES, TRANQUILINO Y.; BICOL, ANGELITO M.; BICOL, ANSELMO G.; BICOL, ARISTEO M.; BICOL, CELESTINO JR., C.; BICOL, CESARIO M.; BICOL, FELICISIMO M.; BICOL, FLORENTINO L.; BICOL, FRANCISCO G.; BICOL, ROGELIO M.; BICOL, ROMULO L.; BIGADION, NOEL S.; BILLONES, ROGELIO A.; BISCOCHO, ELEUTERIO B.; BISCOCHO, PETRONILLO M.; BITO, TEOFILO N.; BLANCO, FERNANDO; BLANCO, VIRGILIO; BULATAO, ALFREDO G.; BULLECER, RODOLFO R.; BUNAO, ISABELO M.; BUNGAY, AVENILO; BUNGAY, JEFFERSON Q.; BUSTAMANTE, ALEXANDER; BUSTAMANTE, JOSE G.; BUSTILLO, PABLITO G.; BUTIONG, VIRGILIO JR.; CAALIM, BENITO T.; CAALIM, ROMEO T.; CABALLA, HONESTO P.; CABALLERO, DELFIN C.; CABALLERO, JACINTO B.; CABANIGAN, BENEDICTO; CABATAY, MOISES; CABEZA, GUILLERMO; CABIGAN, ROSENDO Z.; CABILANGAN, PABLO G.; CABRERA, JOSE D.; CABRERA, HERMANELI; CABUHAT, REYNALDO T.; CAGANAP, JULIO R.; CAGATAN, DOROTEO G.; CAGATAN, PEDRO; CAGATAN, RODOLFO; CAGAYAT, JOVEN C.; CAHIGAS, NESTOR B.; CAILAO, AMANTE; CAILES, DORITO A.; CALADO, FERNANDO M.; CALAJOS, ROGELIO L.; BROTONEL, CEFERINO G.; BERSAMIN, DINDO L.; BRUCE, CESAR B.; BRUGE, AMADO; BUENAFE, TOMAS V.; BUENAFLOR, MARIANITO N.; BUENAVENTURA, ARCHIMEDES N.; BUENAVENTURA, BASILIO N.; BUENAVENTURA, RUPERTO JR., E.; BUENCONSEJO, GUILLERMO; BUENTE, TOMAS; BUENVIAJE, MANUEL; BUENVIAJE, VICENTO; BUGAY, REYNALDO D.; BULAMBAO, BUENAVENTURA D.; BULANHAGUI, ARIEL F.; CAMANAG, SOTERO P.; CAMPANO, PACIFICO; CAMPOSAGRADO, ALEJANDRO M.; CANDA, EDGARDO M.; CANDOR, IRINEO P.; CANDOR, IRMER L.; CANTOS, GERONIMO M.; CANTOS, PRIMITIVO; CANTOS, SEVERINO; CAPACETE, RAMON JR., G.; CAPARAS, GASPAR V.; CAPONPON, EPIFANIO; CAPONPON, RICARDO; CARLOS, NARCISO; CARREON, ARMANDO; CARTEL, JOSE H.; CASA, CRISENDO; CASADO, EMMANUELITO P.; CASINO, RENATO; CASTANARES, DALMACIO R.; CASTANEDA, MENANDRO M.; CASTELO, ELIAS JR., D.; CASTILLO, ANSELMO S.; CASTILLO, ARNEL L.; CASTILLO, BENIGNO A.; CASTILLO, CORNELIO L.; CASTILLO, EMETERIO L.; CASTILLO, FERDINAND L.; CASTILLO, JOAQUIN; CASTILLO, JOSE L.; CASTILLO, JOSEPH B.; CASTILLO, LEONICIO B.; CASTILLO, LOURDINO M.; CALAMBA, FELIPE S.; CALAUAG, RICARDO C.; CALAUAGAN, PATRONICIO L.; CALCENA, ISAGANI; CALDERON, OSCAR C.; CALDERON, REYNALDO V.; CALLEJA, NESTOR D.; CALMA, ALEJANDRO JR., P.; CALMA, FERNANDO R.; CALMA, JERRY D.; CALMA, MIGUEL M.; CALMA, RENATO R.; CALURA, JOVEN C.; CALURA, RENATO R.; CAMACHO, NELSON T.; CAMACHO, SANTOS T.; CAMANA, ROBERTO M.; CAMANAG, FLORANTE C.; CATIBOG, RODOLFO; CATIBOG, SESINANDO; CATIPAN, DOMINADOR D.; CATLI, JAIME B.; CATUD, CONRADO A.; CAY, PRUMENCIO F.; CAYANAN, FRANCISCO D.; CAYAS, REYNALDO; CECELIO, ROMEO O.; CEFERINO, DURANA D.; CELESTINO, VICTORINO R.; CELIS, AUGUSTO; CELIS, RODOLFO B.; CENENA, NESTOR; CENTENO, EMMANUEL C.; CENTURA, GORGONIO C.; CEREZO, ELMO A.; CEREZO, HERMINIGILDO A.; CERRO, CAMILO C.; CETES, HENRY; CHAN, BENJAMIN M.; CHAN, GENEROSO M.; CHAVEZ, CESAR A.; CHUA, ANTONIO C.; CHUA, CECILIO H.; CIABAL, VIVENCIO B.; CIFRA, HERNAN N.; CIFRA, VICENTE C.; CLARETE, RODRIGO; CLARETE, VIENVENIDO; CLAUD, CRIZALDO D.; CASTILLO, MANUEL; CASTILLO, MARIO E.; CASTILLO, NARDITO M.; CASTILLO, NATALIO L.; CASTILLO, NESTOR; CASTILLO, PABLO L.; CASTILLO, ROMEO P.; CASTILLO, VIDAL J.; CASTRO, CESAR M.; CASTRO, CRISALDO M.; CASTRO, DANILO M.; CASTRO, PRUDENCIO; CASTRO, RAMON M.; CASTROJERES, REMAR; CATAPANG, CONRADO M.; CATAPANG, IRENEO; CATIBOG, PEPITO M.; CORDOVA, CARLOS JR., V.; CORNISTA, RINO T.; CORNISTA, ROMEO G.; CORONADO, ALFONSO S.; CORONADO, APOLINARIO V.; CORONEL, ABELARDO; CORONEL, FELIX M.; CORPUZ, LEONARDO P.; CORTEMPRATO, CESAR; CORTEZ, EDGARDO D.; CORVERA, FRANCISCO O.; COSINO, RENATO R.; COSINO, SOFRONIO B.; COSTALES, FELIPE SR., B.; COSTALES, FRANCISCO SR.; CREDITO, CELEDENIO R.; CREDITO, ENRICO R.; CRISOSTOMO, IGMEDIO JR., G.; CORTEJO, JOEL O.; CRUES, ALBERTO A.; CRUES, TEODULFO G.; CRUETA, ANTONIO B.; CRUSIS, MANOLITO R.; CRUZ, ANACLETO JR., V.; CRUZ, ARTURO I.; CRUZ, AUGUSTO B.; CRUZ, DANILO M.; CRUZ, ERNESTO; CRUZ, HILARIO C.; CRUZ, PANCHI G.; CRUZ, ROBERTO P.; CRUZ, RODELIO; CLAVIO, BIENVENIDO M.; COCJIN, JOSE JR., B.; COLMENAR, BALTAZAR R.; COLOMA, AUGUSTO V.; COMPLE, DAMIANO S.; CONCEPCION, MANUEL JR., C.; CONCEPCION, TURIANO V.; CONCEPCION, VIRGILIO C.; CONSTANTINO, ROLANDO A.; CONSTANTINO, TERESITO A.; CONTEMPRATO, CESAR P.; CONTEMPRATO, LAURO G.; CONTI, BAYANI; CONTI, EDMUNDO C.; CONTI, REYNALDO C.; CORALES, ARMANDO C.; CORALES, JESUS M.; CORCUERA, RENATO; CORDERO, MARI F.; DALANON, VICENTE D.; DALUZ, NICOLAS; DATAAN, TEODORO C.; DATAN, JOSE C.; DATAY, ANDRES F.; DATAY, CRISANTO A.; DATILES, MIGUEL A.; DATINGUINOO, DESIDERIO A.; DATINGUINOO, NICASIO C.; DATOON, JOSE; DAVID, ADOLFO; DAVID, EDUARDO; DAVID, ENRICO T.; DAVID, FABIO; DAVID, VICTORIANO S.; DAYACAP, EDGARDO N.; DAYANDAYAN, TOMESTOCLES; DAYANGHIRANG, RUFINO T.; DAYRIT, BAYANI; DAYRIT, LEONARDO S.; DAYRIT, RICARDO; DAYRIT, VICTORIANO C.; DE ADE, BAYANI R.; DE CASTRO, CRISTOBAL L.; DE CASTRO, PRIMITIVO L.; DE CASTRO, ROMEO A.; DE CASTRO, RENE T.; DE CHAVEZ, PEDRO; DE DIOS, CESAR J.; DE GUZMAN, ANGELITO JR.; CRUZ, RODOLFO B.; CRUZ, TEODORO S.; CUARESMA, DIONISIO A.; CUDAL, RAYMUNDO; CUENCO, EDELTRUDO F.; CUENCO, EDGAR F.; CUESTINO, VICTORINO; CUEVAS, ABDON S.; CUEVAS, MANUEL C.; CUIZON, FELIMON; CULLERA, MANUEL M.; CUNANAN, MARIO I.; CUSAP, ERNESTO O.; CUSTODIO, EDUARDO G.; DACASIN, DANILO B.; DACASIN, FERNANDO B.; DAGONDON, FERMIO; DAGUINSIN, RICHARD A.; DE RAMA, FALCONERY R.; DE RAMA, FEDERICO J.; DE RAMA, ONOFRE L.; DE RAMA, RICARDO L.; DE RAMA, ROLANDO A.; DE SILOS, RODOLFO B.; DE TORRES, ARNULFO; DE TORRES, LEONARDO; DE TORRES, NEMESIO A.; DE VERA, IGNACIO C.; DE VERA, MARCIANO D.; DE VERA, MARCIANO V.; DE VERA, NESTOR DR.; DE VERA, REYNALDO M.; DE VERA, WILFREDO M.; DE VILLA, RODOLFO C.; DEL MUNDO, DANILO L.; DEL MUNDO, PEDRO C.; DEL MUNDO, WALFREDO L.; DEL PILAR, FLORENTINO; DEL PILAR, LORENCIO; DEL PRADO, VICENTE P.; DEL RIO, PASTOR; DEL ROSARIO, ALBERTO; DEL ROSARIO, ALFREDO; DEL ROSARIO, CESAR S.; DEL ROSARIO, GENEROSO F.; DEL ROSARIO, GUERERO; DEL ROSARIO, TEODORICO; DEL ROSARIO, VEDASTO; DELA CRUZ, ALBERTO; DE GUZMAN, BENEDICTO N.; DE GUZMAN, CELERINO; DE GUZMAN, DONATO; DE GUZMAN, FRANCISCO C.; DE GUZMAN, ROLANDO F.; DE GUZMAN, ROMAN A.; DE GUZMAN, ROMULO L.; DE JESUS, LIBERTO; DE JESUS, PRIMO; DE JESUS, REYNALDO C.; DE LEMON, VICTORIO SR., R.; DE LEMOS, BENITO JR.; DE LEMOS, VICTORIA; DE LEON, DOMINADOR A.; DE LEON, ENRIQUE C.; DE LEON, ERNESTO C.; DE LEON, JOSE S.; DE LEON, PEDRO G.; DE LUMBAN, JOSELITO L.; DE LUNA, NAPOLEON S.; DELLOSA, JOSELITO FIDEL T.; DELOS REYES, EUSEBIO I.; DELOS REYES, LEONARDO; DELOS REYES, SILVERIO SR., V.; DELOS SANTOS, EMALDO D.; DELOS SANTOS, FELIZARDO M.; DELOS SANTOS, SERAFIN A.; DELOSO, JOSELITO T.; DENIEGA, JUANITO F.; DIATA, ERNESTO F.; DIAZ, ANTONIO R.; DIAZ, EDUARDO A.; DIAZ, ERNESTO E.; DIAZ, FELIX; DIAZ, MELCHOR; DIAZ, NICANOR S.; DIAZ, RENATO B.; DIAZ, TELESFORO M.; DIGA, GERARDO C.; DIMAANO, RODOLFO M.; DIMAAPI, ROMEO P.; DIMAPILIS, LEONCIO I.; DIMATATAC, JOSE A.; DIMATATAC, ROMULO; DIMATULAC, CLEMENTE B.; DIMAULATAN, VIVENCIO C.; DIMAYUGA, LUIS; DINGLASAN, ANIANO M.; DINGLASAN, MANUEL A.; DELA CRUZ, DANIEL; DELA CRUZ, DOMINGO V.; DELA CRUZ, EDGAR R.; DELA CRUZ, EMILIANO JR.; DELA CRUZ, ERNESTO T.; DELA CRUZ, FEDERICO N.; DELA CRUZ, JOSE G.; DELA CRUZ, JUAN R.; DELA CRUZ, MARCELINO G.; DELA CRUZ, REYNALDO B.; DELA CRUZ, WALFREDO B.; DELA CRUZ, ZOSIMO; DELA MERCED, ERNANI; DELA PENA, DOROTEO; DELA RAMA, RICARDO C.; DELA VEGA, ABRAHAM; DELA CRUZ, RODELIO; DELBORO, JOSELITO T.; DELGADO, RUFINO M.; EDUARTE, RENATO A.; EISMA, GODOFREDO E.; EJERCITO, ANTONIO JR.; ELIAS, CARLITO; ELLO, ARDON B.; ELLO, UBED B.; EMMAN, JOHNNY M.; ENANO, JOSEFINO R.; ENCANTO, JOSE T.; ENCARNACION, REYNALDO A.; ENGALLA, JAIME M.; ENGAY, VICENTE; ENGON, VICENTE; ENGUANCHO, EDGARDO; ENGUERO, ELMER F.; ENRIQUEZ, ROLANDO G.; EQUIPADO, ELIAS JR., F.; ERIDAO, EDUARTE C.; ESCARILLA, RAMON JR., T.; ESCARILLO, WILFREDO; ESCARMOSA, FELIZARO; ESCARMOSA, MIGUEL B.; ESCATOTO, ELADIO L.; ESCOBAR, ARMANDO; ESCOTA, GILBERTO B.; ESCUYOR, ROMEO T.; ESEO, ERNESTO SR., A.; ESGUERRA, DEMOCRITO M.; ESGUERRA, JOHN; ESPANOL, MIGUEL L.; DIONISIO. ROLANDO V.; DISINGANIO, DOMINGO J.; DISMAYA, PHILIP G.; DIZON, MODESTO; DIZON, REYNALDO S.; DOCTOLERO, BENJAMIN; DOLOIRAS, MARCELINO D.; DOMINGO, RODOLFO; DOMINGUEZ, ANTONIO S.; DOZA. BENJAMIN E.; DUAG, ELPIDIO I.; DUMAGUIN, SATURNINO H.; DUMAGUN, PERSEVERANDO H.; DUMALI, FELIPE; DUPA, BENJAMIN D.; DURAN, DANILO C.; DURAN, GREGORIO D.; DURANA, CEFERINO; EBRADA, GILBERT; EBRADA, GILBERTO; EBRADA, RICARDO P.; ESPIRITU, RODOLFO C.; ESPIRITU, RODOLFO S.; ESPIRITU, RODRIGO C.; ESPIRITU, ROLANDO E.; ESPORAS, MANUEL M.; ESPREGANTE, JULIAN; ESQUIVEL, ARTURO S.; ESTACIO, BOB L.; ESTACIO, ROMEO P.; ESTANDARTE, DIOSCORO; ESTANISLAO, IGMIDIO; ESTAVA, NESTOR M.; ESTEAN, ERNESTO M.; ESTERON, MELANIO R.; ESTRADA, BENJAMIN S.; ESTRADA, FELICIANO E.; ESTRELLA, GERONIMO; ESTUAR, CONRADO E.; ESTUYE, CLYDE; ETCHON, REYNALDO D.; ETCHON, REYNALDO O.; EVANGELISTA, ANTONIO S.; EVANGELISTA, EDUARDO M.; EVANGELISTA, ROLANDO; EVANGELISTA, VALERIO A.; FABABIER, MANUEL M.; FABRICANTE, PRIMO; FACTORAN, FELICISIMO D.; ESPARAGO, NOEL; ESPINA, PASCUAL F.; ESPINA, ROBERT; ESPINO, ARTURO B.; ESPINO, CARLITO J.; ESPINO, EDGARDO B.; ESPINO, HONORIO E.; ESPINO, HORACIO; ESPINO, SILVERIO D.; ESPINOSA, GRACIANO; ESPINOSA, POLICARPIO C.; ESPINOSA, TEODORO; ESPIRITU, ANGELITO B.; ESPIRITU, EDUARDO S.; ESPIRITU, ERNESTO S.; ESPIRITU, GREGORIO S.; ESPIRITU, ILDEFONSO R.; ESPIRITU, LEONARDO JR., A.; ESPIRITU, MANUEL S.; ESPIRITU, REYNALDO B.; FIRMA, RIZALDO F.; FLORES, AGAPITO C.; FLORES, ARMANDO F.; FLORES, BENJAMIN D.; FLORES, EDILBERTO M.; FLORESCA, ELIGIO B.; FORES, EDGARDO C.; FRANCISCO, ROLANDO B.; FRAGADA, GREGORIO; FRAMIL, ROSAURO R.; FRANCIA, ISABELITO P.; FRANCISCO, BUENAVENTURA M.; FRANCISCO, CORNELIO Y.; FRANCISCO, EDGARDO J.; FRANCISCO, FRAMIL; FRANCISCO, MANUEL S.; FRANCISCO, MARIO B.; FRANCISCO, OLEGARIO B.; FRANCISCO, VALERIANO B.; FRANE, PHILBERT M.; FRANZUELA, ILDEFONSO M.; FIRME, DANIEL PEDRO C.; FURTO, REYNALDO L.; FURTO, WENFREDO L.; GABAWAN, JESUS E.; GABAWAN, RODOLFO A.; GABAY, CASTANIRO; GABAY, CONSTANCIO F.; GABAY, TEODORICO A.; FADRIQUELA, SESENIO; FAJARDO, EFREN G.; FAJARDO, ELISEO; FAJARDO, PEDRO E.; FALLER, REYNALDO C.; FALQUEZA, PORFIRIO; FALTADO, RUBEN; FARAON, CIRIACO; FAUSTINO, WILFREDO; FEDERICO, ABUNDIO B.; FERIA, CARINO; FERNANDEZ, AGATON B.; FERNANDEZ, EMILIO E.; FERNANDEZ, JOSE CELEDONIO L.; FERNANDEZ, SERMAN O.; FERNANDO, LEONARDO S.; FERNANDEZ, ELY E.; FERRER, ARTEMIO C.; FERRER, CENON; FERRER, ERNESTO; FERRER, LEOPOLDO S.; FIGURACION, MISAEL M.; GARCIA, EUGENIO JR., C.; GARCIA, MARCELO L.; GARCIA, MARCELO L. GARCIA, PATRICIO JR., L.; GARCIA, PEDRO C.; GARCIA, PONCIANO G.; GARCIA, R.E.; GARCIA, RAFAEL P.; GARCIA, ROBERTO S.; GARCIA, ROLANDO; GARCIA, PONCIANO J.; GAROFIL, OSIAS G.; GARON, RAYMUNDO C.; GASCON, ROLANDO; GATCHALIAN, ERNESTO E.; GATCHALIAN, JOSE; GATELA, ROLANDO G.; GATULAYAO, CONRADO; GAWAN, JOSE A.; GAYA, JOSE; GAYA, JOSE M.; GAYA, LEONARDO T.; GAYETA, AVELINO DM.; GELLID, MANOL F.; GELLIDO, ERNESTO D.; GEMOTO, ROBERTO; GENEROSO, AGAPITO; GABUTAN, ESMERADO; GALANG, BALBINO C.; GALANG, CESAR; GALLARDO, WILFREDO A.; GALOSO, SANTIAGO N.; GALVEZ, ROMEO A.; GAMBOA, GABRIEL C.; GAMMAD, POTENCIANO D.; GAMUTAN, IROBENGITO M.; GANAS, HILARIO M.; GANDAMON, BERNARDO; GANZON, JUAN A.; GARCIA, ALFREDO JR.; GARCIA, ANDRES JR., A.; GARCIA, ANGELITO P.; GARCIA, BERNARDINO N.; GARCIA, BERNARDO M.; GARCIA, DIGNO P.; GARCIA, ERMANDO M.; GARCIA, ERNESTO L.; GARCIA, ESMERALDO N.; GUINARES, OSCAR L.; GUINHAWA, NARCISO C.; GUINTO, ISAGANI S.; GUITANG, RODOLFO C.; GUNO, ALEXIS L.; GUNO, RICARDO K.; GUPIT, FRANCISCO G.; GUTIERREZ, DENNIS J.; GUTIERREZ, IGNACIO B.; GUTIERREZ, JOSE M.; HABANA, CESAR H.; HALCON, DANILO; HERNANDEZ, ANGELITO; HERNANDEZ, ARMANDO S.; HERNANDEZ, JULIO A.; HERNANDEZ, NAPOLEON; HERNANDEZ, RAUL G.; HERNANDEZ, REYNALDO; HICBAN, CIRILIO; HILADO, JOVENIANO D.; HILADO, MANUEL D.; HILADO, MARIO D.; HILAPO, JUSTO S.; HILARIO, ANTONIO; HILARIO, WINFREDO P.; HINAHON, ROSTITO; HINGADA, FELECISIMO; HINGALA, FELISMO; GERON, RAYMUNDO; GERONIMO, JULIO M.; GERONIMO, ROBERTO A.; GOMEZ, PATRICIO JR., V.; GONZALES, DOMINGO A.; GONZALES, EDUARDO B.; GONZALES, JAIME B.; GONZALES, LAMBERTO C.; GONZALES, MANUEL S.; GONZALES, NORBERTO; GONZALES, PLACIDO; GONZALES, REGINO M.; GONZALES, RUPERTO T.; GOPEZ, ARMANDO S.; GOTANA, EDGARDO Z.; GRAJERA, FLORANTE E.; GREGORIO, JOSE G.; GRULLO, JORGE T.; GUANTO, ROGELIO D.; GUANZON, NARCISO D.; GUDA, ANGEL D.; GUERERO, MARTIN V.; GUEVARA, ROSENDO M.; JACOB, EXPEDITO N.; JACOB, HERY L.; JACOB, VICTOR M.; JANACO, ALEJANDRO M.; JAPITENGA, OSCAR J.; JARDINIANO, HONESTO; JARDINIANO, ROLANDO V.; JARO, ABRAHAM V.; JARO, CESAR; JARO, FERDINAND; JARO, ROMEO M.; JASMIN, MARIO; JAUDALSO, ROBERTO E.; JAVIER, ANTONIO C.; JAVIER, BUENVENIDO; JAVIER, CONRADO N.; JAVIER, ERNESTO; JAVIER, ROMEO M.; JERVOSO, JUANITO N.; JIMENA, ANGELICO JR., B.; JIMENEZ, CARLOS A.; JIMENEZ, DANILO E.; JOAQUIN, PEDRO C.; JOCACA, PEDRO; JOCO, RUSTICO P.; JOCSON, ANTONIO R.; HIPOLITO, EDUARDO M.; HILARIO, EXPEDITO; HOLGADO, RODRIGO C.; HONRADEZ, MAXIMINO B.; HUGGINS, WILFREDO M.; IGNACIO, GENEROSO; IGNACIO, RAUL L.; ILAGAN, FELIPE M.; ILAGAN, MANUEL; ILAGAN, PABLITO; ILAGAN, PEDRO; ILAGAN, RENATO L.; ILAGAN, TEOFILO M.; ILOG, VICENTE M.; INALVES, VICTOR S.; INASIANG, SANTIAGO; INSIGNE, CONRADO A.; INSIONG, CONRADO; ISIDORO, RODOLFO D.; ISLA, GRACIANO G.; JACLA, FLORIANO V.; JACOB, ARNEL L.; LACSAMANA, GERARDO; LACSON, JOSE B.; LADINES, MARIO J.; LAGAC, FELIPE R.; LAGAC, RUFINO; LAGANAPAN, RODRIGO Y.; LAGANAPAN, SANDY P.; LAGMAY, WILFREDO; LAJOM, ELISEO T.; LAKIAN, ARSENIO F.; LAMADRID, EFREN M.; LANDICHO, CONSTANCIO R.; LARKIN, WILFREDO M.; LARKIN, WILFREDO M.; LATANAN, GAUDENCIO; LATAYAN, VIRGILIO; LATOJA, DOMINGO D.; LATOJA, EMILIANO; LATOJA, JUANITO D.; LAURE, ANTONIO S.; LAUREL, WENCESLAO; LAXAMANA, ALFREDO S.; LAYON, EDGAR; LAZARO, DANIEL R.; LEANO, ANTONIO C.; LEANO, FELIX; LEBITA, RICARDO; JOCSON, FELINO U.; JOCSON, FELIPE U.; JOCSON, PEDRO N.; JOCSON, VALENTINO S.; JOLOYA, CLARO; JOLOYA, PEDRO B.; JONAS, ABELARDO E.; JOSE, ESTEBAN SR., S.; JOSE, RAUL; JOSE, RAUL R.; JOSEF, PETRONILLO L.; JOYA, RODOLFO E.; JUCAR, CESAR G.; JUSTO, RENATO E.; KABIGTING, GERTRUDO O.; KAMATOY, ARNALDO P.; KOLIMLIM, EDUARDO SR., S.; LABAY, LAURO J.; LABAYO, LEONARDO; LABELLA, EMMANUEL C.; LABING, ARCADIO T.; LABRADOR, FLORO A.; LABRAMONTE, JOSE R.; LACERONA, EDGARDO B.; LOGUINACIO, EDWIN C.; LONTOC, CRISPULO D.; LONTOC, LORETO; LONTOK, ROGELIO L.; LOPENA, DAVID C.; LOPENA, NICANOR C.; LOPERA, FELIPE M.; LOPERA, PEDRO M.; LOPERA, ROGELIO; LOPEZ, CARLITO M.; LOPEZ, CLODY; LOPEZ, GARLITO; LOPEZ, GEORGE I.; LOPEZ, LAMBERTO; LOPEZ, LARRY; LOPEZ, NICANOR D.; LOPEZ, RODRIGO M.; LOPEZ, VIRGILIO M.; LOQUINARIO, EDWIN C.; LOREJA, BERNARDITO G.; LOREJA, BERNARDITO G.; LORENZO, ISRAEL S.; LORICO, DOMINGO B.; LORINO, ALEJANDRO C.; LOYOLA, DOMINGO S.; LEGASPI, ARTURO S.; LEONOR, ARTURO V.; LEONOR, JULIO P.; LEOOR, MEINARDO M.; LEYESA, TEODORO M.; LEYNES, LUISITO; LICAROS, LUZVIMINDO F.; LILOC, MANOLITO C.; LIMACO, GERARDO JR.; LINSANGAN, ROSANNO S.; LIRIO, EFREN U.; LISING, ARCADIO T.; LISING, ERNESTO S.; LISING, ESMERALDO S.; LISING, RENATO S.; LISING, WILFREDO S.; LLANERA, RODRIGO G.; LOBETA, ROLANDO R.; LOGAN, ARNEL I.; LOGRONIO, CLARO A.; LOGRONIO, CLEMENTE A.; LOGRONIO, CORNELIO A.; LOGUC, FELIPE R.; MACALALAD, ANDRES T.; MACALALAD, NICASIO T.; MACALALAD, NOLI A.; MACALALAD, VICTOR B.; MACALDO, VICTOR C.; MACALDO, VICTOR C.; MACALINO, ALREDO M.; MACALINO, RICARDO; MACALINTAL, JOSE T.; MACARAEG, ARTHUR V.; MACARAEG, IRINEO; MACARAEG, NESTOR; MACARAIG, ERNESTO G.; MACARAIG, AURELIO S.; MACARAIG, BENITO V.; MACARAIG, BIENVENIDO; MACARAIG, EFREN C.; MACARAIG, NESTOR C.; MACARAIG, RODOLFO V.; MACARAIG, ROMEO; MACATANGAY, BASILIO M.; MACATANGAY, BENJAMIN; MACATANGAY, BUENAVENTURA A.; MACATANGAY, DAMASO; MACATANGAY, DAMASO M.; MACATANGAY, HERMOGENES; LUAGE, DANTE A.; LUAGE, HENRY A.; LUALHATI, ANTONIO M.; LUALHATI, EMMANUEL JR.; LUALHATI, JUAN M.; LUALHATI, LEONDES C.; LUALHATI, RAMON C.; LUALHATI, SEBASTIAN; LUBAT, FRANCISCO; LUBIAN, RUBINATO A.; LUCEA, RONITO E.; LUCERO, ARMANDO B.; LUKBAN, NARCISO H.; LUMANGLAS, ARMANDO G.; LUMANGLAS, ELEODORO A.; LUNA, THOMAS V.; LUNA, VICENTE; LUSUNG, ONOFRE M.; MAALIHAN, PELAGIO D.; MAAMO, BERNARDINO C.; MAAMO, MANUEL J.; MAAMO, VICTORIANO; MAAMO, VICTORIO; MABALAY, JOSE P.; MACABEBE, LEONIDES R.; MAGNAYE, RENATO M.; MAGNAYE, VENANCIO L.; MAGNAYE, VICTORINO R.; MAGNO, BOYET; MAGNO, CAMILO B.; MAGNO, DANILO B.; MAGNO, OSCAR R.; MAGNO, ROMEO B.; MAGPANTAY, ALFONSO; MAGPANTAY, FRANCISCO V.; MAGPANTAY, RICARDO C.; MAGPANTAY, SIMEON M.; MAGSINO, ARMANDO M.; MAGSINO, MACARIO S.; MAGSINO, ROLANDO; MAGTIBAY, ANTONIO; MAGTIBAY, MACARIO; MAGTIBAY, VICTOR V.; MAHILUM, GERONIMO SR., L.; MAISOG, CEFERINO G.; MAISOG, DAVID A.; MALABANAN, ROMEO B.; MALIPOL, RICKY; MALONZO, MANUEL; MACATANGAY, JUAN H.; MACATANGAY, MARIO; MACATANGAY, NAPOLEON A.; MACATANGAY, NICOLAS A.; MACATANGAY, REMEGIO; MACATANGAY, RICARDO M.; MACATANGAY, RODEL A.; MACATANGAY, ROMEO; MACATANGAY, ROMULO A.; MACATANGAY, SOFRONIO M.; MADLANGBAYAN, OSIAS Q.; MADRID, ERNESTO L.; MADRID, NICOLAS P.; MAESTRE, FELICITO C.; MAGANAYE, RENCEL B.; MAGANO, MARCOS L.; MAGAT, ABELARDO S.; MAGAT, EDILBERTO G.; MAGBABUA, EFREN C.; MAGBUHAT, BENJAMIN; MAGCALENG, ALFREDO C.; MAGNAYE, ANTONIO E.; MAGNAYE, ERNESTO L.; MAGNAYE, RANERIO M.; MANIGO, CORNELIO JR.; MANIGOS, PABLO SR., R.; MANIGOS, PAQUITO R.; MANIMTIM, ROLANDO C.; MANINGAS, FERMIN; MANINGAS, TEODOLFO D.; MANIVAL, ENRICO S.; MANONGSONG, DANIEL; MANSINARES, LEOPOLDO B.; MANUAL, DEMETRIO P.; MANUAL, ENRIQUE; MANUAL, MARCELO K.; MANUAL, MARCIANO C.; MANUAL, DOMINGO C.; MANUBA, ANGELITO T.; MANUBAG, LITO C.; MANUE, DIOSDADO; MANUEL, ERNESTO F.; MANUEL, MARCELO; MANUEL, MELCHOR G.; MANZANO, EDUARDO N.; MAPA, RICARDO; MAPILE, RAMON H.; MARANA, ROBERTO C.; MARANAN, HERMIE M.; MALONZO, MARCELO G.; MAMADIS, RICARDO; MANA, RODOLFO C.; MANAGHAYA, ISAGANI; MANALAC, REMEGIO S.; MANALILI, BERNARDO; MANALILI, MANUEL A.; MANALILI, ROGELIO; MANALO, ANGEL M.; MANALO, AQUILES L.; MANALO, DANILO M.; MANALO, FELIMON H.; MANALO, JOSE M.; MANANGHAYA, ISAGANI S.; MANANGUIT, ROMULO L.; MANAS, CESAR A.; MANDAYAO, VICENTE; MANDIGMA, DAVID A.; MANEBO, NOEL M.; MANGAHAS, LEOPOLDO A.; MANIAUL, ENRIQUE S.; MANIEGO, NOEL M.; MANIEGO, VIDAL A.; MANIGBAS, ADONIS D.; MANIGBAS, BAYANI; MANIGBAS, BENJAMIN; MARQUEZ, NARCISO A.; MARQUEZ, ROMEO; MARASIGAN, WENCESLAO; MARTINEZ, JOEL L.; MARTINEZ, NOEL R.; MARTINEZ, REYNALDO S.; MARTINEZ, RODOLFO C.; MASICAMPO, DIEGO R.; MATA, PAOLO M.; MATAVERDE, AURELIO M.; MATI, CONRADO L.; MATIENZO, AMADEO; MATIENZO, SALVADOR R.; MATILLA, RENATO; MATILLA, VICTORIANO L.; MATITO, LEONARDO N.; MATREO, DANTE A.; MEDEL, VIRGILIO; MEDINA, AUGUSTO C.; MEDINA, CIPRIANO R.; MEDINA, FLORANTE L.; MEDINA, JAIME L.; MEDINA, JESSE L.; MARANIAG, NORMANDY; MARASIGAN, BASILIO V.; MARASIGAN, DELFIN M.; MARASIGAN, HILARIO M.; MARASIGAN, NEMESIO; MARASIGAN, RODOLFO P.; MARASIGAN, WENCESLAO; MARCELO, DOMINGO G.; MARCELO, LEONARDO J.; MARCELO, MARIO L.; MARCELO, SERAFIN M.; MARCIADA, ROLANDO; MARCIAL, LEONIGILDO; MARIANO, ARMANDO T.; MARIANO, FEDERICO S.; MARIANO, HENRY F.; MARIANO, MARLON L.; MARIANO, NARCISO T.; MARIANO, NAVARRO D.; MARIDABLE, JOSE B.; MARINO, SANTOS E.; MARPURI, RODOLFO C.; MARQUEZ, BAYANI A.; MARQUEZ, CARLOS A.; MARQUEZ, CELSO M.; MENDOZA, TIMOTEO F.; MENDOZA, VIRGILIO V.; MENOR, CRESENTE S.; MERCADO, CONRADO JR., C.; MERCADO, FRANCISCO; MERCADO, GREGORIO; MERCADO, LUIS P.; MERCADO, OSCAR S.; MERCADO, PATRICIO H.; MERCADO, PRIMITIVO H.; MERCADO, REYNALDO E.; MERCADO, RICARDO B.; MERCADO, ROMEO; MERCADO, VALDEMOR C.; MERCADO, VIRGILIO S.; MERCENA, RICARDO; MERIDA, ELIAS H.; MERLAN, MONTANO; MERLAN, MONTANO C.; METRILLO, NEMESIO M.; MICLAT, EDUARDO R.; MILANES, JOEJIE N.; MILANES, JOSE C.; MILAY, RAYMUNDO P.; MEDINA, MARIO L.; MEDINILLA, MARSHAL M.; MEDIODIA, FRANCIS M.; MEDIODIA, LUCIANO; MEDIOLA, ELY M.; MELECIO, LOLITO M.; MELENDEZ, BENIGNO; MELENDEZ, LUCIANO C.; MELENDEZ, NAPOLEON O.; MELLIANG, ALFREDO; MELO, RENATO J.; MEMIJE, RENE J.; MEMIJE, REYNALDO F.; MEMIJE, RODEL J.; MENDIOLA, FRANCIS; MENDIOLA, MANALO B.; MENDIOLA, SIMPLICIO G.; MENDOZA, AVELINO JR., I.; MENDOZA, BENJAMIN L.; MENDOZA, CLARO M.; MENDOZA, JENRIN; MENDOZA, JOSE C.; MENDOZA, MANOLITO D.; MENDOZA, MIGUEL C.; MENDOZA, RAMIRO A.; MENDOZA, ROMEO T.; MENDOZA, TEOFILO R.; MORATILLO, VICTORINO O.; MORENO, ALFREDO; MORENO, FEDERICO M.; MORTEL, DELFIN M.; MORTEL, VICTORINO JR., A.; MOSUELA, CARLITO C.; MUNDO, JESSIE; MUNDO, RUFINO JR.; MUNOZ, ESPIRITU A.; MUNOZ, IGNACIO E.; MUNOZ, ILDEFONSO V.; MUNOZ, JOSE P.; MUNOZ, ROGELIO; NAJERA, ANGEL C.; NAPIZA, JUANITO N.; NAPIZA, LAMBERTO R.; NAPIZA, SALVADOR; NAPIZA, WILFREDO L.; NAPOLAN, ERNESTO C.; NARCISO, BENJAMIN B.; NARCISO, CARLOS G.; NARCISO, MARCELO A.; MINIMO, ELUETERIO V.; MINIMO, GASPAR V.; MINIMO, HERNANDO G.; MIRALES, ARNALDO I.; MIRANDA, ALFREDO P.; MIRANDA, BENJAMIN M.; MIRANDA, CRESENCIANO; MIRANDA, RUBEN H.; MISA, FELIXBERTO D.; MODESTO, CLAUDIO JR., A.; MOGOL, NOEL M.; MOLINA, ILDEFONSO C.; MOLINA, ROGELIO D.; MONDEJAR, ARMANDO B.; MONDIDO, OSCAR C.; MONTECINES, JUANITO O.; MONTON, GENEROSO D.; MONZON, CELSO N.; MONZON, COSME B.; MORADA, COSME B.; MORADA, RENATO V.; MORADA, RICARDO B.; MORADA, RODOLFO B.; MORADA, RODRIGO; MORAL, NESTOR K.; MORALES, ROLANDO M.; OCAMPO, RODRIGO E.; OCCIANO, ANTONIO B.; OCHOA, LORENZITO H.; OCSON, REYNALDO P.; OCTAVIANO, FRANCISCO; OCTAVIO, CARLITO P.; ODESA, ANTONIO L.; ODESA, BENJAMIN; OFICIAR, GIDEON S.; OLAES, ROMULO W.; OLARTE, GREGORIO E.; OLASCO, ANGEL M.; OLEDAN, LUIS; OLIMBA, GERMAN V.; OLIMBA, ZOSIMO V.; OLINDO, JUAN; OLIVA, MARCIAL B.; OLIVARES, FRANCISCO M.; OLIVIAGA, NOEL T.; ONG, RENATO S.; ONGKIKI, LEOPOLDO M.; OPEZ, VICENTE S.; ORALLO, BENJAMIN V.; NARCISO, MELITON B.; NARCISO, NARCISO L.; NATALIA, EDWIN B.; NATALIA, REYNALDO B.; NATI, CONRADO; NATIVIDAD, SAMUEL N.; NAVARETTE, FERNANDO C.; NAVARRO, MARIANO D.; NAVARRO, PACIFICO JR., D.; NAZARENO, FLORANTE A.; NAZARENO, RESURRECCION D.; NAZARIO, RIZAL B.; NEGRITE, JOSUE D.; NEPOMUCENO, ALFREDO; NEPOMUCENO, ISIDRO M.; NER, VALENTE JR., T.; NG, HERBERT G.; NICOLAS, FLORENCIO; NINON, ERNESTO C.; NOFUENTE, MABINI M.; NOGUERA, RODOLFO M.; NUQUI, AVELINO; OBA, NEMESIO P.; OBANA, MARCIAL L.; OBANDO, LUIS G.; OBIAS, ROMEO M.; OCAMPO, DANILO D.; OCAMPO, EDGARDO; PAGUIO, RICARDO T.; PAJARES, ANTONIO V.; PAKINGGAN, EMILIO C.; PALABRICA, LEANDRO P.; PALASIN, SEBASTIAN D.; PALIMA, ANICETO C.; PALMA, RICARDO M.; PALO, QUINCIANO; PALOMA, ABELARDO E.; PALPAL- LATOC, JOSE A.; PAMATIAN, JOSE C.; PAN, GONZALO; PAN, PORFIRIO C.; PANCHO, JOSE V.; PANGAN, BUENEVIDO; PANGAN, ERNESTO S.; PANGAN, JAVIER M.; PANGANIBAN, FRANCISCO D.; PANGAYAO, FELIPE P.; PANGGAT, REGIDOR M.; PAPA, ANGEL A.; ORBISTA, PEDRO JR.; ORDAS, REYNALDO N.; ORDONEZ, RICARDO; ORIAL, ROMEO S.; ORIGENES, ROMEO L.; ORINE, CIPRIANO T.; ORLANES, EUFROCINO B.; ORTANEZ, DANILO R.; ORTEGA, ANTONIO V.; OSIAS, WILFREDO; OVERA, ABELARDO F.; OWAY, LUIS A.; PA-A, VIRGILIO P.; PAALAN, DAVID; PACANZA, FEDERICO C.; PACHECO, JESUS N.; PACHO, ERNIE; PACIFICO, NAVARRO JR., D.; PADILLA, ALFONSO L.; PADILLA, JESUS N.; PADUA, RUFINO C.; PAEZ, ERLANDO P.; PAGADUAN, BENEDICTO V.; PAGLICAUAN, MARIO M.; PAGSANJAN, DANILO P.; PAGSISIHAN, NUMERIANO; PAGUIO, CARLITO; PEREGRINA, LEOPOLDO M.; PERENO, FERNANDO; PEREZ, ANTOLIANO E.; PEREZ, ANTONIO; PEREZ, ARNEL; PEREZ, CARMELITO L.; PEREZ, DANILO M.; PEREZ, DIONISIO M.; PEREZ, EDUARDO M.; PEREZ, EFREN G.; PEREZ, JIMMY; PEREZ, JUAN; PEREZ, LEON E.; PEREZ, ROMEO E.; PEREZ, ROMULO M.; PEREZ, WILLIAM; PERIGIL, CENON P.; PERINO, FERNANDO G.; PESCO, ALBERTO T.; PIELAGO, ELEODORO A.; PILLAJERA, TOMAS JR., B.; PINEDA, DELMAR P.; PARALA, GORGONIO P.; PARAS, JOEL; PAREN, JUANITO; PARUNGAO, ANTONIO D.; PASAMBA, WALDEMAR S.; PASCUA, EDUARDO C.; PASCUAL, EDMUNDO V.; PASCUAL ISAGANI M.; PASIA, FRANCISCO V.; PASIMIO, JOSE R.; PASION, JOSE V.; PASIONA, IRENEO G.; PASMIO, EDILBERTO JR.; PATAG, ROMEO I.; PAYRA, JOSE I.; PAYRA, LUISITO S.; PEDRIGUERA, FERNANDO; PELLAS, CHESTER; PENA, ANGELITO M.; PENA, ANTERO F.; PENDRAS, DIONISIO M.; PENILLA, CARLOS; PEPITO, LOPE T.; PERALTA, HERMINIO; PERALTA, REYNALDO M.; PERAN, RODRIGO P.; PEREA, FRANCISCO L.; PEREA, JUANITO L.; PEREA, OLIMPIO T.; PUEYO, DANTE; PUEYO, REYNALDO Q.; PULIDO, RODOLFO E.; PUNAY, CORNELIO F.; PUNIO, ALEJANDRO F.; PUNIO, GREGORIO F.; PUNZALAN, WILFREDO D.; PURISIMA, ROGELIO P.; QUEBRAL, JOSELITO C.; QUIABO, ROBERTO C.; QUIMAN, FEDERICO T.; QUINTO, ALFREDO L.; QUINTO, JUANITO M.; QUINTOS, ROMEO; QUIOBO, ROGELIO C.; QUITEVIS, ELPIDIO R.; QUOBO, ROBERTO; RABANO, BENJAMIN D.; RABINO, DESIDERIO R.; RACABO, EDUARDO W.; PINEDA, SALVADOR; PINILI, VICTORIO E.; PINPIN, ELIZALDE C.; PINPIN, FRANCISCO; PINPIN, MODESTO M.; PINPIN, WILFREDO C.; PINTO, ROMEO A.; PITAO, MATEO F.; PLAMERAS, ROGELIO C.; PLANTA, ARIEL I.; PLATA, PACIENCIO M.; POBLETE, ARTURO; POBLETE, DOMINADOR N.; POBLETE, LEONARDO N.; POBLETE, SENECO P.; POLLOS, JAIME; PONDALIS, DOMINGO B.; PONIEG, BERNARDO Q.; PORTUGAL, NORBERTO D.; PORTUGUEZ, LAUREANO C.; PREILA, DOMINADOR; PRIMERO, ANGELITO G.; PRIMO, LEONARDO; PRIVADO, PEDERICO R.; PRUDENTE, BUENAVENTURA; PRUDENTE, BUENAVENTURA; PRUDENTE, CARMELITO; PRUDENTE, CARMELITO; RAVELAS, RODRIGO; RAVELAS, ROGELIO R.; RAVELAS, TEODORICO R.; RAVELAS, VICENTE F.; RAYA, ROMEO S.; RAYMUNDO, RICARDO E.; RAYMUNDO, WILFREDO D.; REBONG, ALBERT E.; RECOLASO, ERNESTO E.; RECOLIZADO, BIENVENIDO B.; REDAZA, ALBERTO M.; REGULTO, QUIRICO; REJUSO, ARTHUR; RELLAMA, RAUL D.; RELLAMA, TORIBIO M.; RELLAMA, TORIBIO M.; RELLOSA, JAIME; RELOVA, CASIANO M.; REMO, ILUMINADO S.; REMOQUILLO, EUGENIO A.; REMOQUILLO, RODOLFO A.; RAMELO, JOSELITO F.; RAMIREZ, EUGENIO P.; RAMIREZ, FERNANDO; RAMIREZ, ILDEFONSO R.; RAMIREZ, LEO; RAMIREZ, LIRIO C.; RAMIREZ, LITO C.; RAMIREZ, LUIS A.; RAMIREZ, RICARDO G.; RAMIREZ, RODOLFO; RAMOS, ALBERTO M.; RAMOS, ANSELMO C.; RAMOS, EMETERIO P.; RAMOS, FROILAN M.; RAMOS, JOSE N.; RAMOS, LEONCIO; RAMOS, MANOLITO V.; RAMOS, NOMER M.; RAMOS, ROQUE A.; RAMOS, TOBIAS R.; RAMOS, OSCAR B.; RANADA, JOSE G.; RANADA, MARCELO; RANADA, PEPITO C.; RANGEL, PONCIANO P.; RAQUEDAN, REYNALDO T.; RAVELAS, FEDERICO; RAVELAS, LARRY; RAVELAS, LORENZO D.; RAVELAS, MANUEL F.; REYES, ROMEO B.; REYES, ROMEO S.; REYES, ROMULO M.; REYES, SERGIO L.; REYES, SISENANDO P.; REYES, SOLOMON B.; REYES, VICENTE G.; REYNOSO, EUGENIO F.; REYNOSO, LINDSEY F.; RICAZA, VIRGILIO G.; RICO, ANTONIO F.; RICO, ERNESTO F.; RICO, FERNANDO M.; RIETA, EMMANUEL S.; RIETA, RICARDO V.; RIETA, RODELIO G.; RIETA, RODELIO JR., V.; RIVADA, CARLOS A.; RIVERA, BENITO JR.; REMOTO, FIDEL O.; REMOTO, JESUS O.; RENTOZA, GERARDO; RESPALL, LUCIEN M.; RESVALLES, ISIAS; RETANAN, GAUDENCIO R.; RETENER, TOMAS B.; REY, REDENTOR C.; REYES, ABNER M.; REYES, ALBERTO L.; REYES, ALFREDO S.; REYES, ALVIN C.; REYES, AMABLE S.; REYES, BENEDICTO F.; REYES, CESAR C.; REYES, ERNESTO F.; REYES, FLORENCIO; REYES, GREGORIO B.; REYES, JACINTO JR., M.; REYES, JOSE A.; REYES, JOSE C.; REYES, MAXIMO; REYES, NEPTALI M.; REYES, NESTOR E.; REYES, PABLO; REYES, RIGOR Y.; REYES, RIZALINO R.; REYES, ROGELIO G.; REYES, ROLANDO G.; RONQUILO, REYNOSO P.; ROQUE, AVELINO M.; ROQUE, GERARDO R.; ROQUILLO, QUIRINO; ROSALES, ALFREDO E.; ROSALES, ANGEL P.; ROSALES, ARMANDO E.; ROSALES, MARIO E.; ROSALES, PIDO; ROSALES, RAMON M.; ROSARIO, VIRGILIO L.; ROVELOS, BERNARDINO; RUBIO, WILFREDO; RUBIO, WILFREDO; SA-ANOY, RAMON A.; SABATIN, HONORIO P.; SABELITA, SANTIAGO L.; SABINO, MENANDRO L.; SACDALAN, REYNALDO P.; SACRO, ROMEO A.; RIVERA, BENJAMIN M.; RIVERA, JOSE M.; RIVERA, NILO S.; RIVERA, ROGELIO C.; RIZAL, NAZARIO B.; ROBALE, EDGARDO C.; ROBILLOS, BERNARDO J.; ROBLES, LEO B.; ROBLES, PABLO A.; ROBLES, RUBEN; ROBLEZA, JOSE C.; ROBLEZA, RODOLFO; ROBLEZA, RODRIGO C.; ROBLEZA, RUSTICO C.; ROCABO, EDUARDO; RODRIGUEZ, ANTONIO R.; RODRIGUEZ, BERNARDO R.; RODRIGUEZ, ELIGIO T.; RODRIGUEZ, HENRY A.; RODRIGUEZ, REYNALDO B.; RODRIGUEZ, ROMEO B.; ROMALES, EDGARDO H.; ROMEO, ALMONTE; ROMERO, ABAD ARTURO C.; RONA, SALVADOR T.; RONDILLA, ERNESTO J.; RONQUILLO, ELIAS; RONQUILLO, ELISE; RONQUILLO, LUIS V.; RONQUILLO, RODOLFO C.; RONQUILLO, SEGUNDINO L.; SANOHAN, FRANCISCO F.; SANOZA, ESTEBAN B.; SANSALIAN, ARTURO A.; SANSALIAN, EDUARDO C.; SANSALIAN, LITO; SANSALIAN, MARIO A.; SANSALIAN, RAFAEL A.; SANTA, ADRIANO; SANTIAGO, APOLONIO P.; SANTIAGO, CELSO G.; SANTIAGO, GIOVANNI D.; SANTIAGO, JOSELITO S.; SANTIAGO, RIZALINO T.; SANTIAGO, SERGIO; SANTIAGO, ULDARICO P.; SANTOS, ARTURO L.; SANTOS, DOMINADOR JR., R.; SANTOS, EDILBERTO G.; SADDI, EMILIO S.; SAGUI, ALEXANDER T.; SALAZAR, EDGARDO; SALGATAR, PEDRO L.; SALONGA, EDGARDO; SALONGA, HERMINIO P.; SALTA, AVELINO R.; SALTA, BENJAMIN P.; SALTA, ERNESTO P.; SALTA, TRINIDAD P.; SALVADOR, CARLITO R.; SALVADOR, DOMINGO I.; SALVADOR, ERNESTO I.; SALVADOR, MELECIO I.; SALVADOR, ROGELIO N.; SALVADOR, ROLANDO I.; SAMPARADA, JOSE; SAN JOSE, NEMESIO S.; SAN JOSE, RICARDO S.; SAN JUAN, EDGARDO I.; SAN MATEO, NUMERIANO; SAN PEDRO, ERNESTO Z.; SAN PEDRO, RODOLFO Z.; SAN PEDRO, ROGELIO Z.; SANCHA, ADRIANO V.; SANCHA, GERONIMO M.; SANCHEZ, ARTEMIO B.; SANCHEZ, FRANCISCO F.; SANCHEZ, FRANKLIN G.; SANCHEZ, NICASIO; SIMBAJON, ARTHUR B.; SALVADOR, DOMINGO SR.; SOGUI, ALEXANDER B.; SOLANO, DOMINGO; SOLANTE, JOSELITO C.; SOLANTE, PAQUITO E.; SOLETO, NORBERTO; SOLIMAN, ERDY M.; SOLIMAN, FRANCISCO M.; SOLIS, CARLITO M.; SOLIS, CONRADO III G.; SOLIS, CONRADO JR., A.; SOLIS, EDGARDO; SOLIS, ERNESTO M.; SOLIS, ISAGANI M.; SOMERA, DEMETRIO R.; SORIANO, NICANOR V.; SORIANO, PROCESO M.; SORONO, HERMOGENES S.; SANTOS, EFREN S.; SANTOS, GABRIEL S.; SANTOS, JOSE H.; SANTOS. JUANITO; SANTOS, LUISITO B.; SANTOS, LUISITO B.; SANTOS, NICANOR; SANTOS, ORLANDO S.; SANTOS, RENATO D.; SANTOS, WILFREDO; SAPUYOT, MIGUEL; SARMIENTO, RICARDO M.; SARMIENTO, SILVESTRE; SATRE, MAXIMO JR., L.; SAYAS, RICARDO; SENA, JAIME M.; SENO, QUIRINO O.; SERA, ROBERTO; SERNA, JULIAN G.; SERQUINA, ALEX S.; SERRA, DOMINADOR; SERRANO, EMILIANO B.; SERRANO, RICARDO; SERVAN, FILOMENO M.; SIDRO, ROMEO B.; SIGUA, FERNANDO M.; SILANG, AMADO M.; SILANG, FAUSTINO D.; SILVA, ANICETO G.; SILVA, EDGARDO M.; SILVERIO, ARCADIO JR., C.; SILVERIO, ROLANDO; TANGUINOO, PETER; TAPIA, TAGUMPAY R.; TAPIA, VICENTE JR., R.; TARAYA, ALBERTO P.; TARIMAN, ROMEO T.; TARUC, FERMIN; TARUC, FERMISO JR.; TARUC, WILLIAM; TATING, ROBERTO T.; TEBELIN, TEODULO O.; TEMPLO, HENRY; TEMPLO, LEVY S.; TEMPLO, TEDDY S.; TEMPROSA, MENANDRO P.; TEOSECO, ROMAN L.; TESALONA, BAYANI T.; TIAMSIM, IRENEO; SORONO, MELQUIADES S.; SOTTO, EDUARDO L.; STA. MARIA, ERNESTO G.; STELLA, VICENTE D.; STO. DOMINGO, ALBERTO; SUAMEN, RAFAEL; SUANSING, ROLANDO C.; SUAZO, ANTONIO B.; SULTAN, RODOLFO T.; SUNGLAO, MARIO; SUPANG, FELIMON R.; TABADA, JESUS C.; TABLAIN, VENANCIO; TABLAN, JULIO E.; TABLAN, PASTOR E.; TABOSO, AMADO M.; TAFALLA, ADOLFO D.; TAGORDA, ANASTACIO JR., J.; TAGUINOD, BENJAMIN JR.; TALATAC, ISAIAS; TALATO, GAUDENCIO M.; TALIBSAO, MAXIMINO H.; TALISAY, NAVAS; TALUSIK, FELICISIMO T.; TALUTO, GAUDENCIO M.; TAMAYO, JAIME C.; TAMPELIX, MACARIO L.; TAN, JOESUS; TANAG, ELENO C.; TANAG, LEORINO C.; TANGUIA, AUGUSTO B.; UNTALAN, WILFREDO V.; UNTALAN, WILLIE; URSOLINO, SERGIO A.; VALDERAMA, ANTONIO T.; VALDERAMA, RAMON T.; VALDEZ, ROGELIO R.; VALENCIANO, NILO G.; VALERA, ANICETO A.; VALERO, MAXIMO A.; VALES, AUGUSTO L.; VALLADA, AURELIO S.; VALLAR, FEDERICO P.; VALLARTA, TOMAS JR., L.; VARGAS, ISAIAS V.; VASQUEZ, EDGARDO C.; VEGA, ABRAHAM; VELASQUEZ, BENJAMIN; VELASQUEZ, CONSTANTINO B.; TIAMZON, RODOLFO S.; TIBUS, NICO V.; TIBUS, SAMSON V.; TIO, NORBERTO B.; TIOSECO, FIDEL L.; TIPOSO, LEONILO; TIU, JUAN JR., G.; TOLENTINO, AMADO S.; TOLENTINO, ANGEL G.; TOLENTINO, ARNEL T.; TOLENTINO, BIENVENIDO S.; TOLENTINO, DOMINGO G.; TOLENTINO, MARIO M.; TORRALBA, FELIPE; TORRALBA, GERONIMO M.; TORRES, BENEDICTO; TORRES, JOVITO V.; TORRES, MAXIMIANO Y.; TORRES, NEMESIO; TORRES, RAYMUNDO S.; TRA, ROGELIO S.; TRAVISON, RODOLFO S.; TRESVALLES, ISIAS V.; TRIAS, ANTONIO; TRIAS, FRANCISCO G.; TRIAS, RENATO S.; TRILLANES, RENE M.; TUAZON, GAVIN U.; TUNGCOL, BENEDICTO; UBALDO, PLACIDO C.; UMALI, FRANCISCO A.; UNIDA, SIMPLICIDO; UNIDAD, REYNALDO R.; VILLAHERMOSA, DOMINGO O.; VILLALOBOS, ROLANDO C.; VILLALUZ, ANTONIO; VILLANUEVA, CARLITO; VILLANUEVA, DANILO A.; VILLANUEVA, DANILO N.; VILLANUEVA, ELITO S.; VILLANUEVA, ERNESTO N.; VILLANUEVA, MANUEL N.; VILLARBA, ANGEL; VILLAREAL, JOSE V.; VILLARINO, FELICISIMO T.; VILLARINO, JUANITO P.; VILLARINO, LEONARDO; VILLAROSA, FRANCISCO M.; ABANTO, NICK; VELASQUEZ, ELPIDIO B.; VELASQUEZ, MARIO M.; VERDADERO, EUGENIO C.; VERDAN, OSCAR A.; VERGARA, ALFREDO S.; VERGARA, BIENVENIDO; VERGARA, IGNACIO P.; VERGARA, LEGORIO S.; VERGARA, PEDRO; VERNAL, VICTORIO; VERNES, MARIANO N.; VERZONILLA, RUFINO V.; VERZOSA, RAMON R.; VIAR, GUILLERMO E.; VICMUNDO, FELICITO P.; VICTORIA, DELFIN V.; VICTORIA, GILBERT; VICTORIA, JUBERT D.; VICTORIANO, ALFREDO; VICTORIANO, AUGUSTO; VICTORIANO, AUGUSTO; VICTORIANO, HERMANE; VIDALLON , TEOFILO P.; VIERNES, SABINO N.; VIERNES, MARIANO N.; VILLAROMAN, RAFAEL D.; VILLA, JESUS J.; VILLABLANCO, JOVEN; VILLAFLORES, EDGARDO G.; VILLAFLORES, FRANCISCO; VILLAGERA, CEFERINO; VILLAHERMOSA, ALEX; VILLANUEVA, ROGELIO R.; VILLAR, ALFREDO A.; VILLAR, NEPHTALI D.; VILLAR, RAUL R.; VO, HERMINIO V.; YANGLO, ALEJANDRO M.; YLAYA, GALILEO C.; YNGENTE, VICENTE D.; YULO, BUENAVENTURA M.; YUVIENGCO, MEYNARDO L.; ZALAVARIA, CARLOS R.; ZAMORA, PRIMO B.; ZARA, FRANCISCO; ZULUETA, JOSE B.; ZUNIGA, ORO C.; ACUPAN, JUANITO; ACUPAN, ROMEO; ALDEGUER, JAIME B.; BAS, FERNANDO; BAUTISTA, LEONARDO; BENITEZ, JOVITO N.; BLANCO, ALBERTO B.; CIFRA, HERNAN N.; ELISAN, RISTITUTO; ENGON, VICENTE; HERMOSO, ROBERTO; LOZA, CRISOSTOMO; VIAR, ROMEO E. 1,petitioners,
vs.
HON. COURT OF APPEALS, BROWN & ROOT INTERNATIONAL, INC. (now Kellog Brown & Root), ASIA INTERNATIONAL BUILDERS CORP., and NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, respondents.
D E C I S I O N
NACHURA, J.:
The numerous claimants herein, 2,1232 overseas Filipino workers, the enormous amount of their claim, US$609,695,262.42, the more than two decades of their protracted crusade before the labor tribunal and the courts, and the voluminous records that have accumulated make this case appear to be extremely contentious and inordinately complicated. But, then, as the commonest of clichés goes, appearances can be truly deceiving.
Before the Court is a petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court assailing the May 31, 2004 Decision3 of the Court of Appeals (CA) in CA-G.R. SP No. 77272 and the July 14, 2005 Resolution4 denying the motion for reconsideration thereof.
This petition had its origins in 1984 when numerous claimants led by Bienvenido M. Cadalin, Rolando M. Amul and Donato B. Evangelista instituted a class suit with the Philippine Overseas Employment Administration (POEA) for money claims, among which are the benefits provided by Amiri Decree No. 23 of Bahrain, Retirement and Savings Plan benefits, etc., arising from their recruitment by respondent Asia International Builders Corp. (AIBC) and employment by Brown & Root International, Inc. (BRII).5 Several other complaints were filed by other groups of claimants with the same money claims.6 The said POEA cases, L-84-06-555, L-85-10-777, L-85-10-779 and L-86-05-460, were consequently consolidated. On January 30, 1989, the POEA Administrator rendered his decision awarding US$824,652.44 in favor of only 324 claimants.7
On appeal, the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) promulgated its September 2, 1991 Resolution disposing of the cases as follows:
WHEREFORE, premises considered, the Decision of the POEA in these consolidated cases is modified to the extent and in accordance with the following dispositions:
1. The claims of the 94 complainants identified and listed in Annex "A" hereof are dismissed for having prescribed;
2. Respondents AIBC and Brown & Root are hereby ordered, jointly and severally, to pay the 149 complainants, identified and listed in Annex "B" hereof, the peso equivalent, at the time of payment, of the total amount in US dollars indicated opposite their respective names;
3. The awards given by the POEA to the 19 complainants classified and listed in Annex "C" hereof, who appear to have worked elsewhere than in Bahrain are hereby set aside.
4. All claims other than those indicated in Annex "B", including those for overtime work and favorably granted by the POEA, are hereby dismissed for lack of substantial evidence in support thereof or are beyond the competence of this Commission to pass upon.
In addition, this Commission, in the exercise of its powers and authority under Article 218 (c) of the Labor Code, as amended by R.A. 6715, hereby directs Labor Arbiter Fatima J. Franco of this Commission to summon parties, conduct hearings and receive evidence, as expeditiously as possible, and thereafter submit a written report to this Commission (First Division) of the proceedings taken, regarding the claims of the following:
(a) complainants identified and listed in Annex "D" attached and made an integral part of this Resolution, whose claims were dismissed by the POEA for lack of proof of employment in Bahrain (these complainants numbering 683, are listed in pages 13 to 23 of the decision of the POEA, subject of the appeals) and,
(b) complainants identified and listed in Annex "E" attached and made an integral part of this Resolution, whose awards decreed by the POEA, to Our mind, are not supported by substantial evidence.
SO ORDERED.8
Considering that all the motions for reconsideration of the NLRC decision were denied, the parties elevated the consolidated cases to us via petitions for certiorari under Rule 65, G.R. Nos. 104776, 104911-14 and 105029-32, which we likewise consolidated.9
On December 5, 1994, the Court rendered its Decision dismissing the three consolidated petitions after finding no grave abuse of discretion on the part of the NLRC.10
With the dismissal of the certiorari petitions, the NLRC went on to implement its September 2, 1991 Resolution. Pursuant to the second portion of the said resolution (dealing with the claimants under Annexes "D" and "E"), the NLRC, through its labor arbiters, conducted formal hearings, mandatory conferences and conciliation hearings.11 In the course of the proceedings, which lasted from 1997 to 2001, alleged similarly-situated claimants, 19 batches in all, joined the cases through a Submission and Manifestational Motion dated July 7, 2000.12 Compromise agreements with AIBC and BRII were also entered into by several groups of claimants.13
In a Compliance and Manifestation dated August 30, 2001,14 the counsel for the claimants, Atty. Gerardo A. Del Mundo, submitted 18 names of remaining claimants under Annexes "D" and "E" of the September 2, 1991 Resolution, who opted to continue with the litigation until its final resolution. These 18 were joining the 1,297 claimants for recovery of actual and other forms of damages and the 1,690 claimants for recovery of retirement and savings benefits.15
Nevertheless, in disposing of the case, the NLRC considered only 1,975 claimants for retirement and savings benefit, and 1,223 out of the 1,975 claimants for benefits under the Amiri Decree.16 Thus, on December 3, 2002, the NLRC rendered its decision17 granting all the said claims. The fallo of the decision reads:
WHEREFORE, judgment is hereby rendered ordering respondents Brown & Root International, Inc. (BRII) and Asia International Builders Corporation (AIBC) to pay, jointly and solidarily, all the complainants/OFWs their respective monetary claims in the total amount of SIX HUNDRED NINE MILLION SIX HUNDRED NINETY-FIVE THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED SIXTY-TWO U.S. DOLLARS & 42/100 (US$609,695,262.42) as of this date, as indicated in the following Annexes to this Decision which shall form as, and hereby made, integral parts hereof, to wit:
1. Annex "A" in the total amount of US$123,389,048.48 consisting of all the claims of six hundred sixty-five (665) complainants identified and listed thereunder who shall each receive the full amount in United States Dollars indicated opposite their respective names or its peso equivalent at the time of actual payment as and for Friday/Holiday Pay [Overtime], Annual Leaving Differential [V. L.], Leaving Indemnity, Unexpired Portion of Contract, Travel Reserved Fund (T.R.F.), Hazard Pay (100% B.S.), and U.S. Labor Law EEOC plus legal interest of six percent (6%) per annum for the period from the date the employee was illegally dismissed from service until the decision becomes final and executory, after which time, the interest rate shall be twelve percent (12%) per annum until the amount due are actually paid or satisfied;
2. Annex "B" in the total amount of US$110,164,456.32 consisting of all the claims of five hundred fifty-eight (558) complainants identified and listed thereunder who shall each receive the full amount in United States Dollars indicated opposite their respective names or its peso equivalent at the time of actual payment, as and for Friday/Holiday Pay [Overtime], Annual Leaving Differential [V.L.], Leaving Indemnity, Unexpired Portion of Contract, Travel Reserved Fund (T.R.F.), Hazard Pay (100% B.S.), and U.S. Labor Law EEOC plus legal interest of six percent (6%) per annum for the period from the date the employee was illegally dismissed from service until the decision becomes final and executory, after which time, the interest rate shall be twelve percent (12%) per annum until the amounts due are actually paid or satisfied;
3. Annex "C" in the total amount of US$3,532,005.00 consisting of all the claims of one thousand nine hundred seventy-five (1,975) complainants identified and listed thereunder who shall each receive the full amount in United States Dollars indicated opposite their respective names or its peso equivalent at the time of actual payment, as and for their R & S or retirement pay benefits plus legal interest of six percent (6%) per annum for the period from the date the employee was illegally dismissed from service until the decision becomes final and executory, after which time, the interest rate shall be twelve percent (12%) per annum until the amounts due are actually paid or satisfied;
plus legal interests computed at US$256,032,910.58 as of this date.
Respondents BRII and AIBC are further hereby adjudged and ordered to pay, jointly and solidarily, each of the complainants in Annexes "A" and "B" the sum of US$50,000.00, or a total amount of US$61,150,000.00 as and by way of moral and exemplary damages.
Further, respondents are ordered to pay, jointly and severally, attorney’s fees equivalent to ten percent (10%) of all the foregoing monetary awards, or in the total amount of US$55,426,842.04.
All other claims are hereby dismissed for lack of merit.
SO ORDERED.18
Despite the favorable decision, petitioners, on one hand, filed a partial motion for reconsideration asking the NLRC to award additional benefits.19 On the other hand, AIBC and BRII filed their separate motions for reconsideration on January 3, 2003 and January 16, 2003, respectively.20
Ruling in the main that it had no jurisdictional authority to award the claims, the NLRC in its May 7, 2003 Resolution21 reversed its earlier decision and disposed of the case as follows:
WHEREFORE, Our December 3, 2002 decision is set aside. Judgment is hereby rendered:
1. Granting the twin motions for reconsideration of BRII and AIBC and thereby:
a) treating, the complaint of the 149 complainants listed in Annex "B" of the September 2, 1991 resolution of the Commission as closed and terminated due to the satisfaction of the awards thereon;
b) treating, [except for the 19 claimants as earlier discussed] the complaint of those listed in Annexes "D" and "E" of the same September 2, 1991 resolution as closed and terminated in view of the approved settlement reached by the parties and the full satisfaction of the considerations thereon;
c) directing respondents BRII and AIBC to solidarily pay: (1) Dominador P. Serra; (2) Felix M. Diaz; (3) Leo B. Robles; and (4) Arturo V. Macaraig the peso equivalent of the same benefits awarded to those listed in Annex "B" of Our September 2, 1991 resolution;
d) directing respondents BRII and AIBC to solidarily pay each of the following fifteen (15) complainants:
1. Amado Aloria
2. Wilfredo Arica
3. Rodolfo B. Celis
4. Felix J. Coronel
5. Generoso Del Rosario
6. Pedro G. De Leon
7. Armando Lucero
8. Alfredo Macalino
9. Eduardo W. Racabo
10. Ruben Robels
11. Rodolfo Robleza
12. Vicente Bagting
13. Felix Coronel
14. Carlito Espino
15. Romeo Macaraig
the peso equivalent of US$500.00, the same settlement amount paid by BRII to the other complainants listed in Annexes "D" and "E" of Our September 2, 1991 resolution;
2. Denying complainants’ December 20, 2002 partial motion for reconsideration, for being without merit.
SO ORDERED.22
Petitioners promptly filed a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 before the CA, which was docketed as CA-G.R. SP No. 77272.23 Finding, however, that the NLRC did not act whimsically, capriciously or in wanton disregard of the law when it issued the May 7, 2003 Resolution, the appellate court upheld the same on May 31, 2004,24 thus:
UPON THE VIEW WE TAKE OF THIS CASE, THUS, the instant petition is DISMISSED for lack of merit and the assailed decision dated May 7, 2003 AFFIRMED. Without costs.
SO ORDERED.25
On July 14, 2005, the CA further denied the two motions for reconsideration filed by petitioners and another claimant, Amado S. Tolentino.26
From the said ruling of the appellate court, two petitions for review on certiorari under Rule 45 were filed before this Court: (1) the instant case, G.R. No. 168923 filed by alleged 2,123 claimants; and (2) G.R. No. 168925 filed by claimant Tolentino. This Court, nonetheless, denied Tolentino’s petition on November 7, 2005, for his failure to sufficiently show that the CA committed any reversible error in the challenged decision.27 An entry of judgment was later issued on February 21, 2006.28
Left, then, for resolution of the Court is this petition,29 in which the petitioners raise the following grounds:
A. WHETHER THE RESPONDENT COURT OF APPEALS ERRED IN DENYING THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION AND DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR LACK OF MERIT DESPITE THE GROSS FAILURE OF PRIVATE RESPONDENTS TO FILE WITHIN THE 10-DAY PERIOD THEIR MOTIONS FOR RECONSIDERATION, AND NON-COMPLIANCE OF THE MANDATORY REQUIREMENT OF FILING SUPERSEDEAS BOND IN THE AMOUNT OF US$609 MILLION OR ACTUAL AWARDS IN VIOLATION OF LAW AND JURISPRUDENCE.
B. WHETHER THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS ERRED IN SETTING ASIDE THE AWARDS GRANTED IN THE NLRC DECISION OF DECEMBER 03, 2002 AND AFFIRMING THE QUESTIONED NLRC RESOLUTION OF MAY 07, 2003 REVERSING THE FINAL AND EXECUTORY JUDGMENT WITHOUT OR IN EXCESS OF ITS JURISDICTION COMMITTED WITH GRAVE ABUSE OF DISCRETION AMOUNTING TO LACK OR EXCESS OF JURISDICTION NOT IN ACCORD WITH LAW AND APPLICABLE DECISIONS OF THE SUPREME COURT.
C. THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS ERRED IN HOLDING AS APPLICABLE THE DOCTRINE OF FINALITY OF THE NLRC DECISION OF SEPTEMBER 2, 1991 SINCE THERE WAS NO FINALITY YET CONSIDERING THE REMAND AND RE-OPENING OF THE CASES MANDATED BY THE SAME NLRC DECISION OF SEPTEMBER 2, 1991.
D. THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS GRAVELY ERRED IN GIVING CREDENCE TO THE THEORY OF THE PRIVATE RESPONDENTS THAT PETITIONERS’ ACTION ARE BARRED BY PRESCRIPTION.
E. THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS COMMITTED A GRAVE ABUSE OF DISCRETION WHEN IT DISREGARDED THE LAW AND JURISPRUDENCE ON ILLEGAL QUITCLAIMS AND WAIVERS.
F. THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS COMMITTED A GRAVE ABUSE OF DISCRETION AMOUNTING TO OR IN EXCESS OF JURISDICTION WHEN IT DEPARTED FROM THE ACCEPTED AND USUAL COURSE OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF RESOLVING ON THE MERITS THE CLAIMS OF 1,975 AWARDEES AND OTHER SIMILARLY SITUATED PETITIONERS WHO HAVE VALID AND BINDING CLAIMS AGAINST THE PRIVATE RESPONDENTS.30
The pivotal issue for resolution in this case is whether the alleged 2,12331 petitioners are entitled to their claim of US$609,695,262.42.
We rule in the negative. However, we partially grant the petition insofar as it relates to the 149 claimants listed in Annex "B" of the September 2, 1991 Resolution of the NLRC.
Ruling first on the procedural issues raised, we find as flimsy the petitioners’ contention that the December 3, 2002 NLRC Decision granting their claims has already attained finality as no timely motion for reconsideration was filed and no bond was posted by the private respondents. The records reveal that while AIBC’s motion for reconsideration was filed one day late, BRII timely filed its motion on January 16, 2003;32 thus, insofar as the latter is concerned, the NLRC decision has not yet attained finality. This fact notwithstanding, the NLRC, in the light of our ruling in Surigao del Norte Electric Cooperative v. National Labor Relations Commission,33 has ample authority to entertain tardy appeals if the circumstances of the case warrant liberality considering the amount and the issues involved.34 This principle applies with greater force to this case because what is involved is not an appeal but a mere motion for reconsideration. The NLRC, in the interest of due process, can very well disregard technicalities of procedure.35
As regards the appeal bond, we agree with private respondents’ contention that neither Article 223 of the Labor Code, as amended, nor the Rules of Procedure of the NLRC requires the posting of a bond for the Commission to entertain a motion for reconsideration of its decision. An appeal bond is required only for the perfection of an appeal of a Labor Arbiter’s decision involving a monetary award.36
Proceeding now to the meat of the instant controversy, we find that the NLRC, except with respect to the aforementioned 149 claimants listed in Annex "B" of the September 2, 1991 Resolution, did not abuse its discretion, much more gravely, when it reconsidered its December 3, 2002 Decision and denied the claims of the rest of the petitioners. At this juncture, we emphasize that certiorari under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court will lie only when grave abuse of discretion or an act without or in excess of jurisdiction on the part of the labor tribunals is clearly shown.37 It is incumbent, then, for petitioners to establish before the appellate court that the labor tribunal capriciously and whimsically exercised its judgment as would amount to lack of jurisdiction, or that it exercised its power in an arbitrary or despotic manner by reason of passion or personal hostility, and that its abuse of discretion was so patent and gross as to constitute an evasion of positive duty enjoined or a refusal to act at all in contemplation of law.38
Further, deference to the expertise acquired by the labor tribunal and the limited scope granted the Court in the exercise of certiorari jurisdiction restrain any probe into the correctness of the NLRC’s evaluation of evidence.39 Oft-repeated is the rule that appellate courts accord the factual findings of the labor tribunal not only respect but also finality when supported by substantial evidence,40 as in the instant case. Thus, we find no reversible error in the CA’s ruling affirming the NLRC’s decision, with the exception again of the aforesaid 149 claimants.
1. AALAGOS, Rogelio
2. ABACAN, Gerardo M.
3. ABAD, Nicanor
4. ABADE, Ricardo B.
5. ABAN, Jose
6. ABANDO, Alex B.
7. ABANDO, Gregorio
8. ABANES, Andres A.
9. ABANES, Martin M.
10. ABANES, Reynaldo A.
11. ABANES, Rodrigo M.
12. ABANO, Jovenal A.
13. ABANTE, Ariel B.
14. ABANTE, Eduardo
15. ABANTO, Gregorio M.
16. ABANTO, Nick
17. ABARCA, Felmon M.
18. ABARQUEZ, Emigdion N.
19. ABARRO, Jose H.
20. ABARRO, Josefino Q.
21. ABELANIO, Celso S.
22. ABELLA, Herminio V.
23. ABESTANO, Miguel O.
24. ABILA, Fernando J.
25. ABOY, Ernesto M.
26. ABRIL, Modesto M.
27. ABUBO, Rodrigo G.
28. ABULON, Julian V.
29. ABUSTAN, Jose Jr., B.
30. ACAIN, Felipe C.
31. ACAN, Norberto G.
32. ACERES, Dante C.
33. ACERO, Danny
34. ACHA, Rogelio B.
35. ACLAN, Efren
36. ACO, Rogelio A.
37. ACOJIDO, Reynaldo S.
38. ACTA, Leowilin A.
39. ACUEZA, Eugenio C.
40. ACUNA, Manuel T.
41. ACUPAN, Antonio
42. ACUPAN, Benito
43. ACUPAN, Benjamin D.
44. ACUPAN, Eduardo B.
45. ACUPAN, Emmanuel
46. ACUPAN, Juanito P.
47. ACUPAN, Maximiano A.
48. ACUPAN, Reynaldo C.
49. ACUPAN, Romeo C.
50. ACUPAN, Solano
51. ACUPAN, Vicente A.
52. ADAJAR, Cesar L.
53. ADALIN, Gregorio
54. ADALLA, Gregorio
55. ADANA, Manuel P.
56. ADAWAG, Angel G.
57. ADAWAG, Carlito
58. ADAWAG, Cresenciano
59. ADAWAG, Noel P.
60. ADAWAG, Teodulfo
61. ADRAYAN, Alfredo B.
62. AGAPITO, Generoso M.
63. AGNE, Bernardo R.
64. AGNE, Florentino R.
65. AGNE, Rizalino R.
66. AGUADO, Aniceto A.
67. AGUBA, Restituto A.
68. AGUDO, Guillermo R.
69. AGUDO, Quiterio R.
70. AGUE, Florentino R.
71. AGUILA, Benjamin G.
72. AGUILA, Bernardo F.
73. AGUILA, Josue G.
74. AGUILA, Vicente G.
75. AGUILAR, Esperidion T.
76. AGUILAR, Francisco
77. AGUINALDO, Manuel P.
78. AGUIRRE, Dante
79. AGUIRRE, Herminio J.
80. AGUSTIN, Galicano D.
81. ALABAY, Agripino V.
82. ALABAY, Nestor M.
83. ALAGAD, Alfonso
84. ALAGAD, Bernardo F.
85. ALAGAD, Fernando
86. ALBERTO, Gonzalo Jr., D.
87. ALBINO, Septimo O.
88. ALBO, Alejandro R.
89. ALBURO, Orlando
90. ALCAIRA, Alexander R.
91. ALCALDE, Rolando A.
92. ALCANTARA, Conrado Luis D.
93. ALCANTARA, Jaime B.
94. ALCANTARA, Jesus M.
95. ALCANTARA, Lamberto Q.
96. ALCANTARA, Marianito Jr., J.
97. ALCANTARA, Mario C.
98. ALDEGUER, Federico Jr., T.
99. ALDEGUER, Jaime B.
100. ALDIANO, Ponciano C.
101. ALDOVER, Alfredo L.
102. ALDOVER, Bencio L.
103. ALEA, Diosdado A.
104. ALEGADA, Wilfredo
105. ALEJANDRE, Alejandro
106. ALEJANDRE, Benjamin A.
107. ALEJANDRE, Hilarion F.
108. ALEJANDRE, Maximino R.
109. ALEJANDRE, Noel P.
110. ALEJANDRINO, Anselmo V.
111. ALEJANDRINO, Enrico I.
112. ALEJANDRO, Benjamin
113. ALEJANDRO, Eduardo L.
114. ALEJANDRO, Eulalio V.
115. ALEJANDRO, Maximino
116. ALFECHE, Inocencio V.
117. ALFREDO, Teodolfo M.
118. ALHAMBRA, Cezar A.
119. ALINDAY, Tomas C.
120. ALMENAR, Alberto Z.
121. ALMERO, Ernesto C.
122. ALMONTE, Romeo B.
123. ALMONTE, Virgilio B.
124. ALONZO, Arnaldo
125. ALORIA, Amado C.
126. ALVAREZ, Alexander
127. ALVAREZ, Apolinario A.
128. ALVAREZ, Camilo
129. ALVAREZ, Manuel C.
130. ALVAREZ, Pablo C.
131. ALVAREZ, Raul A.
132. ALVAREZ, Rolando S.
133. AMA, Pafico
134. AMBAL, Edmundo G.
135. AMBAL, Hermogenes R.
136. AMBROCIO, Benjamin R.
137. AMBUNAN, Julian P.
138. AMISTAD, Martin G.
139. AMORES, Carlos
140. AMPIL, Jose R.
141. AMUL, Rolando
142. AMUL, Sebastian B.
143. AMURAO, Crispulo Jr., C.
144. AMURAO, Crispulo Sr., T.
145. AMUTAN, Fernando L.
146. AMUTAN, Moises
147. ANANDING, Amorsolo S.
148. ANCHETA, Bernard P.
149. ANCHETA, Teotinio O.
150. ANDAL, Danilo L.
151. ANDAMO, Carlos P.
152. ANDAYA, Joaquin S.
153. ANDOY, Leopoldo R.
154. ANDRADA, Dan F.
155. ANDRADA, Simeon
156. ANDULAN, Reynaldo B.
157. ANG, Nestor V.
158. ANGELES, Geronimo H.
159. ANGLO, Antonio T.
160. ANI, Jeoffrey
161. ANICETE, Beltranico S.
162. ANICETE, Romeo S.
163. ANIS, Bartolome B.
164. ANSALDO, Jose B.
165. ANTILLON, Elinio P.
166. ANTIPONO, Armando B.
167. ANTONIO, Larry T.
168. APILADO, Antonio
169. APILADO, Arturo P.
170. APOLINARIO, Francisco
171. APOLINARIO, Pepito
172. APUADO, Victorio C.
173. AQUINO, Abanes O.
174. AQUINO, Abner O.
175. AQUINO, Angel D.
176. AQUINO, Bartolome
177. AQUINO, Graciano M.
178. AQUINO, Isidro
179. AQUINO, Jimmy B.
180. AQUINO, Pastor
181. AQUINO, Rosendo M.
182. AQUINO, Ruben M.
183. ARACARIA, Alexander
184. ARANDELA, Percival L.
185. ARANGORIN, Roberto A.
186. ARATEA, Benjamin O.
187. ARAULLO, Arturo V.
188. ARAULLO, Prudencio
189. ARAYATA, Escolastico
190. ARCANGEL, Manuel DG.
191. ARCARIA, Alexander
192. ARCIAGA, Francisco P.
193. AREVALO, Jose
194. AREVALO, Juanito
195. AREVALO, Mario a.
196. AREVALO, Ramon A.
197. AREVALO, Rodolfo D.
198. ARGETE, Gavino M.
199. ARGUELLES, Alfredo
200. ARGUELLES, Angelito M.
201. ARGUELLES, Eulalio
202. ARGUELLES, Hermenigildo M.
203. ARICA, Wilfredo P.
204. ARIZA, Dionisio R.
205. ARLITA, Vicente
206. ARONSE, Juanito P.
207. ARTITA, Rogelio S.
208. ARUELIO, Vicente
209. ASEDILLO, Jose M.
210. ASPER, Rodolfo M.
211. ASUNAN, Danilo R.
212. ASUNCION, Antonio
213. ASUNCION, Artemio M.
214. ASUNCION, Edgardo
215. ASUNCION, Feliciano N.
216. ASUNCION, Rexy Sr., L.
217. ASUNCION, Rodolfo C.
218. ATIENZA, Carlito C.
219. ATIENZA, Jose R.
220. ATIENZA, Justo
221. ATIENZA, Restituto A.
222. ATUD, Leonelito M.
223. AUSTRIA, Angel
224. AUSTRIA, Calixto B.
225. AUSTRIA, Oscar M.
226. AUSTRIA, Savador T.
227. AVELLANA, Jose
228. AVILA, Virgilio I.
229. AVUELTA, Ricardo Jr., P.
230. AXALAN, Bartolome M.
231. AXALAN, Loreto Jr.,
232. AXALAN, Marinao V.
233. AXALAN, Vicente R.
234. AYO, Herbert
235. AZAGRA, Jaime A.
236. BABAEL, Sherlito S.
237. BABAGAY, Conrado T.
238. BABAGAY, Gerardo
239. BABASA, Wilhem S.
240. BABILONIA, Alfredo C.
241. BACAL, Felimon
242. BACAMANTE, Virgilio A.
243. BACANI, Jose L.
244. BACARAT, Paisal G.
245. BADUA, Emerito M.
246. BAES, Filoteo A.
247. BAGADIONG, Guillermo T.
248. BAGADIONG, Noel S.
249. BAGASIN, Lamilo A.
250. BAGTING, Vicente G
251. BALABALO, Luis
252. BALANTE, Geronimo
253. BALATAZO, Silverio M.
254. BALBICRAN, Gerardo R.
255. BALBIERAN, Anatalio B.
256. BALBIERAN, Maximo C.
257. BALBIERAN, Romeo B.
258. BALBIERAN, Romulo R.
259. BALBIERAN, Vicente D.
260. BALBIN, Rodolfo C.
261. BALBIRAN, Fernando B.
262. BALCOBA, Federico B.
263. BALINAS, Pablo G.
264. BALINGIT, Rodolfo F.
265. BALITBIT, Rodolfo
266. BALIWAG, Cesario H.
267. BALOBO, Alfredo S.
268. BALOBO, Teodoro V.
269. BANAAG, Falconeri
270. BARASARI, Rizal
271. BARBA, Danilo M.
272. BARBOZA, Ramon T.
273. BARCENA, Fidel F.
274. BARIN, Rodolfo
275. BARLENA, Fidel F.
276. BARLENA, Florentino
277. BAROLA, Abdon V.
278. BARRIENTOS, Benjamin
279. BARRO, Bernardo C.
280. BARTIDO, Leonardo
281. BARTOLOME, Marcelo
282. BARZAGA, Vivencio T.
283. BAS, Fernando
284. BASILAN, Juan L.
285. BASMAYOR, Artemio A.
286. BASTRO, Reynaldo U.
287. BATACLAN, Mario
288. BATAIN, Romeo
289. BATICA, Ernesto Sr., S.
290. BATICA, Hobino O.
291. BATICA, Roberto S.
292. BATINGA, Elueterio P.
293. BATITIS, Ceferino
294. BAUAN, Victoriano A.
295. BAUAN, Vivencio C.
296. BAUTISTA, Ceferino O.
297. BAUTISTA, Emegdio P.
298. BAUTISTA, Gaudencio S.
299. BAUTISTA, Irene P.
300. BAUTISTA, Jose D.
301. BAUTISTA, Leonardo
302. BAUTISTA, Mamerto S.
303. BAUTISTA, Ruperto B.
304. BAUTISTA, Rustico
305. BAUTISTA, Teodoro S.
306. BAUTISTA, Virgilio O.
307. BAYA, Inoncencio
308. BAYA, Jesus R.
309. BAYACAL, Venancio Jr., V.
310. BAYACAL, Winefredo
311. BAYLON, Lolito F.
312. BEBIT, Wenniefredo B.
313. BELEN, Enrico P.
314. BELIR, Ben G.
315. BELTRAN, Diego
316. BELTRAN, Ebrulfo G.
317. BELTRAN, Eric B.
318. BELTRAN, Largion G.
319. BENITEZ, Jovito N.
320. BENITEZ, Raul B.
321. BENSON, Perfecto F.
322. BERGONIO , Ireneo G.
323. BERMUDEZ, Isabelo
324. BERMUDEZ, Rolando
325. BERNAL, Victorio
326. BERNALES, Emiliano Jr., L.
327. BERON, Danilo
328. BERSAMIN, Benjamin A.
329. BERSAMIN, Dindo L.
330. BERWITE, Renato P.
331. BICOL, Angelito M.
332. BICOL, Anselmo G.
333. BICOL, Aristeo M.
334. BICOL, Celestino Jr., C.
335. BICOL, Cesario M.
336. BICOL, Felicisimo M.
337. BICOL, Florentino L.
338. BICOL, Francisco G.
339. BICOL, Larry C.
340. BICOL, Rogelio M.
341. BICOL, Romulo L.
342. BIGADION, Noel S.
343. BILLONES, Rogelio A.
344. BISCOCHO, Eleuterio B.
345. BISCOCHO, Petronillo M.
346. BITO, Teofilo N.
347. BLANCO, Alberto B.
348. BLANCO, Fernando
349. BLANCO, Virgilio
350. BLAS, Rogelio
351. BLAY, Nestor M.
352. BLAY, Rodrigo M.
353. BOADO, Elpidio A.
354. BOBADILLA, Cesar
355. BOBADILLA, Danilo A.
356. BOBADILLA, Laudico A.
357. BOBIER, Felix M.
358. BOBONGO, Dionisio O.
359. BODADILLA, Cesar A.
360. BODADILLA, Danilo A.
361. BOLANTE, Geronimo E.
362. BOLANTE, Gil I.
363. BOLISAY, Carlito M.
364. BONDOC, Augusto
365. BONDOC, Benito U.
366. BONDOC, Domingo
367. BONGT, Domingo S.
368. BOOC, Pepe S.
369. BOQUIREN, Arnulfo Jr., M.
370. BORDILLA, Eresto J.
371. BORJA, James Sr., V.
372. BORNALES, Ricardo C.
373. BRACAMANTE, Bayani S.
374. BRACAMANTE, Virgilio A.
375. BRACEROS, Wilfredo
376. BRAGAIS, Demetrio B.
377. BRAGANZA, Norberto E.
378. BRAVO, Tinioso S.
379. BRECINO, Angeles
380. BRIONES, Eureclydon G.
381. BRIONES, Romeo B.
382. BRIONES, Tranquilino Y.
383. BROTONEL, Ceferino G.
384. BRUCE, Cesar B.
385. BRUGE, Amado
386. BUENAFE, Tomas V.
387. BUENAFLOR, Marianito N.
388. BUENAVENTURA, Archimedes N.
389. BUENAVENTURA, Basilio N.
390. BUENAVENTURA, Ruperto Jr., E.
391. BUENCONSEJO, Guillermo
392. BUENTE, Tomas
393. BUENVIAJE, Manuel
394. BUENVIAJE, Vicento
395. BUGAY, Reynaldo D.
396. BULAMBAO, Buenaventura D.
397. BULANHAGUI, Ariel F.
398. BULATAO, Alfredo G.
399. BULLECER, Rodolfo R.
400. BUNAO, Isabelo M.
401. BUNGAY, Avenilo
402. BUNGAY, Jefferson Q.
403. BUSTAMANTE, Alexander
404. BUSTAMANTE, Jose G.
405. BUSTILLO, Pablito G.
406. BUTIONG, Virgilio Jr.,
407. CAALIM, Benito T.
408. CAALIM, Romeo T.
409. CABALLA, Honesto P.
410. CABALLERO, Delfin C.
411. CABALLERO, Jacinto B.
412. CABANIGAN, Benedicto
413. CABATAY, Moises
414. CABEZA, Guillermo
415. CABIGAN, Rosendo Z.
416. CABILANGAN, Pablo G.
417. CABRERA, Hermaneli
418. CABRERA, Jose D.
419. CABUHAT, Reynaldo T.
420. CADALIN, Bienvenido
421. CAGANAP, Julio R.
422. CAGATAN, Doroteo G.
423. CAGATAN, Pedro
424. CAGATAN, Rodolfo
425. CAGAYAT, Joven C.
426. CAHIGAS, Nestor B.
427. CAILAO, Amante
428. CAILES, Dorito A.
429. CALADO, Fernando M.
430. CALAJOS, Rogelio L.
431. CALAMBA, Felipe S.
432. CALAUAG, Ricardo C.
433. CALAUAGAN, Patronicio L.
434. CALCENA, Isagani
435. CALDERON, Oscar C.
436. CALDERON, Reynaldo V.
437. CALLEJA, Nestor D.
438. CALMA, Alejandro Jr., P.
439. CALMA, Fernando R.
440. CALMA, Jerry D.
441. CALMA, Miguel M.
442. CALMA, Renato R.
443. CALURA, Joven C.
444. CALURA, Renato R.
445. CAMACHO, Nelson T.
446. CAMACHO, Santos T.
447. CAMANA, Roberto M.
448. CAMANAG, Florante C.
449. CAMANAG, Sotero P.
450. CAMPANO, Pacifico
451. CAMPOSAGRADO, Alejandro M.
452. CANDA, Edgardo M.
453. CANDOR, Irineo P.
454. CANDOR, Irmer L.
455. CANTOS, Geronimo M.
456. CANTOS, Primitivo
457. CANTOS, Severino
458. CAPACETE, Ramon Jr., G.
459. CAPARAS, Gaspar V.
460. CAPONPON, Epifanio
461. CAPONPON, Ricardo
462. CARLOS, Narciso
463. CARREON, Armando
464. CARTEL, Jose H.
465. CASA, Crisendo
466. CASADO, Emmanuelito P.
467. CASINO, Renato
468. CASTANARES, Dalmacio R.
469. CASTANEDA, Menandro M.
470. CASTELO, Elias Jr., D.
471. CASTILLO, Anselmo S.
472. CASTILLO, Arnel L.
473. CASTILLO, Benigno A.
474. CASTILLO, Cornelio L.
475. CASTILLO, Emeterio L.
476. CASTILLO, Ferdinand L.
477. CASTILLO, Joaquin
478. CASTILLO, Jose L.
479. CASTILLO, Joseph B.
480. CASTILLO, Leonicio B.
481. CASTILLO, Lourdino M.
482. CASTILLO, Manuel
483. CASTILLO, Mario E.
484. CASTILLO, Nardito M.
485. CASTILLO, Natalio L.
486. CASTILLO, Nestor
487. CASTILLO, Pablo L.
488. CASTILLO, Romeo P.
489. CASTILLO, Vidal J.
490. CASTRO, Cesar M.
491. CASTRO, Crisaldo M.
492. CASTRO, Danilo M.
493. CASTRO, Prudencio
494. CASTRO, Ramon M.
495. CASTROJERES, Remar
496. CATAPANG, Conrado M.
497. CATAPANG, Ireneo
498. CATIBOG, Pepito M.
499. CATIBOG, Rodolfo
500. CATIBOG, Sesinando
501. CATIPAN, Dominador D.
502. CATLI, Jaime B.
503. CATUD, Conrado A.
504. CAY, Prumencio F.
505. CAYANAN, Francisco D.
506. CAYAS, Reynaldo
507. CECELIO, Romeo O.
508. CEFERINO, Durana D.
509. CELESTINO, Victorino R.
510. CELIS, Augusto
511. CELIS, Rodolfo B.
512. CENENA, Nestor
513. CENTENO, Emmanuel C.
514. CENTURA, Gorgonio C.
515. CEREZO, Elmo A.
516. CEREZO, Herminigildo A.
517. CERRO, Camilo C.
518. CETES, Henry
519. CHAN, Benjamin M.
520. CHAN, Generoso M.
521. CHAVEZ, Cesar A.
522. CHUA, Antonio C.
523. CHUA, Cecilio H.
524. CIABAL, Vivencio B.
525. CIFRA, Hernan N.
526. CIFRA, Vicente C.
527. CLARETE, Rodrigo
528. CLARETE, Vienvenido
529. CLAUD, Crizaldo D.
530. CLAVIO, Bienvenido M.
531. COCJIN, Jose Jr., B.
532. COLMENAR, Baltazar R.
533. COLOMA, Augusto V.
534. COMPLE, Damiano S.
535. CONCEPCION, Manuel Jr., C.
536. CONCEPCION, Turiano V.
537. CONCEPCION, Virgilio C.
538. CONSTANTINO, Rolando A.
539. CONSTANTINO, Teresito A.
540. CONTEMPRATO, Cesar P.
541. CONTEMPRATO, Lauro G.
542. CONTI, Bayani
543. CONTI, Edmundo C.
544. CONTI, Reynaldo C.
545. CORALES, Armando C.
546. CORALES, Jesus M.
547. CORCUERA, Renato
548. CORDERO, Mari F.
549. CORDOVA, Carlos Jr., V.
550. CORNISTA, Rino T.
551. CORNISTA, Romeo G.
552. CORONADO, Alfonso S.
553. CORONADO, Apolinario V.
554. CORONEL, Abelardo
555. CORONEL, Felix M.
556. CORPUZ, Leonardo P.
557. CORTEJO, Joel O.
558. CORTEMPRATO, Cesar
559. CORTEZ, Eedgardo D.
560. CORVERA, Francisco O.
561. COSINO, Renato R.
562. COSINO, Sofronio B.
563. COSTALES, Felipe Sr., B.
564. COSTALES, Francisco Sr.,
565. CREDITO, Celedenio R.
566. CREDITO, Enrico R.
567. CRISOSTOMO, Igmedio Jr., G.
568. CRUES, Alberto A.
569. CRUES, Teodulfo G.
570. CRUETA, Antonio B.
571. CRUSIS, Manolito R.
572. CRUZ, Anacleto Jr., V.
573. CRUZ, Arturo I.
574. CRUZ, Augusto B.
575. CRUZ, Danilo M.
576. CRUZ, Ernesto
577. CRUZ, Hilario C.
578. CRUZ, Panchi G.
579. CRUZ, Roberto P.
580. CRUZ, Rodelio
581. CRUZ, Rodolfo B.
582. CRUZ, Teodoro S.
583. CUARESMA, Dionisio A.
584. CUDAL, Raymundo
585. CUENCO, Edeltrudo F.
586. CUENCO, Edgar F.
587. CUESTINO, Victorino
588. CUEVAS, Abdon S.
589. CUEVAS, Manuel C.
590. CUIZON, Felimon
591. CULLERA, Manuel M.
592. CUNANAN, Mario I.
593. CUSAP, Ernesto O.
594. CUSTODIO, Eduardo G.
595. DACASIN, Danilo B.
596. DACASIN, Fernando B.
597. DAGONDON, Fermio
598. DAGUINSIN, Richard A.
599. DALANON, Vicente D.
600. DALUZ, Nicolas
601. DATAAN, Teodoro C.
602. DATAN, Jose C.
603. DATAY, Andres F.
604. DATAY, Crisanto A.
605. DATILES, Miguel A.
606. DATINGUINOO, Desiderio A.
607. DATINGUINOO, Nicasio C.
608. DATOON, Jose
609. DAVID, Adolfo
610. DAVID, Eduardo
611. DAVID, Enrico T.
612. DAVID, Fabio
613. DAVID, Victoriano S.
614. DAYACAP, Edgardo N.
615. DAYANDAYAN, Tomestocles
616. DAYANGHIRANG, Rufino T.
617. DAYRIT, Bayani
618. DAYRIT, Leonardo S.
619. DAYRIT, Ricardo
620. DAYRIT, Victoriano C.
621. DE ADE, Bayani R.
622. DE CASTRO, Cristobal L.
623. DE CASTRO, Primitivo L.
624. DE CASTRO, Rene T.
625. DE CASTRO, Romeo A.
626. DE CHAVEZ, Pedro
627. DE DIOS, Cesar J.
628. DE GUZMAN, Angelito Jr.,
629. DE GUZMAN, Benedicto N.
630. DE GUZMAN, Celerino
631. DE GUZMAN, Donato
632. DE GUZMAN, Francisco C.
633. DE GUZMAN, Rolando F.
634. DE GUZMAN, Roman A.
635. DE GUZMAN, Romulo L.
636. DE JESUS, Liberto
637. DE JESUS, Primo
638. DE JESUS, Reynaldo C.
639. DE LEMON, Victorio SR., R.
640. DE LEMOS, Benito Jr.
641. DE LEMOS, Victoria
642. DE LEON, Dominador A.
643. DE LEON, Enrique C.
644. DE LEON, Ernesto C.
645. DE LEON, Jose S.
646. DE LEON, Pedro G.
647. DE LUMBAN, Joselito L.
648. DE LUNA, Napoleon S.
649. DE RAMA, Falconery R.
650. DE RAMA, Federico J.
651. DE RAMA, Onofre L.
652. DE RAMA, Ricardo L.
653. DE RAMA, Rolando A.
654. DE SILOS, Rodolfo B.
655. DE TORRES, Arnulfo
656. DE TORRES, Leonardo
657. DE TORRES, Nemesio A.
658. DE VERA, Ignacio C.
659. DE VERA, Marciano D.
660. DE VERA, Marciano V.
661. DE VERA, Nestor DR.
662. DE VERA, Reynaldo M.
663. DE VERA, Wilfredo M.
664. DE VILLA, Rodolfo C.
665. DEL MUNDO, Danilo L.
666. DEL MUNDO, Pedro C.
667. DEL MUNDO, Walfredo L.
668. DEL PILAR, Florentino
669. DEL PILAR, Lorencio
670. DEL PRADO, Vicente P.
671. DEL RIO, Pastor
672. DEL ROSARIO, Alberto
673. DEL ROSARIO, Alfredo
674. DEL ROSARIO, Cesar S.
675. DEL ROSARIO, Generoso F.
676. DEL ROSARIO, Guerero
677. DEL ROSARIO, Teodorico
678. DEL ROSARIO,. Vedasto
679. DELA CRUZ, Alberto
680. DELA CRUZ, Daniel
681. DELA CRUZ, Domingo V.
682. DELA CRUZ, Edgar R.
683. DELA CRUZ, Emiliano Jr.,
684. DELA CRUZ, Ernesto T.
685. DELA CRUZ, Federico N.
686. DELA CRUZ, Jose G.
687. DELA CRUZ, Juan R.
688. DELA CRUZ, Marcelino G.
689. DELA CRUZ, Reynaldo B.
690. DELA CRUZ, Rodelio
691. DELA CRUZ, Walfredo B.
692. DELA CRUZ, Zosimo
693. DELA MERCED, Ernani
694. DELA PENA, Doroteo
695. DELA RAMA, Ricardo C.
696. DELA VEGA, Abraham
697. DELBORO, Joselito T.
698. DELGADO, Rufino M.
699. DELLOSA, Joselito Fidel T.
700. DELOS REYES, Eusebio I.
701. DELOS REYES, Leonardo
702. DELOS REYES, Silverio Sr., V.
703. DELOS SANTOS, Emaldo D.
704. DELOS SANTOS, Felizardo M.
705. DELOS SANTOS, Serafin A.
706. DELOSO, Joselito T.
707. DENIEGA, Juanito F.
708. DIATA, Ernesto F.
709. DIAZ, Antonio R.
710. DIAZ, Eduardo A.
711. DIAZ, Ernesto E.
712. DIAZ, Felix
713. DIAZ, Melchor
714. DIAZ, Renato B.
715. DIAZ, Telesforo M.
716. DIAZ,Nicanor S.
717. DIGA, Gerardo C.
718. DIMAANO, Rodolfo M.
719. DIMAAPI, Romeo P.
720. DIMAPILIS, Leoncio I.
721. DIMATATAC, Jose A.
722. DIMATATAC, Romulo
723. DIMATULAC, Clemente B.
724. DIMAULATAN, Vivencio C.
725. DIMAYUGA, Luis
726. DINGLASAN, Aniano M.
727. DINGLASAN, Manuel A.
728. DIONISIO. Rolando V.
729. DISINGANIO, Domingo J.
730. DISMAYA, Philip G.
731. DIZON, Modesto
732. DIZON, Reynaldo S.
733. DOCTOLERO, Benjamin
734. DOLOIRAS, Marcelino D.
735. DOMINGO, Rodolfo
736. DOMINGUEZ, Antonio S.
737. DOZA. Benjamin E.
738. DUAG. Elpidio I.
739. DUMAGUIN, Saturnino H.
740. DUMAGUN, Perseverando H.
741. DUMALI, Felipe
742. DUPA, Benjamin D.
743. DURAN, Danilo C.
744. DURAN, Gregorio D.
745. DURANA, Ceferino
746. EBRADA, Gilbert
747. EBRADA, Gilberto
748. EBRADA, Ricardo P.
749. EDUARTE, Renato A.
750. EISMA, Godofredo E.
751. EJERCITO, Antonio Jr.,
752. ELIAS, Carlito
753. ELISAN, Ristituto
754. ELLO, Ardon B.
755. ELLO, Ubed B.
756. EMMAN, Johnny M.
757. ENANO, Josefino R.
758. ENCANTO, Jose T.
759. ENCARNACION, Reynaldo A.
760. ENGALLA, Jaime M.
761. ENGAY, Vicente
762. ENGON, Vicente
763. ENGUANCHO, Edgardo
764. ENGUERO, Elmer F.
765. ENRIQUEZ, Rolando G.
766. EQUIPADO, Elias Jr., F.
767. ERIDAO, Eduarte C.
768. ESCARILLA, Ramon Jr. T.
769. ESCARILLO, Wilfredo
770. ESCARMOSA, Felizaro
771. ESCARMOSA, Miguel B.
772. ESCATOTO, Eladio L.
773. ESCOBAR, Armando
774. ESCOTA, Gilberto B.
775. ESCUYOR, Romeo T.
776. ESEO, Ernesto Sr., A.
777. ESGUERRA, Democrito M.
778. ESGUERRA, John
779. ESPANOL, Miguel L.
780. ESPARAGO, Noel
781. ESPINA, Pascual F.
782. ESPINA, Robert
783. ESPINO, Arturo B.
784. ESPINO, Carlito J.
785. ESPINO, Edgardo B.
786. ESPINO, Honorio E.
787. ESPINO, Horacio
788. ESPINO, Silverio D.
789. ESPINOSA, Graciano
790. ESPINOSA, Policapio C.
791. ESPINOSA, Teodoro
792. ESPIRITU, Angelito B.
793. ESPIRITU, Eduardo S.
794. ESPIRITU, Ernesto S.
795. ESPIRITU, Gregorio S.
796. ESPIRITU, Ildefonso R.
797. ESPIRITU, Leonardo Jr., A.
798. ESPIRITU, Manuel S.
799. ESPIRITU, Reynaldo B.
800. ESPIRITU, Rodolfo C.
801. ESPIRITU, Rodolfo S.
802. ESPIRITU, Rodrigo C.
803. ESPIRITU, Rolando E.
804. ESPORAS, Manuel M.
805. ESPREGANTE, Julian
806. ESQUIVEL, Arturo S.
807. ESTACIO, Bob L.
808. ESTACIO, Romeo P.
809. ESTANDARTE, Dioscoro
810. ESTANISLAO, Igmidio
811. ESTAVA, Nestor M.
812. ESTEAN, Ernesto M.
813. ESTERON, Melanio R.
814. ESTRADA, Benjamin S.
815. ESTRADA, Feliciano E.
816. ESTRELLA, Geronimo
817. ESTUAR, Conrado E.
818. ESTUYE, Clyde
819. ETCHON, Reynaldo D.
820. ETCHON, Reynaldo O.
821. EVANGELISTA, Antonio S.
822. EVANGELISTA, Donato
823. EVANGELISTA, Eduardo M.
824. EVANGELISTA, Rolando
825. EVANGELISTA, Valerio A.
826. FABABIER, Manuel M.
827. FABRICANTE, Primo
828. FACTORAN, Felicisimo D.
829. FADRIQUELA, Sesenio
830. FAJARDO, Efren G.
831. FAJARDO, Eliseo
832. FAJARDO, Pedro E.
833. FALLER, Reynaldo C.
834. FALQUEZA, Porfirio
835. FALTADO, Ruben
836. FARAON, Ciriaco
837. FAUSTINO, Wilfredo
838. FEDERICO, Abundio B.
839. FERIA, Carino
840. FERNANDEZ, Agaton B.
841. FERNANDEZ, Emilio E.
842. FERNANDEZ, Jose Celedonio L.
843. FERNANDEZ, Serman O.
844. FERNANDO, Leonardo S.
845. FERNANDZ, Ely E.
846. FERRER, Artemio C.
847. FERRER, Cenon
848. FERRER, Ernesto
849. FERRER, Leopoldo S.
850. FIGURACION, Misael M.
851. FIRMA, Rizaldo F.
852. FLORES, Agapito C.
853. FLORES, Armando F.
854. FLORES, Benjamin D.
855. FLORES, Edilberto M.
856. FLORESCA, Eligio B.
857. FORES, Edgardo C.
858. FRAGADA, Gregorio
859. FRAMIL, Rosauro R.
860. FRANCIA, Isabelito P.
861. FRANCISCO, Buenaventura M.
862. FRANCISCO, Cornelio Y.
863. FRANCISCO, Edgardo J.
864. FRANCISCO, Framil
865. FRANCISCO, Manuel S.
866. FRANCISCO, Mario B.
867. FRANCISCO, Olegario B.
868. FRANCISCO, Rolando B.
869. FRANCISCO, Valeriano B.
870. FRANE, Philbert M.
871. FRANZUELA, Ildefonso M.
872. FRIRME, Daniel Pedro C.
873. FURTO, Reynaldo L.
874. FURTO, Wenfredo L.
875. GABAWAN, Jesus E.
876. GABAWAN, Rodolfo A.
877. GABAY, Castaniro
878. GABAY, Constancio F.
879. GABAY, Teodorico A.
880. GABUTAN, Esmerado
881. GALANG, Balbino C.
882. GALANG, Cesar
883. GALLARDO, Wilfredo A.
884. GALOSO, Santiago N.
885. GALVEZ, Romeo A.
886. GAMBOA, Gabriel C.
887. GAMMAD, Potenciano D.
888. GAMUTAN, Irobengito M.
889. GANAS, Hilario M.
890. GANDAMON, Bernardo
891. GANZON, Juan A.
892. GARCIA, Alfredo Jr.,
893. GARCIA, Andres Jr., A.
894. GARCIA, Angelito P.
895. GARCIA, Bernardino N.
896. GARCIA, Bernardo M.
897. GARCIA, Digno P.
898. GARCIA, Ermando M.
899. GARCIA, Ernesto L.
900. GARCIA, Esmeraldo N.
901. GARCIA, Eugenio Jr., C.
902. GARCIA, Marcelo L.
903. GARCIA, Patricio Jr., L.
904. GARCIA, Pedro C.
905. GARCIA, Ponciano G.
906. GARCIA, Ponciano J.
907. GARCIA, R.E.
908. GARCIA, Rafael P.
909. GARCIA, Roberto S.
910. GARCIA, Rolando
911. GAROFIL, Osias G.
912. GARON, Raymundo C.
913. GASCON, Rolando
914. GATCHALIAN, Ernesto E.
915. GATCHALIAN, Jose
916. GATELA, Rolando G.
917. GATULAYAO, Conrado
918. GAWAN, Jose A.
919. GAYA, Jose M.
920. GAYA, Leonardo T.
921. GAYETA, Avelino DM.
922. GELLID, Manol F.
923. GELLIDO, Ernesto D.
924. GEMOTO, Roberto
925. GENEROSO, Agapito
926. GERON, Raymundo
927. GERONIMO, Julio M.
928. GERONIMO, Roberto A.
929. GOMEZ, Patricio Jr., V.
930. GONZALES, Domingo A.
931. GONZALES, Eduardo B.
932. GONZALES, Jaime B.
933. GONZALES, Lamberto C.
934. GONZALES, Manuel S.
935. GONZALES, Norberto
936. GONZALES, Placido
937. GONZALES, Regino M.
938. GONZALES, Ruperto T.
939. GOPEZ, Armando S.
940. GOTANA, Edgardo Z.
941. GRAJERA, Florante E.
942. GREGORIO, Jose G.
943. GRULLO, Jorge T.
944. GUANTO, Rogelio D.
945. GUANZON, Narciso D.
946. GUDA, Angel D.
947. GUERERO, Martin V.
948. GUEVARA, Rosendo M.
949. GUINARES, Oscar L.
950. GUINHAWA, Narciso C.
951. GUINTO, Isagani S.
952. GUITANG, Rodolfo C.
953. GUNO, Alexis L.
954. GUNO, Ricardo K.
955. GUPIT, Francisco G.
956. GUTIERREZ, Dennis J.
957. GUTIERREZ, Ignacio B.
958. GUTIERREZ, Jose M.
959. HABANA, Cesar H.
960. HALCON, Danilo
961. HERMOSO, Roberto
962. HERNANDEZ, Angelito
963. HERNANDEZ, Armando S.
964. HERNANDEZ, Julio A.
965. HERNANDEZ, Napoleon
966. HERNANDEZ, Raul G.
967. HERNANDEZ, Reynaldo
968. HICBAN, Cirilio
969. HILADO, Joveniano D.
970. HILADO, Manuel D.
971. HILADO, Mario D.
972. HILAPO, Justo S.
973. HILARIO, Antonio
974. HILARIO, Winfredo P.
975. HINAHON, Rostito
976. HINGADA, Felecisimo
977. HINGALA, Felismo
978. HIPOLITO, Eduardo M.
979. HLARIO, Expedito
980. HOLGADO, Rodrigo C.
981. HONRADEZ, Maximino B.
982. HUGGINS, Wilfredo M.
983. IGNACIO, Generoso
984. IGNACIO, Raul L.
985. ILAGAN, Felipe M.
986. ILAGAN, Manuel
987. ILAGAN, Pablito
988. ILAGAN, Pedro
989. ILAGAN, Renato L.
990. ILAGAN, Teofilo M.
991. ILOG, Vicente M.
992. INALVES, Victor S.
993. INASIANG, Santiago
994. INSIGNE, Conrado A.
995. INSIONG, Conrado
996. ISIDORO, Rodolfo D.
997. ISLA, Graciano G.
998. JACLA, Floriano V.
999. JACOB, Arnel L.
1000. JACOB, Expedito N.
1001. JACOB, Hery L.
1002. JACOB, Victor M.
1003. JANACO, Alejandro M.
1004. JAPITENGA, Oscar J.
1005. JARDINIANO, Honesto
1006. JARDINIANO, Rolando V.
1007. JARO, Abraham V.
1008. JARO, Cesar
1009. JARO, Ferdinand
1010. JARO, Romeo M.
1011. JASMIN, Mario
1012. JAUDALSO, Roberto E.
1013. JAVIER, Antonio C.
1014. JAVIER, Buenvenido
1015. JAVIER, Conrado N.
1016. JAVIER, Ernesto
1017. JAVIER, Romeo M.
1018. JERVOSO, Juanito N.
1019. JIMENA, Angelico Jr., B.
1020. JIMENEZ, Carlos A.
1021. JIMENEZ, Danilo E.
1022. JOAQUIN, Pedro C.
1023. JOCACA, Pedro
1024. JOCO, Rustico P.
1025. JOCSON, Antonio R.
1026. JOCSON, Felino U.
1027. JOCSON, Felipe U.
1028. JOCSON, Pedro N.
1029. JOCSON, Valentino S.
1030. JOLOYA, Claro
1031. JOLOYA, Pedro B.
1032. JONAS, Abelardo E.
1033. JOSE, Esteban Sr., S.
1034. JOSE, Raul R.
1035. JOSEF, Petronillo L.
1036. JOYA, Rodolfo E.
1037. JUCAR, Cesar G.
1038. JUSTO, Renato E.
1039. KABIGTING, Gertrudo O.
1040. KAMATOY, Arnaldo P.
1041. KOLIMLIM, Eduardo Sr., S.
1042. LABAY, Lauro J.
1043. LABAYO, Leonardo
1044. LABELLA, Emmanuel C.
1045. LABING, Arcadio T.
1046. LABRADOR, Floro A.
1047. LABRAMONTE, Jose R.
1048. LACERONA, Edgardo B.
1049. LACSAMANA, Gerardo
1050. LACSON, Jose B.
1051. LADINES, Mario J.
1052. LAGAC, Felipe R.
1053. LAGAC, Rufino
1054. LAGANAPAN, Rodrigo Y.
1055. LAGANAPAN, Sandy P.
1056. LAGMAY, Wilfredo
1057. LAJOM, Eliseo T.
1058. LAKIAN, Arsenio F.
1059. LAMADRID, Efren M.
1060. LANDICHO, Constancio R.
1061. LARKIN, Wilfredo M.
1062. LATANAN, Gaudencio
1063. LATAYAN, Virgilio
1064. LATOJA, Domingo D.
1065. LATOJA, Emiliano
1066. LATOJA, Juanito D.
1067. LAURE, Antonio S.
1068. LAUREL, Wenceslao
1069. LAXAMANA, Alfredo S.
1070. LAYON, Edgar
1071. LAZARO, Daniel R.
1072. LEANO, Antonio C.
1073. LEANO, Felix
1074. LEBITA, Ricardo
1075. LEGASPI, Arturo S.
1076. LEONOR, Arturo V.
1077. LEONOR, Julio P.
1078. LEOOR, Meinardo M.
1079. LEYESA, Teodoro M.
1080. LEYNES, Luisito
1081. LICAROS, Luzvimindo F.
1082. LILOC, Manolito C.
1083. LIMACO, Gerardo Jr.,
1084. LINSANGAN, Rosanno S.
1085. LIRIO, Efren U.
1086. LISING, Arcadio T.
1087. LISING, Ernesto S.
1088. LISING, Esmeraldo S.
1089. LISING, Renato S.
1090. LISING, Wilfredo S.
1091. LLANERA, Rodrigo G.
1092. LOBETA, Rolando R.
1093. LOGAN, Arnel I.
1094. LOGRONIO, Claro A.
1095. LOGRONIO, Clemente A.
1096. LOGRONIO, Cornelio A.
1097. LOGUC, Felipe R.
1098. LOGUINACIO, Edwin C.
1099. LONTOC, Crispulo D.
1100. LONTOC, Loreto
1101. LONTOK, Rogelio L.
1102. LOPENA, David C.
1103. LOPENA, Nicanor C.
1104. LOPERA, Felipe M.
1105. LOPERA, Pedro M.
1106. LOPERA, Rogelio
1107. LOPEZ, Carlito M.
1108. LOPEZ, Clody
1109. LOPEZ, Garlito
1110. LOPEZ, George I.
1111. LOPEZ, Lamberto
1112. LOPEZ, Larry
1113. LOPEZ, Nicanor D.
1114. LOPEZ, Rodrigo M.
1115. LOPEZ, Virgilio M.
1116. LOQUINARIO, Edwin C.
1117. LOREJA, Bernardito G.
1118. LORENZO, Israel S.
1119. LORICO, Domingo B.
1120. LORINO, Alejandro C.
1121. LOYOLA, Domingo S.
1122. LOZA, Crisostomo
1123. LUAGE, Dante A.
1124. LUAGE, Henry A.
1125. LUALHATI, Antonio M.
1126. LUALHATI, Emmanuel Jr.,
1127. LUALHATI, Juan M.
1128. LUALHATI, Leondes C.
1129. LUALHATI, Ramon C.
1130. LUALHATI, Sebastian
1131. LUBAT, Francisco
1132. LUBIAN, Rubinato A.
1133. LUCEA, Ronito E.
1134. LUCERO, Armando B.
1135. LUKBAN, Narciso H.
1136. LUMANGLAS, Armando G.
1137. LUMANGLAS, Eleodoro A.
1138. LUNA, Thomas V.
1139. LUNA, Vicente
1140. LUSUNG, Onofre M.
1141. MAALIHAN, Pelagio D.
1142. MAAMO, Bernardino C.
1143. MAAMO, Manuel J.
1144. MAAMO, Victoriano
1145. MAAMO, Victorio
1146. MABALAY, Jose P.
1147. MACABEBE, Leonides R.
1148. MACALALAD, Andres T.
1149. MACALALAD, Nicasio T.
1150. MACALALAD, Noli A.
1151. MACALALAD, Victor B.
1152. MACALDO, Victor C.
1153. MACALINO, Alredo M.
1154. MACALINO, Ricardo
1155. MACALINTALA, Jose T.
1156. MACARAEG, Arthur V.
1157. MACARAEG, Irineo
1158. MACARAEG, Nestor
1159. MACARAIG, Aurelio S.
1160. MACARAIG, Benito V.
1161. MACARAIG, Bienvenido
1162. MACARAIG, Efren C.
1163. MACARAIG, Ernesto G.
1164. MACARAIG, Nestor C.
1165. MACARAIG, Rodolfo V.
1166. MACARAIG, Romeo
1167. MACATANGAY, Basilio M.
1168. MACATANGAY, Benjamin
1169. MACATANGAY, Buenaventura A.
1170. MACATANGAY, Damaso M.
1171. MACATANGAY, Hermogenes
1172. MACATANGAY, Juan H.
1173. MACATANGAY, Mario
1174. MACATANGAY, Napoleon A.
1175. MACATANGAY, Nicolas A.
1176. MACATANGAY, Remegio
1177. MACATANGAY, Ricardo M.
1178. MACATANGAY, Rodel A.
1179. MACATANGAY, Romeo
1180. MACATANGAY, Romulo A.
1181. MACATANGAY, Sofronio M.
1182. MADLANGBAYAN, Osias Q.
1183. MADRID, Ernesto L.
1184. MADRID, Nicolas P.
1185. MAESTRE, Felicito C.
1186. MAGANAYE, Rencel B.
1187. MAGANO, Marcos L.
1188. MAGAT, Abeardo S.
1189. MAGAT,Edilberto G.
1190. MAGBABUA, Efren C.
1191. MAGBUHAT, Benjamin
1192. MAGCALENG, Alfredo C.
1193. MAGNAYE, Antonio E.
1194. MAGNAYE, Ernesto L.
1195. MAGNAYE, Ranerio M.
1196. MAGNAYE, Renato M.
1197. MAGNAYE, Venancio L.
1198. MAGNAYE, Victorino R.
1199. MAGNO, Boyet
1200. MAGNO, Camilo B.
1201. MAGNO, Danilo B.
1202. MAGNO, Oscar R.
1203. MAGNO, Romeo B.
1204. MAGPANTAY, Alfonso
1205. MAGPANTAY, Francisco V.
1206. MAGPANTAY, Ricardo C.
1207. MAGPANTAY, Simeon M.
1208. MAGSINO, Armando M.
1209. MAGSINO, Macario S.
1210. MAGSINO, Rolando
1211. MAGTIBAY, Antonio
1212. MAGTIBAY, Macario
1213. MAGTIBAY, Victor V.
1214. MAHILUM, Geronimo Sr, L.
1215. MAISOG, Ceferino G.
1216. MAISOG, David A.
1217. MALABANAN, Romeo B.
1218. MALIPOL, Ricky
1219. MALONZO, Manuel
1220. MALONZO, Marcelo G.
1221. MAMADIS, Ricardo
1222. MANA, Rodolfo C.
1223. MANAGHAYA, Isagani
1224. MANALAC, Remegio S.
1225. MANALILI, Bernardo
1226. MANALILI, Manuel A.
1227. MANALILI, Rogelio
1228. MANALO, Angel M.
1229. MANALO, Aquiles L.
1230. MANALO, Danilo M.
1231. MANALO, Felimon H.
1232. MANALO, Jose M.
1233. MANANGHAYA, Isagani S.
1234. MANANGUIT, Romulo L.
1235. MANAS, Cesar A.
1236. MANDAYAO, Vicente
1237. MANDIGMA, David A.
1238. MANEBO, Noel M.
1239. MANGAHAS, Leopoldo A.
1240. MANIAUL, Enrique S.
1241. MANIEGO, Noel M.
1242. MANIEGO, Vidal A.
1243. MANIGBAS, Adonis D.
1244. MANIGBAS, Bayani
1245. MANIGBAS, Benjamin
1246. MANIGO, Cornelio Jr.,
1247. MANIGOS, Pablo Sr., R.
1248. MANIGOS, Paquito R.
1249. MANIMTIM, Rolando C.
1250. MANINGAS, Fermin
1251. MANINGAS, Teodolfo D.
1252. MANIVAL, Enrico S.
1253. MANONGSONG, Daniel
1254. MANSINARES, Leopoldo B.
1255. MANUAL, Demetrio P.
1256. MANUAL, Domingo C.
1257. MANUAL, Enrique
1258. MANUAL, Marcelo K.
1259. MANUAL, Marciano C.
1260. MANUBA, Angelito T.
1261. MANUBAG, Lito C.
1262. MANUE, Diosdado
1263. MANUEL, Ernesto F.
1264. MANUEL, Marcelo
1265. MANUEL, Melchor G.
1266. MANZANO, Eduardo N.
1267. MAPA, Ricardo
1268. MAPILE, Ramon H.
1269. MARANA, Roberto C.
1270. MARANAN, Hermie M.
1271. MARANIAG, Normandy
1272. MARASIGAN, Basilio V.
1273. MARASIGAN, Delfin M.
1274. MARASIGAN, Hilario M.
1275. MARASIGAN, Nemesio
1276. MARASIGAN, Rodolfo P.
1277. MARASIGAN, Wenceslao
1278. MARCELO, Domingo G.
1279. MARCELO, Leonardo J.
1280. MARCELO, Mario L.
1281. MARCELO, Serafin M.
1282. MARCIADA, Rolando
1283. MARCIAL, Leonigildo
1284. MARIANO, Armando T.
1285. MARIANO, Federico S.
1286. MARIANO, Henry F.
1287. MARIANO, Marlon L.
1288. MARIANO, Narciso T.
1289. MARIANO, Navarro D.
1290. MARIDABLE, Jose B.
1291. MARINO, Santos E.
1292. MARPURI, Rodolfo C.
1293. MARQUEZ, Bayani A.
1294. MARQUEZ, Carlos A.
1295. MARQUEZ, Celso M.
1296. MARQUEZ, Narciso A.
1297. MARQUEZ, Romeo
1298. MARSIGAN, Wenceslao
1299. MARTINEZ, Joel L.
1300. MARTINEZ, Noel R.
1301. MARTINEZ, Reynaldo S.
1302. MARTINEZ, Rodolfo C.
1303. MASICAMPO, Diego R.
1304. MATA, Paolo M.
1305. MATAVERDE, Aurelio M.
1306. MATI, Conrado L.
1307. MATIENZO, Amadeo
1308. MATIENZO, Salvador R.
1309. MATILLA, Renato
1310. MATILLA, Victoriano L.
1311. MATITO, Leonardo N.
1312. MATREO, Dante A.
1313. MEDEL, Virgilio
1314. MEDINA, Augusto C.
1315. MEDINA, Cipriano R.
1316. MEDINA, Florante L.
1317. MEDINA, Jaime L.
1318. MEDINA, Jesse L.
1319. MEDINA, Mario L.
1320. MEDINILLA, Marshal M.
1321. MEDIODIA, Francis M.
1322. MEDIODIA, Luciano
1323. MEDIOLA, Ely M.
1324. MELECIO, Lolito M.
1325. MELENDEZ, Benigno
1326. MELENDEZ, Luciano C.
1327. MELENDEZ, Napoleon O.
1328. MELLIANG, Alfredo
1329. MELO, Renato J.
1330. MEMIJE, Rene J.
1331. MEMIJE, Reynaldo F.
1332. MEMIJE, Rodel J.
1333. MENDIOLA, Francis
1334. MENDIOLA, Manalo B.
1335. MENDIOLA, Simplicio G.
1336. MENDOZA, Avelino Jr., I.
1337. MENDOZA, Benjamin L.
1338. MENDOZA, Claro M.
1339. MENDOZA, Jenrin
1340. MENDOZA, Jose C.
1341. MENDOZA, Manolito D.
1342. MENDOZA, Miguel C.
1343. MENDOZA, Ramiro A.
1344. MENDOZA, Romeo T.
1345. MENDOZA, Teofilo R.
1346. MENDOZA, Timoteo F.
1347. MENDOZA, Virgilio V.
1348. MENOR, Cresente S.
1349. MERCADO, Conrado Jr., C.
1350. MERCADO, Francisco
1351. MERCADO, Gregorio
1352. MERCADO, Luis P.
1353. MERCADO, Oscar S.
1354. MERCADO, Patricio H.
1355. MERCADO, Primitivo H.
1356. MERCADO, Reynaldo E.
1357. MERCADO, Ricardo B.
1358. MERCADO, Romeo
1359. MERCADO, Valdemor C.
1360. MERCADO, Virgilio S.
1361. MERCENA, Ricardo
1362. MERIDA, Elias H.
1363. MERLAN, Montano C.
1364. METRILLO, Nemesio M.
1365. MICLAT, Eduardo R.
1366. MILANES, Joejie N.
1367. MILANES, Jose C.
1368. MILAY, Raymundo P.
1369. MINIMO, Elueterio V.
1370. MINIMO, Gaspar V.
1371. MINIMO, Hernando G.
1372. MIRALES, Arnaldo I.
1373. MIRANDA, Alfredo P.
1374. MIRANDA, Benjamin M.
1375. MIRANDA, Cresenciano
1376. MIRANDA, Ruben H.
1377. MISA, Felixberto D.
1378. MODESTO, Claudio Jr., A.
1379. MOGOL, Noel M.
1380. MOLINA, Ildefonso C.
1381. MOLINA, Rogelio D.
1382. MONDEJAR, Armando B.
1383. MONDIDO, Oscar C.
1384. MONTECINES, Juanito O.
1385. MONTON, Generoso D.
1386. MONZON, Celso N.
1387. MONZON, Cosme B.
1388. MORADA, Cosme B.
1389. MORADA, Renato V.
1390. MORADA, Ricardo B.
1391. MORADA, Rodolfo B.
1392. MORADA, Rodrigo
1393. MORAL, Nestor K.
1394. MORALES, Rolando M.
1395. MORATILLO, Victorino O.
1396. MORENO, Alfredo
1397. MORENO, Federico M.
1398. MORTEL, Delfin M.
1399. MORTEL, Victorino Jr., A.
1400. MOSUELA, Carlito C.
1401. MUNDO, Jessie
1402. MUNDO, Rufino Jr.,
1403. MUNOZ, Espiritu A.
1404. MUNOZ, Ignacio E.
1405. MUNOZ, Ildefonso V.
1406. MUNOZ, Jose P.
1407. MUNOZ, Rogelio
1408. NAJERA, Angel C.
1409. NAPIZA, Juanito N.
1410. NAPIZA, Lamberto R.
1411. NAPIZA, Salvador
1412. NAPIZA, Wilfredo L.
1413. NAPOLAN, Ernesto C.
1414. NARCISO, Benjamin B.
1415. NARCISO, Carlos G.
1416. NARCISO, Marcelo A.
1417. NARCISO, Meliton B.
1418. NARCISO, Narciso L.
1419. NATALIA, Edwin B.
1420. NATALIA, Reynaldo B.
1421. NATI, Conrado
1422. NATIVIDAD, Samuel N.
1423. NAVARETTE, Fernando C.
1424. NAVARRO, Mariano D.
1425. NAVARRO, Pacifico Jr., D.
1426. NAZARENO, Florante A.
1427. NAZARENO, Resurreccion D.
1428. NAZARIO, Rizal B.
1429. NEGRITE, Josue D.
1430. NEPOMUCENO, Alfredo
1431. NEPOMUCENO, Isidro M.
1432. NER, Valente Jr., T.
1433. NG, Herbert G.
1434. NICOLAS, Florencio
1435. NINON, Ernesto C.
1436. NOFUENTE, Mabini M.
1437. NOGUERA, Rodolfo M.
1438. NUQUI, Avelino
1439. OBA, Nemesio P.
1440. OBANA, Marcial L.
1441. OBANDO, Luis G.
1442. OBIAS, Romeo M.
1443. OCAMPO, Danilo D.
1444. OCAMPO, Edgardo
1445. OCAMPO, Rodrigo E.
1446. OCCIANO, Antonio B.
1447. OCHOA, Lorenzito H.
1448. OCSON, Reynaldo P.
1449. OCTAVIANO, Francisco
1450. OCTAVIO, Carlito P.
1451. ODESA, Antonio L.
1452. ODESA, Benjamin
1453. OFICIAR, Gideon S.
1454. OLAES, Romulo W.
1455. OLARTE, Gregorio E.
1456. OLASCO, Angel M.
1457. OLEDAN, Luis
1458. OLIMBA, German V.
1459. OLIMBA, Zosimo V.
1460. OLINDO, Juan
1461. OLIVA, Marcial B.
1462. OLIVARES, Francisco M.
1463. OLIVIAGA, Noel T.
1464. ONG, Renato S.
1465. ONGKIKI, Leopoldo M.
1466. OPEZ, Vicente S.
1467. ORALLO, Benjamin V.
1468. ORBISTA, Pedro Jr.,
1469. ORDAS, Reynaldo N.
1470. ORDONEZ, Ricardo
1471. ORIAL, Romeo S.
1472. ORIGENES, Romeo L.
1473. ORINE, Cipriano T.
1474. ORLANES, Eufrocino B.
1475. ORTANEX, Danilo R
1476. ORTEGA, Antonio V.
1477. OSIAS, Wilfredo
1478. OVERA, Abelardo F.
1479. OWAY, Luis A.
1480. PA-A, Virgilio P.
1481. PAALAN, David
1482. PACANZA, Federico C.
1483. PACHECO, Jesus N.
1484. PACHO, Ernie
1485. PACIFICO, Navarro Jr., D.
1486. PADILLA, Alfonso L.
1487. PADILLA, Jesus N.
1488. PADUA, Rufino C.
1489. PAEZ, Erlando P.
1490. PAGADUAN, Beneficto V.
1491. PAGLICAUAN, Mario M.
1492. PAGSANJAN, Danilo P.
1493. PAGSISIHAN, Numeriano
1494. PAGUIO, Carlito
1495. PAGUIO, Ricardo T.
1496. PAJARES, Antonio V.
1497. PAKINGGAN, Emilio C.
1498. PALABRICA, Leandro P.
1499. PALASIN, Sebastian D.
1500. PALIMA, Aniceto C.
1501. PALMA, Ricardo M.
1502. PALO, Quinciano
1503. PALOMA, Abelardo E.
1504. PALPAL-LATOC, Jose A.
1505. PAMATIAN, Jose C.
1506. PAN, Gonzalo
1507. PAN, Profirio C.
1508. PANCHO, Jose V.
1509. PANGAN, Buenveido
1510. PANGAN, Ernesto S.
1511. PANGAN, Javier M.
1512. PANGANIBAN, Francisco D.
1513. PANGAYAO, Felipe P.
1514. PANGGAT, Regidor M.
1515. PAPA, Angel A.
1516. PARALA, Gorgonio P.
1517. PARAS, Joel
1518. PAREN, Juanito
1519. PARUNGAO, Antonio D.
1520. PASAMBA, Waldemar S.
1521. PASCUA, Eduardo C.
1522. PASCUAL Isagani M.
1523. PASCUAL, Edmundo V.
1524. PASIA, Francisco V.
1525. PASIMIO, Jose R
1526. PASION, Jose V.
1527. PASIONA, Ireneo G.
1528. PASMIO, Edilberto Jr.,
1529. PATAG, Romeo I.
1530. PAYRA, Jose I.
1531. PAYRA, Luisito S.
1532. PEDRIGUERA, Fernando
1533. PELLAS, Chester
1534. PENA, Angelito M.
1535. PENA, Antero F.
1536. PENDRAS, Dionisio M.
1537. PENILLA, Carlos
1538. PEPITO, Lope T.
1539. PERALTA, Herminio
1540. PERALTA, Reynaldo M.
1541. PERAN, Rodrigo P.
1542. PEREA, Francisco L.
1543. PEREA, Juanito L.
1544. PEREA, Olimpio T.
1545. PEREGRINA, Leopoldo M.
1546. PERENO, Fernando
1547. PEREZ, Antoliano E.
1548. PEREZ, Antonio
1549. PEREZ, Arnel
1550. PEREZ, Carmelito L.
1551. PEREZ, Danilo M.
1552. PEREZ, Dionisio M.
1553. PEREZ, Eduardo M.
1554. PEREZ, Efren G.
1555. PEREZ, Jimmy
1556. PEREZ, Juan
1557. PEREZ, Leon E.
1558. PEREZ, Romeo E.
1559. PEREZ, Romulo M.
1560. PEREZ, William
1561. PERIGIL, Cenon P.
1562. PERINO, Fernando G.
1563. PESCO, Alberto T.
1564. PIELAGO, Eleodoro A.
1565. PILLAJERA, Tomas Jr., B.
1566. PINEDA, Delmar P.
1567. PINEDA, Salvador
1568. PINILI, Victorio E.
1569. PINPIN, Elizalde C
1570. PINPIN, Francisco
1571. PINPIN, Modesto M.
1572. PINPIN, Wilfredo C.
1573. PINTO, Romeo A.
1574. PITAO, Mateo F.
1575. PLAMERAS, Rogelio C.
1576. PLANTA, Ariel I.
1577. PLATA, Paciencio M.
1578. POBLETE, Arturo
1579. POBLETE, Dominador N.
1580. POBLETE, Leonardo N.
1581. POBLETE, Seneco P.
1582. POLLOS, Jaime
1583. PONDALIS, Domingo B.
1584. PONIEG, Bernardo Q.
1585. PORTUGAL, Norberto D.
1586. PORTUGUEZ, Laureano C.
1587. PREILA, Dominador
1588. PRIMERO, Angelito G.
1589. PRIMO, Leonardo
1590. PRIVADO,Pederico R.
1591. PRUDENTE, Buenaventura
1592. PRUDENTE, Carmelito
1593. PUEYO, Dante
1594. PUEYO, Reynaldo Q.
1595. PULIDO, Rodolfo E.
1596. PUNAY, Cornelio F.
1597. PUNIO, Alejandro F.
1598. PUNIO, Gregorio F.
1599. PUNZALAN, Wilfredo D.
1600. PURISIMA, Rogelio P.
1601. QUEBRAL, Joselito C
1602. QUIABO, Roberto C.
1603. QUIMAN, Federico T.
1604. QUINTO, Alfredo L.
1605. QUINTO, Juanito M.
1606. QUINTOS, Romeo
1607. QUIOBO, Rogelio C.
1608. QUITEVIS, Elpidio R.
1609. QUOBO, Roberto
1610. RABANO, Benjamin D.
1611. RABINO, Desiderio R.
1612. RACABO, Eduardo W.
1613. RAMELO, Joselito F.
1614. RAMIREZ, Eugenio P.
1615. RAMIREZ, Fernando
1616. RAMIREZ, Ildefonso R.
1617. RAMIREZ, Leo
1618. RAMIREZ, Lirio C.
1619. RAMIREZ, Lito C.
1620. RAMIREZ, Luis A.
1621. RAMIREZ, Ricardo G.
1622. RAMIREZ, Rodolfo
1623. RAMOS, Alberto M.
1624. RAMOS, Anselmo C.
1625. RAMOS, Emeterio P.
1626. RAMOS, Froilan M.
1627. RAMOS, Jose N.
1628. RAMOS, Leoncio
1629. RAMOS, Manolito V.
1630. RAMOS, Nomer M.
1631. RAMOS, Oscar B.
1632. RAMOS, Roque A.
1633. RAMOS, Tobias R.
1634. RANADA, Jose G.
1635. RANADA, Marcelo
1636. RANADA, Pepito C.
1637. RANGEL, Ponciano P.
1638. RAQUEDAN, Reynaldo T.
1639. RAVELAS, Federico
1640. RAVELAS, Larry
1641. RAVELAS, Lorenzo D.
1642. RAVELAS, Manuel F.
1643. RAVELAS, Rodrigo
1644. RAVELAS, Rogelio R.
1645. RAVELAS, Teodorico R.
1646. RAVELAS, Vicente F.
1647. RAYA, Romeo S.
1648. RAYMUNDO, Ricardo E.
1649. RAYMUNDO, Wilfredo D.
1650. REBONG, Albert E.
1651. RECOLASO, Ernesto E.
1652. RECOLIZADO, Bienvenido B.
1653. REDAZA, Alberto M.
1654. REGULTO, Quirico
1655. REJUSO, Arthur
1656. RELLAMA, Raul D.
1657. RELLAMA, Toribio M.
1658. RELLOSA, Jaime
1659. RELOVA, Casiano M.
1660. REMO, Iluminado S.
1661. REMOQUILLO, Eugenio A.
1662. REMOQUILLO, Rodolfo A.
1663. REMOTO, Fidel O.
1664. REMOTO, Jesus O.
1665. RENTOZA, Gerardo
1666. RESPALL, Lucien M.
1667. RESVALLES, Isias
1668. RETANAN, Gaudencio R.
1669. RETENER, Tomas B.
1670. REY, Redentor C.
1671. REYES, Abner M.
1672. REYES, Alberto L.
1673. REYES, Alfredo S.
1674. REYES, Alvin C.
1675. REYES, Amable S.
1676. REYES, Benedicto F.
1677. REYES, Cesar C.
1678. REYES, Ernesto F.
1679. REYES, Florencio
1680. REYES, Gregorio B.
1681. REYES, Jacinto Jr., M.
1682. REYES, Jose A.
1683. REYES, Jose C.
1684. REYES, Maximo
1685. REYES, Neptali M.
1686. REYES, Nestor E.
1687. REYES, Pablo
1688. REYES, Rigor Y.
1689. REYES, Rizalino R.
1690. REYES, Rogelio G.
1691. REYES, Rolando G.
1692. REYES, Romeo B.
1693. REYES, Romeo S.
1694. REYES, Romulo M.
1695. REYES, Sergio L.
1696. REYES, Sisenando P.
1697. REYES, Solomon B.
1698. REYES, Vicente G.
1699. REYNOSO, Eugenio F.
1700. REYNOSO, Lindsey F.
1701. RICAZA, Virgilio G.
1702. RICO, Antonio F.
1703. RICO, Ernesto F.
1704. RICO, Fernando M.
1705. RIETA, Emmanuel S.
1706. RIETA, Ricardo V.
1707. RIETA, Rodelio G.
1708. RIETA, Rodelio Jr., V.
1709. RIVADA, Carlos A.
1710. RIVERA, Benito Jr.,
1711. RIVERA, Benjamin M.
1712. RIVERA, Jose M.
1713. RIVERA, Nilo S.
1714. RIVERA, Rogelio C.
1715. RIZAL, Nazario B.
1716. ROBALE, Edgardo C.
1717. ROBILLOS, Bernardo J.
1718. ROBLES, Leo B.
1719. ROBLES, Pablo A.
1720. ROBLES, Ruben
1721. ROBLEZA, Jose C.
1722. ROBLEZA, Rodolfo
1723. ROBLEZA, Rodrigo C.
1724. ROBLEZA, Rustico C.
1725. ROCABO, Eduardo
1726. RODRIGUEZ, Antonio R.
1727. RODRIGUEZ, Bernardo R.
1728. RODRIGUEZ, Eligio T.
1729. RODRIGUEZ, Henry A.
1730. RODRIGUEZ, Reynaldo B.
1731. RODRIGUEZ, Romeo B.
1732. ROMALES, Edgardo H.
1733. ROMEO, Almonte
1734. ROMERO, Abad Arturo C.
1735. RONA, Salvador T.
1736. RONDILLA, Ernesto J.
1737. RONQUILLO, Elias
1738. RONQUILLO, Elise
1739. RONQUILLO, Luis V.
1740. RONQUILLO, Rodolfo C.
1741. RONQUILLO, Segundino L.
1742. RONQUILO, Reynoso P.
1743. ROQUE, Avelino M.
1744. ROQUE, Gerardo R.
1745. ROQUILLO, Quirino
1746. ROSALES, Alfredo E.
1747. ROSALES, Angel P.
1748. ROSALES, Armando E.
1749. ROSALES, Mario E.
1750. ROSALES, Pido
1751. ROSALES, Ramon M.
1752. ROSARIO, Virgilio L.
1753. ROVELOS, Bernardino
1754. RUBIO, Wilfredo
1755. SA-ANOY, Ramon A.
1756. SABATIN, Honorio P.
1757. SABELITA, Santiago L.
1758. SABINO, Menandro L.
1759. SACDALAN, Reynaldo P.
1760. SACRO, Romeo A.
1761. SADDI, Emilio S
1762. SAGUI, Alexander T.
1763. SALAZAR, Edgardo
1764. SALGATAR, Pedro L.
1765. SALONGA, Edgardo
1766. SALONGA, Herminio P.
1767. SALTA, Avelino R.
1768. SALTA, Benjamin P.
1769. SALTA, Ernesto P.
1770. SALTA, Trinidad P.
1771. SALVADOR, Carlito R.
1772. SALVADOR, Domingo I.
1773. SALVADOR, Domingo Sr.
1774. SALVADOR, Ernesto I.
1775. SALVADOR, Melecio I.
1776. SALVADOR, Rogelio N.
1777. SALVADOR, Rolando I.
1778. SAMPARADA, Jose
1779. SAN JOSE, Nemesio S.
1780. SAN JOSE, Ricardo S.
1781. SAN JUAN, Edgardo I.
1782. SAN MATEO, Numeriano
1783. SAN PEDRO, Ernesto Z.
1784. SAN PEDRO, Rodolfo Z.
1785. SAN PEDRO, Rogelio Z.
1786. SANCHA, Adriano V.
1787. SANCHA, Geronimo M.
1788. SANCHEZ, Artemio B.
1789. SANCHEZ, Francisco F.
1790. SANCHEZ, Franklin G.
1791. SANCHEZ, Nicasio
1792. SANOHAN, Francisco F.
1793. SANOZA, Esteban B.
1794. SANSALIAN, Arturo A.
1795. SANSALIAN, Eduardo C.
1796. SANSALIAN, Lito
1797. SANSALIAN, Mario A.
1798. SANSALIAN, Rafael A.
1799. SANTA, Adriano
1800. SANTIAGO, Apolonio P.
1801. SANTIAGO, Celso G.
1802. SANTIAGO, Giovanni D.
1803. SANTIAGO, Joselito S.
1804. SANTIAGO, Rizalino T.
1805. SANTIAGO, Sergio
1806. SANTIAGO, Uldarico P.
1807. SANTOS, Arturo L.
1808. SANTOS, Dominador Jr., R.
1809. SANTOS, Edilberto G.
1810. SANTOS, Efren S.
1811. SANTOS, Gabriel S.
1812. SANTOS, Jose H.
1813. SANTOS, Juanito
1814. SANTOS, Luisito B.
1815. SANTOS, Nicanor
1816. SANTOS, Orlando S.
1817. SANTOS, Renato D.
1818. SANTOS, Wilfredo
1819. SAPUYOT, Miguel
1820. SARMIENTO, Ricardo M.
1821. SARMIENTO, Silvestre
1822. SATRE, Maximo Jr., L.
1823. SAYAS, Ricardo
1824. SENA, Jaime M.
1825. SENO, Quirino O.
1826. SERA, Roberto
1827. SERNA, Julian G.
1828. SERQUINA, Alex S.
1829. SERRA, Domnador
1830. SERRANO, Emiliano B.
1831. SERRANO, Ricardo
1832. SERVAN, Filomeno M.
1833. SIDRO, Romeo B.
1834. SIGUA, Fernando M.
1835. SILANG, Amado M.
1836. SILANG,Faustino D.
1837. SILVA, Aniceto G.
1838. SILVA, Edgardo M.
1839. SILVERIO, Arcadio Jr., C.
1840. SILVERIO, Rolando
1841. SIMBAJON, Arthur B.
1842. SOGUI, Alexander B.
1843. SOLANO, Domingo
1844. SOLANTE, Joselito C.
1845. SOLANTE, Paquito E.
1846. SOLETO, Norberto
1847. SOLIMAN, Erdy M.
1848. SOLIMAN, Francisco M.
1849. SOLIS, Carlito M.
1850. SOLIS, Conrado III G.
1851. SOLIS, Conrado Jr., A.
1852. SOLIS, Edgardo
1853. SOLIS, Ernesto M.
1854. SOLIS, Isagan M.
1855. SOMERA, Demetrio R.
1856. SORIANO, Nicanor V.
1857. SORIANO, Proceso M.
1858. SORONO, Hermogenes S.
1859. SORONO, Melquiades S.
1860. SOTTO, Eduardo L.
1861. STA. MARIA, Ernesto G.
1862. STELLA, Vicente D.
1863. STO. DOMINGO, Alberto
1864. SUAMEN, Rafael
1865. SUANSING, Rolando C.
1866. SUAZO, Antonio B.
1867. SULTAN, Rodolfo T.
1868. SUNGLAO, Mario
1869. SUPANG, Felimon R.
1870. TABADA, Jesus C.
1871. TABLAIN, Venancio
1872. TABLAN, Julio E.
1873. TABLAN, Pastor E.
1874. TABOSO, Amado M.
1875. TAFALLA, Adolfo D.
1876. TAGORDA, Anastacio Jr., J.
1877. TAGUINOD, Benjamin Jr.,
1878. TALATAC, Isaias
1879. TALATO, Gaudencio M.
1880. TALIBSAO, Maximino H.
1881. TALISAY, Navas
1882. TALUSIK, Felicisimo T.
1883. TALUTO, Gaudencio M.
1884. TAMAYO, Jaime C.
1885. TAMPELIX, Macario L.
1886. TAN, Joesus
1887. TANAG, Eleno C.
1888. TANAG, Leorino C.
1889. TANGUIA, Augusto B.
1890. TANGUINOO, Peter
1891. TAPIA, Tagumpay R.
1892. TAPIA, Vicente Jr., R.
1893. TARAYA, Aberto P.
1894. TARIMAN, Romeo T.
1895. TARUC, Fermin
1896. TARUC, Fermiso Jr.,
1897. TARUC, William
1898. TATING, Roberto T.
1899. TEBELIN, Teodulo O.
1900. TEMPLO, Henry
1901. TEMPLO, Levy S.
1902. TEMPLO, Teddy S.
1903. TEMPROSA, Menandro P.
1904. TEOSECO, Roman L.
1905. TESALONA, Bayani T.
1906. TIAMSIM, Ireneo
1907. TIAMZON, Rodolfo S.
1908. TIBUS, Nico V.
1909. TIBUS, Samson V.
1910. TIO, Norberto B.
1911. TIOSECO, Fidel L.
1912. TIPOSO, Leonilo
1913. TIU, Juan Jr., G.
1914. TOLENTINO, Amado S.
1915. TOLENTINO, Angel G.
1916. TOLENTINO, Arnel T.
1917. TOLENTINO, Bienvenido S.
1918. TOLENTINO, Domingo G.
1919. TOLENTINO, Mario M.
1920. TORRALBA, Felipe
1921. TORRALBA, Geronimo M.
1922. TORRES, Benedicto
1923. TORRES, Jovito V.
1924. TORRES, Maximiano Y.
1925. TORRES, Nemesio
1926. TORRES, Raymundo s
1927. TRA, Rogelio S.
1928. TRAVISON, Rodolfo S.
1929. TRESVALLES, Isias V.
1930. TRIAS, Antonio
1931. TRIAS, Francisco G.
1932. TRIAS, Renato S.
1933. TRILLANES, Rene M.
1934. TUAZON, Gavin U.
1935. TUNGCOL, Benedicto
1936. UBALDO, Placido C.
1937. UMALI, Francisco A.
1938. UNIDA, Simplicido
1939. UNIDAD, Reynaldo R.
1940. UNTALAN, Wilfredo V.
1941. UNTALAN, Willie
1942. URSOLINO, Sergio A.
1943. VALDERAMA, Antonio T.
1944. VALDERAMA, Ramon T.
1945. VALDEZ, Rogelio R.
1946. VALENCIANO, Nilo G.
1947. VALERA, Aniceto A.
1948. VALERO, Maximo A.
1949. VALES, Augusto L.
1950. VALLADA, Aurelio S
1951. VALLAR, Federico P.
1952. VALLARTA, Tomas Jr., L.
1953. VARGAS, Isaias V.
1954. VASQUEZ, Edgardo C.
1955. VEGA, Abraham
1956. VELASQUEZ, Benjamin
1957. VELASQUEZ, Constantino B
1958. VELASQUEZ, Elpidio B.
1959. VELASQUEZ, Mario M.
1960. VERDADERO, Eugenio C.
1961. VERDAN, Oscar A.
1962. VERGARA, Alfredo S.
1963. VERGARA, Bienvenido
1964. VERGARA, Ignacio P.
1965. VERGARA, Legorio S.
1966. VERGARA, Pedro
1967. VERNAL, Victorio
1968. VERNES, Mariano N.
1969. VERZONILLA, Rufino V.
1970. VERZOSA, Ramon R.
1971. VIAR, Guillermo E.
1972. VIAR, Romeo E.
1973. VICMUNDO, Felicito P.
1974. VICTORIA, Delfin V.
1975. VICTORIA, Gilbert
1976. VICTORIA, Jubert D.
1977. VICTORIANO, Alfredo
1978. VICTORIANO, Augusto
1979. VICTORIANO, Hermane
1980. VIDALLON , Teofilo P.
1981. VIENES, Sabino N.
1982. VIERNES, Mariano N.
1983. VILAROMAN, Rafael D.
1984. VILLA, Jesus J.
1985. VILLABLANCO, Joven
1986. VILLAFLORES, Edgardo G.
1987. VILLAFLORES, Francisco
1988. VILLAGERA, Ceferino
1989. VILLAHERMOSA, Alex
1990. VILLAHERMOSA, Domingo O.
1991. VILLALOBOS, Rolando C.
1992. VILLALUZ, Antonio
1993. VILLANUEVA, Carlito
1994. VILLANUEVA, Danilo A.
1995. VILLANUEVA, Danilo N.
1996. VILLANUEVA, Elito S.
1997. VILLANUEVA, Ernesto N.
1998. VILLANUEVA, Manuel N.
1999. VILLANUEVA, Rogelio R.
2000. VILLAR, Alfredo A.
2001. VILLAR, Nephtali D.
2002. VILLAR, Raul R.
2003. VILLARBA, Angel
2004. VILLAREAL, Jose V.
2005. VILLARINO, Felicisimo T.
2006. VILLARINO, Juanito P.
2007. VILLARINO, Leonardo
2008. VILLAROSA, Francisco M.
2009. VO, Herminio V.
2010. YANGLO, Alejandro M.
2011. YLAYA, Galileo C.
2012. YNGENTE, Vicente D.
2013. YULO, Buenaventura M.
2014. YUVIENGCO, Meynardo L.
2015. ZALAVARIA, Carlos R.
2016. ZAMORA, Primo B.
2017. ZARA, Francisco
2018. ZULUETA, Jose B.
2019. ZUNIGA, Oro C.
The Court cannot, however, award all the claims of these 2,019 petitioners. Let it be noted that the instant case is a continuation of the Cadalin case decided on December 5, 1994.42 In that earlier case, we dismissed the certiorari petitions assailing the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution. By dismissing the said petitions, in effect, we upheld the following dispositions of the NLRC:
1. Dismissing the claims of the 94 complainants identified and listed in Annex "A" for having prescribed;
2. Ordering BRII and AIBC to pay solidarily the claims of the 149 complainants identified and listed in Annex "B;"
3. Setting aside the awards given by the POEA to the 19 complainants classified and listed in Annex "C," who appear to have worked elsewhere than in Bahrain; and
4. Directing the Labor Arbiter to summon parties, conduct hearings and receive evidence, and thereafter submit a written report to the NLRC of the proceedings taken, regarding the claims of the complainants identified and listed in Annexes "D" and "E."43
With nothing standing in its way, the NLRC went on to implement the September 2, 1991 Resolution. Considering that the claims of the 94 complainants in Annex "A" were dismissed, and that those of the 19 complainants in Annex "C" were set aside, what was left for the labor tribunal to implement were: (1) the payment of the claims of the 149 complainants identified and listed in Annex "B"; and (2) the summoning of parties, the conduct of hearings and the reception of evidence regarding the claims of 683 complainants identified and listed in Annex "D" and of the 6944 complainants identified and listed in Annex "E" of the said 1991 Resolution, totaling 752.
The number ballooned from the 149 Annex "B" claimants and the 752 Annexes "D" and "E" claimants, to 2,019 petitioners in this petition, primarily because, during the 1997 to 2001 proceedings, petitioners’ counsel, through a Submission and Manifestational Motion dated July 7, 2000,45 included additional claimants by alleging that they were similarly situated as the Annexes "B," "D" and "E" complainants. The Court observed that out of the 2,019 petitioners in this case, 1,077 are first-time claimants–they are not parties in the earlier Cadalin case and they only asserted their claims during the 1997-2001 proceedings. These 1,077 first-time claimants are as follows:
1. ABACAN, Gerardo M.
2. ABADE, Ricardo B.
3. ABANDO, Alex B.
4. ABANDO, Gregorio
5. ABANO, Jovenal A.
6. ABANTE, Ariel B.
7. ABANTO, Nick
8. ABARCA, Felmon M.
9. ABILA, Fernando J.
10. ABOY, Ernesto M.
11. ABRL, Modesto M.
12. ABULON, Julian V.
13. ACAIN, Felipe C.
14. ACAN, Norberto G.
15. ACERO, Danny
16. ACHA, Rogelio B.
17. ACLAN, Efren
18. ACO, Rogelio A.
19. ACUNA, Manuel T.
20. ACUPAN, Benito
21. ACUPAN, Benjamin D.
22. ACUPAN, Juanito P.
23. ACUPAN, Maximiano A.
24. ACUPAN, Vicente A.
25. ADAJAR, Cesar L.
26. ADALIN, Gregorio
27. ADALLA, Gregorio
28. ADAWAG, Angel G.
29. ADAWAG, Carlito
30. ADAWAG, Cresenciano
31. ADAWAG, Noel P.
32. ADAWAG, Teodulfo
33. ADRAYAN, Alfredo B.
34. AGAPITO, Generoso M.
35. AGNE, Bernardo R.
36. AGNE, Rizalino R.
37. AGUADO, Aniceto A.
38. AGUBA, Restituto A.
39. AGUE, Florentino R.
40. AGUILA, Benjamin G.
41. AGUILA, Bernardo F.
42. AGUILA, Josue G.
43. AGUILA, Vicente G.
44. AGUILAR, Esperidion T.
45. AGUILAR, Francisco
46. AGUSTIN, Galicano D.
47. ALABAY, Agripino V.
48. ALABAY, Nestor M.
49. ALAGAD, Alfonso
50. ALAGAD, Bernardo F.
51. ALAGAD, Fernando
52. ALBINO, Septimo O.
53. ALBO, Alejandro R.
54. ALBURO, Orlando
55. ALCAIRA, Alexander R.
56. ALCALDE, Rolando A.
57. ALCANTARA, Jaime B.
58. ALCANTARA, Jesus M.
59. ALCANTARA, Mario C.
60. ALDEGUER, Federico Jr., T.
61. ALDEGUER, Jaime B.
62. ALDIANO, Ponciano C.
63. ALDOVER, Alfredo L.
64. ALEA, Diosdado A.
65. ALEGADA, Wilfredo
66. ALEJANDRE, Maximino R.
67. ALEJANDRE, Noel P.
68. ALEJANDRINO, Enrico I.
69. ALFECHE, Inocencio V.
70. ALFREDO, Teodolfo M.
71. ALHAMBRA, Cezar A.
72. ALINDAY, Tomas C.
73. ALMERO, Ernesto C.
74. ALMONTE, Romeo B.
75. ALMONTE, Virgilio B.
76. ALVAREZ, Alexander
77. ALVAREZ, Raul A.
78. ALVAREZ, Rolando S.
79. AMA, Pafico
80. AMBAL, Edmundo G.
81. AMBUNAN, Julian P.
82. AMPIL, Jose R.
83. AMUL, Sebastian B.
84. AMURAO, Crispulo Jr., C.
85. AMURAO, Crispulo Sr., T.
86. AMUTAN, Fernando L.
87. ANDAL, Danilo L.
88. ANDAMO, Carlos P.
89. ANDOY, Leopoldo R.
90. ANDRADA, Dan F.
91. ANDRADA, Simeon
92. ANDULAN, Reynaldo B.
93. ANG, Nestor V.
94. ANGELES, Geronimo H.
95. ANICETE, Beltranico S.
96. ANICETE, Romeo S.
97. ANIS, Bartolome B.
98. ANSALDO, Jose B.
99. APOLINARIO, Pepito
100. APUADO, Victorio C.
101. AQUINO, Abanes O.
102. AQUINO, Abner O.
103. AQUINO, Angel D.
104. AQUINO, Graciano M.
105. AQUINO, Jimmy B.
106. AQUINO, Ruben M.
107. ARACARIA, Alexander
108. ARANDELA, Percival L.
109. ARAYATA, Escolastico
110. ARCANGEL, Manuel DG.
111. AREVALO, Mario a.
112. ARGETE, Gavino M.
113. ARGUELLES, Alfredo
114. ARGUELLES, Angelito M.
115. ARGUELLES, Hermenigildo M.
116. ARONSE, Juanito P.
117. ARTITA, Rogelio S.
118. ASPER, Rodolfo M.
119. ASUNAN, Danilo R.
120. ASUNCION, Feliciano N.
121. ASUNCION, Rodolfo C.
122. ATIENZA, Carlito C.
123. ATIENZA, Jose R.
124. ATIENZA, Restituto A.
125. ATUD, Leonelito M.
126. AUSTRIA, Oscar M.
127. AVELLANA, Jose
128. AVUELTA, Ricardo Jr., P.
129. AXALAN, Loreto Jr.,
130. AXALAN, Marinao V.
131. AXALAN, Vicente R.
132. AZAGRA, Jaime A.
133. BABAEL, Sherlito S.
134. BABAGAY, Conrado T.
135. BABAGAY, Gerardo
136. BABASA, Wilhem S.
137. BACAMANTE, Virgilio A.
138. BACARAT, Paisal G.
139. BADUA, Emerito M.
140. BAES, Filoteo A.
141. BAGADIONG, Guillermo T.
142. BAGADIONG, Noel S.
143. BAGASIN, Lamilo A.
144. BALABALO, Luis
145. BALANTE, Geronimo
146. BALBICRAN, Gerardo R.
147. BALBIERAN, Anatalio B.
148. BALBIERAN, Maximo C.
149. BALBIERAN, Romeo B.
150. BALBIRAN, Fernando B.
151. BALCOBA, Federico B.
152. BALINAS, Pablo G.
153. BALINGIT, Rodolfo F.
154. BALIWAG, Cesario H.
155. BARASARI, Rizal
156. BARCENA, Fidel F.
157. BARIN, Rodolfo
158. BARLENA, Fidel F.
159. BARLENA, Florentino
160. BAROLA, Abdon V.
161. BARTIDO, Leonardo
162. BARTOLOME, Marcelo
163. BARZAGA, Vivencio T.
164. BASMAYOR, Artemio A.
165. BASTRO, Reynaldo U.
166. BATAIN, Romeo
167. BATICA, Ernesto Sr., S.
168. BATICA, Hobino O.
169. BATINGA, Elueterio P.
170. BAUAN, Victoriano A.
171. BAUTISTA, Ceferino O.
172. BAUTISTA, Emegdio P.
173. BAUTISTA, Irene P.
174. BAUTISTA, Mamerto S.
175. BAYA, Inoncencio
176. BAYACAL, Venancio Jr., V.
177. BAYLON, Lolito F.
178. BELTRAN, Ebrulfo G.
179. BELTRAN, Largion G.
180. BENITEZ, Jovito N.
181. BERNAL, Victorio
182. BERSAMIN, Dindo L.
183. BERWITE, Renato P.
184. BICOL, Cesario M.
185. BICOL, Florentino L.
186. BIGADION, Noel S.
187. BISCOCHO, Eleuterio B.
188. BLANCO, Alberto B.
189. BLANCO, Virgilio
190. BLAS, Rogelio
191. BLAY, Nestor M.
192. BLAY, Rodrigo M.
193. BOADO, Elpidio A.
194. BOBADILLA, Cesar
195. BOBADILLA, Danilo A.
196. BOBADILLA, Laudico A.
197. BODADILLA, Cesar A.
198. BODADILLA, Danilo A.
199. BOLANTE, Geronimo E.
200. BOLANTE, Gil I.
201. BOLISAY, Carlito M.
202. BONDOC, Benito U.
203. BONGT, Domingo S.
204. BOQUIREN, Arnulfo Jr., M.
205. BORDILLA, Eresto J.
206. BORNALES, Ricardo C.
207. BRACAMANTE, Virgilio A.
208. BRAGAIS, Demetrio B.
209. BRAGANZA, Norberto E.
210. BRAVO, Tinioso S.
211. BRIONES, Tranquilino Y.
212. BROTONEL, Ceferino G.
213. BRUCE, Cesar B.
214. BUENAFE, Tomas V.
215. BUENAVENTURA, Ruperto Jr., E.
216. BUENTE, Tomas
217. BUGAY, Reynaldo D.
218. BULAMBAO, Buenaventura D.
219. BULANHAGUI, Ariel F.
220. BULATAO, Alfredo G.
221. BULLECER, Rodolfo R.
222. BUNAO, Isabelo M.
223. BUNGAY, Avenilo
224. BUNGAY, Jefferson Q.
225. BUSTAMANTE, Jose G.
226. CAALIM, Benito T.
227. CAALIM, Romeo T.
228. CABALLERO, Jacinto B.
229. CABIGAN, Rosendo Z.
230. CABILANGAN, Pablo G.
231. CABRERA, Jose D.
232. CABUHAT, Reynaldo T.
233. CAHIGAS, Nestor B.
234. CAILES, Dorito A.
235. CALADO, Fernando M.
236. CALCENA, Isagani
237. CALMA, Alejandro Jr., P.
238. CALMA, Fernando R.
239. CALMA, Jerry D.
240. CALMA, Miguel M.
241. CALURA, Joven C.
242. CALURA, Renato R.
243. CAMANAG, Sotero P.
244. CANDOR, Irmer L.
245. CANTOS, Geronimo M.
246. CANTOS, Primitivo
247. CAPACETE, Ramon Jr., G.
248. CAPARAS, Gaspar V.
249. CAPONPON, Ricardo
250. CARLOS, Narciso
251. CARTEL, Jose H.
252. CASA, Crisendo
253. CASADO, Emmanuelito P.
254. CASINO, Renato
255. CASTANARES, Dalmacio R.
256. CASTELO, Elias Jr., D.
257. CASTILLO, Arnel L.
258. CASTILLO, Emeterio L.
259. CASTILLO, Ferdinand L.
260. CASTILLO, Leonicio B.
261. CASTILLO, Lourdino M.
262. CASTILLO, Mario E.
263. CASTILLO, Nardito M.
264. CASTILLO, Natalio L.
265. CASTILLO, Nestor
266. CASTILLO, Vidal J.
267. CASTRO, Cesar M.
268. CASTRO, Crisaldo M.
269. CATAPANG, Conrado M.
270. CATAPANG, Ireneo
271. CATIBOG, Pepito M.
272. CATIBOG, Rodolfo
273. CATIPAN, Dominador D.
274. CATUD, Conrado A.
275. CAY, Prumencio F.
276. CAYANAN, Francisco D.
277. CENENA, Nestor
278. CENTURA, Gorgonio C.
279. CEREZO, Elmo A.
280. CERRO, Camilo C.
281. CETES, Henry
282. CHAN, Generoso M.
283. CHAVEZ, Cesar A.
284. CHUA, Cecilio H.
285. CIFRA, Hernan N.
286. CIFRA, Vicente C.
287. CLARETE, Vienvenido
288. CLAUD, Crizaldo D.
289. CLAVIO, Bienvenido M.
290. COCJIN, Jose Jr., B.
291. COMPLE, Damiano S.
292. CONCEPCION, Manuel Jr., C.
293. CONCEPCION, Virgilio C.
294. CONSTANTINO, Rolando A.
295. CONTEMPRATO, Lauro G.
296. CONTI, Bayani
297. CONTI, Edmundo C.
298. CONTI, Reynaldo C.
299. CORDERO, Mari F.
300. CORDOVA, Carlos Jr., V.
301. CORNISTA, Rino T.
302. CORNISTA, Romeo G.
303. CORONADO, Alfonso S.
304. CORTEJO, Joel O.
305. CORTEMPRATO, Cesar
306. CORTEZ, Eedgardo D.
307. COSINO, Renato R.
308. COSINO, Sofronio B.
309. COSTALES, Felipe Sr., B.
310. CREDITO, Enrico R.
311. CRISOSTOMO, Igmedio Jr., G.
312. CRUES, Teodulfo G.
313. CRUZ, Arturo I.
314. CRUZ, Augusto B.
315. CRUZ, Danilo M.
316. CRUZ, Ernesto
317. CRUZ, Hilario C.
318. CRUZ, Rodelio
319. CRUZ, Rodolfo B.
320. CUDAL, Raymundo
321. CUENCO, Edeltrudo F.
322. CUENCO, Edgar F.
323. CUESTINO, Victorino
324. CUEVAS, Abdon S.
325. CUEVAS, Manuel C.
326. CULLERA, Manuel M.
327. CUNANAN, Mario I.
328. CUSAP, Ernesto O.
329. CUSTODIO, Eduardo G.
330. DACASIN, Danilo B.
331. DACASIN, Fernando B.
332. DALUZ, Nicolas
333. DATAAN, Teodoro C.
334. DATAN, Jose C.
335. DATAY, Andres F.
336. DATINGUINOO, Desiderio A.
337. DAVID, Adolfo
338. DAYANDAYAN, Tomestocles
339. DAYANGHIRANG, Rufino T.
340. DAYRIT, Leonardo S.
341. DAYRIT, Victoriano C.
342. DE ADE, Bayani R.
343. DE CASTRO, Cristobal L.
344. DE CASTRO, Primitivo L.
345. DE CASTRO, Rene T.
346. DE CHAVEZ, Pedro
347. DE DIOS, Cesar J.
348. DE GUZMAN, Benedicto N.
349. DE GUZMAN, Donato
350. DE GUZMAN, Rolando F.
351. DE LEMON, Victorio SR., R.
352. DE LEMOS, Victoria
353. DE LEON, Dominador A.
354. DE LEON, Enrique C.
355. DE LEON, Ernesto C.
356. DE RAMA, Falconery R.
357. DE RAMA, Federico J.
358. DE TORRES, Arnulfo
359. DE TORRES, Nemesio A.
360. DE VERA, Marciano D.
361. DE VERA, Marciano V.
362. DE VERA, Reynaldo M.
363. DE VILLA, Rodolfo C.
364. DEL MUNDO, Danilo L.
365. DEL MUNDO, Walfredo L.
366. DEL PILAR, Lorencio
367. DEL PRADO, Vicente P.
368. DEL RIO, Pastor
369. DEL ROSARIO, Alfredo
370. DEL ROSARIO, Cesar S.
371. DEL ROSARIO, Guerero
372. DEL ROSARIO,. Vedasto
373. DELA CRUZ, Edgar R.
374. DELA CRUZ, Federico N.
375. DELA CRUZ, Juan R.
376. DELA CRUZ, Marcelino G.
377. DELA CRUZ, Rodelio
378. DELA CRUZ, Walfredo B.
379. DELA PENA, Doroteo
380. DELA VEGA, Abraham
381. DELBORO, Joselito T.
382. DELGADO, Rufino M.
383. DELLOSA, Joselito Fidel T.
384. DELOS REYES, Eusebio I.
385. DELOS REYES, Silverio Sr., V.
386. DELOS SANTOS, Emaldo D.
387. DELOS SANTOS, Serafin A.
388. DENIEGA, Juanito F.
389. DIAZ, Antonio R.
390. DIAZ, Ernesto E.
391. DIAZ, Renato B.
392. DIAZ, Telesforo M.
393. DIMAANO, Rodolfo M.
394. DIMAAPI, Romeo P.
395. DIMAPILIS, Leoncio I.
396. DIMATATAC, Jose A.
397. DIMATATAC, Romulo
398. DIMAULATAN, Vivencio C.
399. DIMAYUGA, Luis
400. DINGLASAN, Aniano M.
401. DISINGANIO, Domingo J.
402. DOMINGO, Rodolfo
403. DUAG. Elpidio I.
404. DUMAGUIN, Saturnino H.
405. DUMALI, Felipe
406. DURANA, Ceferino
407. EBRADA, Gilberto
408. ELIAS, Carlito
409. ELISAN, Ristituto
410. EMMAN, Johnny M.
411. ENCANTO, Jose T.
412. ENGALLA, Jaime M.
413. ENGON, Vicente
414. ENGUERO, Elmer F.
415. ENRIQUEZ, Rolando G.
416. ESCARILLA, Ramon Jr. T.
417. ESCARILLO, Wilfredo
418. ESCOTA, Gilberto B.
419. ESEO, Ernesto Sr., A.
420. ESPANOL, Miguel L.
421. ESPARAGO, Noel
422. ESPINA, Pascual F.
423. ESPINA, Robert
424. ESPINO, Arturo B.
425. ESPINO, Edgardo B.
426. ESPINO, Honorio E.
427. ESPINO, Horacio
428. ESPINO, Silverio D.
429. ESPINOSA, Policapio C.
430. ESPINOSA, Teodoro
431. ESPIRITU, Gregorio S.
432. ESPIRITU, Ildefonso R.
433. ESPIRITU, Leonardo Jr., A.
434. ESPIRITU, Rodolfo S.
435. ESTACIO, Bob L.
436. ESTACIO, Romeo P.
437. ESTANDARTE, Dioscoro
438. ESTRADA, Feliciano E.
439. ESTRELLA, Geronimo
440. ETCHON, Reynaldo D.
441. ETCHON, Reynaldo O.
442. EVANGELISTA, Antonio S.
443. EVANGELISTA, Donato
444. EVANGELISTA, Eduardo M.
445. EVANGELISTA, Rolando
446. FABABIER, Manuel M.
447. FACTORAN, Felicisimo D.
448. FAJARDO, Efren G.
449. FAJARDO, Pedro E.
450. FALLER, Reynaldo C.
451. FALTADO, Ruben
452. FARAON, Ciriaco
453. FEDERICO, Abundio B.
454. FERIA, Carino
455. FERNANDEZ, Agaton B.
456. FERNANDEZ, Jose Celedonio L.
457. FERNANDEZ, Serman O.
458. FERNANDO, Leonardo S.
459. FERNANDZ, Ely E.
460. FERRER, Cenon
461. FERRER, Leopoldo S.
462. FIRMA, Rizaldo F.
463. FLORES, Agapito C.
464. FLORESCA, Eligio B.
465. FRAGADA, Gregorio
466. FRAMIL, Rosauro R.
467. FRANCIA, Isabelito P.
468. FRANCISCO, Cornelio Y.
469. FRANCISCO, Edgardo J.
470. FRANCISCO, Framil
471. FRANCISCO, Mario B.
472. FRANE, Philbert M.
473. FRANZUELA, Ildefonso M.
474. FURTO, Reynaldo L.
475. FURTO, Wenfredo L.
476. GABAY, Castaniro
477. GALLARDO, Wilfredo A.
478. GALVEZ, Romeo A.
479. GAMMAD, Potenciano D.
480. GAMUTAN, Irobengito M.
481. GANAS, Hilario M.
482. GARCIA, Alfredo Jr.,
483. GARCIA, Angelito P.
484. GARCIA, Bernardino N.
485. GARCIA, Digno P.
486. GARCIA, Ermando M.
487. GARCIA, Esmeraldo N.
488. GARCIA, R.E.
489. GASCON, Rolando
490. GATCHALIAN, Ernesto E.
491. GATCHALIAN, Jose
492. GATULAYAO, Conrado
493. GAWAN, Jose A.
494. GAYA, Jose M.
495. GAYA, Leonardo T.
496. GELLID, Manol F.
497. GELLIDO, Ernesto D.
498. GEMOTO, Roberto
499. GENEROSO, Agapito
500. GERONIMO, Julio M.
501. GERONIMO, Roberto A.
502. GOMEZ, Patricio Jr., V.
503. GONZALES, Domingo A.
504. GONZALES, Eduardo B.
505. GONZALES, Jaime B.
506. GONZALES, Lamberto C.
507. GONZALES, Manuel S.
508. GONZALES, Norberto
509. GONZALES, Regino M.
510. GOPEZ, Armando S.
511. GOTANA, Edgardo Z.
512. GRAJERA, Florante E.
513. GRULLO, Jorge T.
514. GUANZON, Narciso D.
515. GUEVARA, Rosendo M.
516. GUINARES, Oscar L.
517. GUINTO, Isagani S.
518. GUITANG, Rodolfo C.
519. HALCON, Danilo
520. HERMOSO, Roberto
521. HERNANDEZ, Angelito
522. HERNANDEZ, Armando S.
523. HERNANDEZ, Julio A.
524. HERNANDEZ, Napoleon
525. HILADO, Manuel D.
526. HILADO, Mario D.
527. HILARIO, Winfredo P.
528. HINGALA, Felismo
529. HLARIO, Expedito
530. HOLGADO, Rodrigo C.
531. HUGGINS, Wilfredo M.
532. ILAGAN, Pedro
533. ILAGAN, Teofilo M.
534. ILOG, Vicente M.
535. INALVES, Victor S.
536. INASIANG, Santiago
537. INSIGNE, Conrado A.
538. ISIDORO, Rodolfo D.
539. JACLA, Floriano V.
540. JACOB, Victor M.
541. JANACO, Alejandro M.
542. JARDINIANO, Rolando V.
543. JARO, Ferdinand
544. JARO, Romeo M.
545. JAUDALSO, Roberto E.
546. JAVIER, Antonio C.
547. JAVIER, Conrado N.
548. JAVIER, Ernesto
549. JIMENA, Angelico Jr., B.
550. JOCACA, Pedro
551. JOCO, Rustico P.
552. JOLOYA, Claro
553. JONAS, Abelardo E.
554. JOSEF, Petronillo L.
555. JOYA, Rodolfo E.
556. JUCAR, Cesar G.
557. JUSTO, Renato E.
558. KAMATOY, Arnaldo P.
559. LABAYO, Leonardo
560. LABING, Arcadio T.
561. LABRADOR, Floro A.
562. LABRAMONTE, Jose R.
563. LAGAC, Felipe R.
564. LAGANAPAN, Sandy P.
565. LAJOM, Eliseo T.
566. LAKIAN, Arsenio F.
567. LANDICHO, Constancio R.
568. LATOJA, Domingo D.
569. LATOJA, Juanito D.
570. LAURE, Antonio S.
571. LAYON, Edgar
572. LEANO, Felix
573. LEOOR, Meinardo M.
574. LEYESA, Teodoro M.
575. LEYNES, Luisito
576. LICAROS, Luzvimindo F.
577. LINSANGAN, Rosanno S.
578. LISING, Arcadio T.
579. LISING, Esmeraldo S.
580. LLANERA, Rodrigo G.
581. LOGAN, Arnel I.
582. LOGRONIO, Claro A.
583. LOGRONIO, Clemente A.
584. LOGRONIO, Cornelio A.
585. LOGUC, Felipe R.
586. LOGUINACIO, Edwin C.
587. LONTOK, Rogelio L.
588. LOPENA, David C.
589. LOPENA, Nicanor C.
590. LOPEZ, Lamberto
591. LOPEZ, Larry
592. LOPEZ, Nicanor D.
593. LOPEZ, Rodrigo M.
594. LOQUINARIO, Edwin C.
595. LOZA, Crisostomo
596. LUAGE, Henry A.
597. LUALHATI, Ramon C.
598. LUBIAN, Rubinato A.
599. LUCEA, Ronito E.
600. LUKBAN, Narciso H.
601. LUMANGLAS, Armando G.
602. LUMANGLAS, Eleodoro A.
603. LUNA, Vicente
604. LUSUNG, Onofre M.
605. MAAMO, Bernardino C.
606. MAAMO, Manuel J.
607. MAAMO, Victoriano
608. MAAMO, Victorio
609. MACABEBE, Leonides R.
610. MACALALAD, Victor B.
611. MACALDO, Victor C.
612. ACALINTALA, Jose T.
613. MACARAEG, Irineo
614. MACARAEG, Nestor
615. MACARAIG, Aurelio S.
616. MACARAIG, Bienvenido
617. MACARAIG, Efren C.
618. MACARAIG, Nestor C.
619. MACATANGAY, Basilio M.
620. MACATANGAY, Buenaventura A.
621. MACATANGAY, Juan H.
622. MACATANGAY, Napoleon A.
623. MACATANGAY, Nicolas A.
624. MACATANGAY, Remegio
625. MACATANGAY, Ricardo M.
626. MACATANGAY, Romeo
627. MACATANGAY, Sofronio M.
628. MAESTRE, Felicito C.
629. MAGANAYE, Rencel B.
630. MAGANO, Marcos L.
631. MAGAT, Abeardo S.
632. MAGNAYE, Ernesto L.
633. MAGNAYE, Ranerio M.
634. MAGNAYE, Renato M.
635. MAGNAYE, Venancio L.
636. MAGNAYE, Victorino R.
637. MAGNO, Boyet
638. MAGNO, Camilo B.
639. MAGNO, Danilo B.
640. MAGNO, Oscar R.
641. MAGNO, Romeo B.
642. MAGPANTAY, Francisco V.
643. MAGSINO, Rolando
644. MAGTIBAY, Macario
645. MAISOG, Ceferino G.
646. MAISOG, David A.
647. MALABANAN, Romeo B.
648. MALIPOL, Ricky
649. MALONZO, Marcelo G.
650. MANAGHAYA, Isagani
651. MANALAC, Remegio S.
652. MANALILI, Rogelio
653. MANALO, Danilo M.
654. MANALO, Jose M.
655. MANANGHAYA, Isagani S.
656. MANANGUIT, Romulo L.
657. MANAS, Cesar A.
658. MANDAYAO, Vicente
659. MANDIGMA, David A.
660. MANEBO, Noel M.
661. MANIEGO, Noel M.
662. MANIEGO, Vidal A.
663. MANIGBAS, Benjamin
664. MANIGOS, Pablo Sr., R.
665. MANIGOS, Paquito R.
666. MANINGAS, Fermin
667. MANINGAS, Teodolfo D.
668. MANIVAL, Enrico S.
669. MANSINARES, Leopoldo B.
670. MANUAL, Demetrio P.
671. MANUAL, Domingo C.
672. MANUAL, Enrique
673. MANUAL, Marcelo K.
674. MANUAL, Marciano C.
675. MANUBA, Angelito T.
676. MANUBAG, Lito C.
677. MANUEL, Marcelo
678. MARANIAG, Normandy
679. MARASIGAN, Basilio V.
680. MARASIGAN, Delfin M.
681. MARASIGAN, Hilario M.
682. MARASIGAN, Rodolfo P.
683. MARCELO, Mario L.
684. MARCELO, Serafin M.
685. MARCIADA, Rolando
686. MARIANO, Armando T.
687. MARIANO, Federico S.
688. MARIANO, Marlon L.
689. MARIANO, Narciso T.
690. MARIANO, Navarro D.
691. MARPURI, Rodolfo C.
692. MARQUEZ, Bayani A.
693. MARQUEZ, Carlos A.
694. MARQUEZ, Celso M.
695. MARQUEZ, Romeo
696. MARSIGAN, Wenceslao
697. MARTINEZ, Reynaldo S.
698. MARTINEZ, Rodolfo C.
699. MATA, Paolo M.
700. MATI, Conrado L.
701. MATIENZO, Amadeo
702. MATIENZO, Salvador R.
703. MATITO, Leonardo N.
704. MEDINA, Augusto C.
705. MEDINA, Cipriano R.
706. MEDINA, Florante L.
707. MEDINA, Jaime L.
708. MEDINA, Jesse L.
709. MEDINA, Mario L.
710. MEDINILLA, Marshal M.
711. MEDIODIA, Francis M.
712. MEDIOLA, Ely M.
713. MELENDEZ, Napoleon O.
714. MELLIANG, Alfredo
715. MENDOZA, Benjamin L.
716. MENDOZA, Jenrin
717. MENDOZA, Jose C.
718. MENDOZA, Manolito D.
719. MENDOZA, Miguel C.
720. MENDOZA, Ramiro A.
721. MENDOZA, Romeo T.
722. MENDOZA, Teofilo R.
723. MENDOZA, Virgilio V.
724. MENOR, Cresente S.
725. MERCADO, Conrado Jr., C.
726. MERCADO, Francisco
727. MERCADO, Oscar S.
728. MERCADO, Patricio H.
729. MERCADO, Primitivo H.
730. MERCADO, Reynaldo E.
731. MERCADO, Ricardo B.
732. MERCADO, Romeo
733. MERCADO, Valdemor C.
734. MERCADO, Virgilio S.
735. MERIDA, Elias H.
736. MICLAT, Eduardo R.
737. MILANES, Joejie N.
738. MINIMO, Elueterio V.
739. MINIMO, Hernando G.
740. MIRALES, Arnaldo I.
741. MIRANDA, Alfredo P.
742. MIRANDA, Ruben H.
743. MOGOL, Noel M.
744. MOLINA, Rogelio D.
745. MONTECINES, Juanito O.
746. MONZON, Celso N.
747. MONZON, Cosme B.
748. MORADA, Rodrigo
749. MORAL, Nestor K.
750. MORATILLO, Victorino O.
751. MORENO, Alfredo
752. MORTEL, Delfin M.
753. MOSUELA, Carlito C.
754. MUNDO, Jessie
755. MUNDO, Rufino Jr.,
756. MUNOZ, Jose P.
757. NAJERA, Angel C.
758. NAPIZA, Juanito N.
759. NAPIZA, Lamberto R.
760. NAPIZA, Salvador
761. NAPIZA, Wilfredo L.
762. NAPOLAN, Ernesto C.
763. NARCISO, Benjamin B.
764. NARCISO, Carlos G.
765. NARCISO, Meliton B.
766. NARCISO, Narciso L.
767. NATALIA, Edwin B.
768. NATIVIDAD, Samuel N.
769. NAVARRO, Mariano D.
770. NEPOMUCENO, Isidro M.
771. NER, Valente Jr., T.
772. NOFUENTE, Mabini M.
773. NOGUERA, Rodolfo M.
774. OBANA, Marcial L.
775. OBIAS, Romeo M.
776. OCHOA, Lorenzito H.
777. OCTAVIANO, Francisco
778. OCTAVIO, Carlito P.
779. ODESA, Antonio L.
780. OFICIAR, Gideon S.
781. OLAES, Romulo W.
782. OLARTE, Gregorio E.
783. OLEDAN, Luis
784. OLIMBA, German V.
785. OLIVIAGA, Noel T.
786. ONGKIKI, Leopoldo M.
787. OPEZ, Vicente S.
788. ORDAS, Reynaldo N.
789. ORINE, Cipriano T.
790. ORTEGA, Antonio V.
791. OVERA, Abelardo F.
792. PACANZA, Federico C.
793. PACHO, Ernie
794. PACIFICO, Navarro Jr., D.
795. PADILLA, Jesus N.
796. PADUA, Rufino C.
797. PAEZ, Erlando P.
798. PAGADUAN, Beneficto V.
799. PAGLICAUAN, Mario M.
800. PAGUIO, Carlito
801. PAJARES, Antonio V.
802. PALASIN, Sebastian D.
803. PALIMA, Aniceto C.
804. PALMA, Ricardo M.
805. PALOMA, Abelardo E.
806. PALPAL-LATOC, Jose A.
807. PANGAN, Javier M.
808. PANGANIBAN, Francisco D.
809. PANGAYAO, Felipe P.
810. PANGGAT, Regidor M.
811. PARAS, Joel
812. PARUNGAO, Antonio D.
813. PASAMBA, Waldemar S.
814. PASCUA, Eduardo C.
815. PASCUAL Isagani M.
816. PASCUAL, Edmundo V.
817. PASIONA, Ireneo G.
818. PAYRA, Jose I.
819. PAYRA, Luisito S.
820. PEDRIGUERA, Fernando
821. PELLAS, Chester
822. PENA, Antero F.
823. PENILLA, Carlos
824. PEPITO, Lope T.
825. PERAN, Rodrigo P.
826. PEREA, Francisco L.
827. PEREA, Juanito L.
828. PEREA, Olimpio T.
829. PEREGRINA, Leopoldo M.
830. PERENO, Fernando
831. PEREZ, Arnel
832. PEREZ, Carmelito L.
833. PEREZ, Danilo M.
834. PEREZ, Dionisio M.
835. PEREZ, Efren G.
836. PEREZ, Jimmy
837. PERIGIL, Cenon P.
838. PESCO, Alberto T.
839. PIELAGO, Eleodoro A.
840. PILLAJERA, Tomas Jr., B.
841. PINILI, Victorio E.
842. PINTO, Romeo A.
843. PITAO, Mateo F.
844. PLAMERAS, Rogelio C.
845. PLANTA, Ariel I.
846. PLATA, Paciencio M.
847. PONIEG, Bernardo Q.
848. PORTUGAL, Norberto D.
849. PORTUGUEZ, Laureano C.
850. PRIMERO, Angelito G.
851. PRIMO, Leonardo
852. PRIVADO,Pederico R.
853. PUNAY, Cornelio F.
854. PUNIO, Gregorio F.
855. PUNZALAN, Wilfredo D.
856. PURISIMA, Rogelio P.
857. QUEBRAL, Joselito C
858. QUIABO, Roberto C.
859. QUINTO, Juanito M.
860. QUITEVIS, Elpidio R.
861. QUOBO, Roberto
862. RABANO, Benjamin D.
863. RABINO, Desiderio R.
864. RAMELO, Joselito F.
865. RAMIREZ, Ildefonso R.
866. RAMIREZ, Lirio C.
867. RAMIREZ, Luis A.
868. RAMOS, Emeterio P.
869. RAMOS, Jose N.
870. RAMOS, Leoncio
871. RAMOS, Manolito V.
872. RAMOS, Nomer M.
873. RAMOS, Oscar B.
874. RAMOS, Roque A.
875. RANADA, Jose G.
876. RANADA, Pepito C.
877. RANGEL, Ponciano P.
878. RAVELAS, Federico
879. RAVELAS, Larry
880. RAVELAS, Lorenzo D.
881. RAVELAS, Rodrigo
882. RAVELAS, Rogelio R.
883. RAVELAS, Teodorico R.
884. RAYA, Romeo S.
885. RAYMUNDO, Ricardo E.
886. REBONG, Albert E.
887. RECOLIZADO, Bienvenido B.
888. REGULTO, Quirico
889. RELLAMA, Raul D.
890. RELOVA, Casiano M.
891. REMO, Iluminado S.
892. REMOQUILLO, Rodolfo A.
893. REMOTO, Jesus O.
894. RESVALLES, Isias
895. REYES, Abner M.
896. REYES, Alberto L.
897. REYES, Cesar C.
898. REYES, Ernesto F.
899. REYES, Florencio
900. REYES, Jacinto Jr., M.
901. REYES, Maximo
902. REYES, Neptali M.
903. REYES, Nestor E.
904. REYES, Pablo
905. REYES, Rigor Y.
906. REYES, Rogelio G.
907. REYES, Romeo B.
908. REYES, Romeo S.
909. REYES, Sisenando P.
910. REYES, Vicente G.
911. REYNOSO, Eugenio F.
912. REYNOSO, Lindsey F.
913. RICO, Antonio F.
914. RIVADA, Carlos A.
915. RIVERA, Benjamin M.
916. RIVERA, Jose M.
917. RIVERA, Nilo S.
918. RIVERA, Rogelio C.
919. RIZAL, Nazario B.
920. ROBALE, Edgardo C.
921. ROBLEZA, Rustico C.
922. RODRIGUEZ, Henry A.
923. RODRIGUEZ, Reynaldo B.
924. RODRIGUEZ, Romeo B.
925. ROMERO, Abad Arturo C.
926. RONA, Salvador T.
927. RONDILLA, Ernesto J.
928. ROQUE, Gerardo R.
929. ROSALES, Alfredo E.
930. ROSALES, Armando E.
931. ROSALES, Mario E.
932. ROSALES, Pido
933. ROVELOS, Bernardino
934. RUBIO, Wilfredo
935. SA-ANOY, Ramon A.
936. SABATIN, Honorio P.
937. SABELITA, Santiago L.
938. SACDALAN, Reynaldo P.
939. SACRO, Romeo A.
940. SADDI, Emilio S
941. SAGUI, Alexander T.
942. SALAZAR, Edgardo
943. SALONGA, Herminio P.
944. SALTA, Avelino R.
945. SALTA, Benjamin P.
946. SALTA, Ernesto P.
947. SALTA, Trinidad P.
948. SALVADOR, Domingo I.
949. SALVADOR, Domingo Sr.
950. SALVADOR, Ernesto I.
951. SALVADOR, Melecio I.
952. SALVADOR, Rogelio N.
953. SALVADOR, Rolando I.
954. SAN JOSE, Nemesio S.
955. SAN JUAN, Edgardo I.
956. SAN PEDRO, Rodolfo Z.
957. SAN PEDRO, Rogelio Z.
958. SANCHEZ, Franklin G.
959. SANOZA, Esteban B.
960. SANSALIAN, Arturo A.
961. SANSALIAN, Eduardo C.
962. SANSALIAN, Lito
963. SANSALIAN, Mario A.
964. SANSALIAN, Rafael A.
965. SANTA, Adriano
966. SANTIAGO, Celso G.
967. SANTIAGO, Giovanni D.
968. SANTIAGO, Rizalino T.
969. SANTIAGO, Uldarico P.
970. SANTOS, Arturo L.
971. SANTOS, Dominador Jr., R.
972. SANTOS, Jose H.
973. SANTOS, Luisito B.
974. SANTOS, Nicanor
975. SANTOS, Orlando S.
976. SANTOS, Wilfredo
977. SARMIENTO, Ricardo M.
978. SATRE, Maximo Jr., L.
979. SAYAS, Ricardo
980. SENA, Jaime M.
981. SENO, Quirino O.
982. SERA, Roberto
983. SERNA, Julian G.
984. SERRANO, Emiliano B.
985. SERRANO, Ricardo
986. SERVAN, Filomeno M.
987. SIGUA, Fernando M.
988. SILVERIO, Arcadio Jr., C.
989. SOGUI, Alexander B.
990. SOLETO, Norberto
991. SOLIMAN, Erdy M.
992. SOLIMAN, Francisco M.
993. SOMERA, Demetrio R.
994. SORIANO, Proceso M.
995. SORONO, Hermogenes S.
996. SORONO, Melquiades S.
997. SUAMEN, Rafael
998. SUANSING, Rolando C.
999. SUAZO, Antonio B.
1000. SUNGLAO, Mario
1001. TABADA, Jesus C.
1002. TABLAIN, Venancio
1003. TABLAN, Julio E.
1004. TABLAN, Pastor E.
1005. TABOSO, Amado M.
1006. TAFALLA, Adolfo D.
1007. TAGORDA, Anastacio Jr., J.
1008. TAGUINOD, Benjamin Jr.,
1009. TALATO, Gaudencio M.
1010. TALISAY, Navas
1011. TALUTO, Gaudencio M.
1012. TAMAYO, Jaime C.
1013. TAMPELIX, Macario L.
1014. TAN, Joesus
1015. TANAG, Eleno C.
1016. TANAG, Leorino C.
1017. TAPIA, Tagumpay R.
1018. TAPIA, Vicente Jr., R.
1019. TARAYA, Aberto P.
1020. TARIMAN, Romeo T.
1021. TARUC, Fermiso Jr.,
1022. TATING, Roberto T.
1023. TEBELIN, Teodulo O.
1024. TEMPLO, Teddy S.
1025. TEOSECO, Roman L.
1026. TESALONA, Bayani T.
1027. TIAMSIM, Ireneo
1028. TIBUS, Nico V.
1029. TIBUS, Samson V.
1030. TIO, Norberto B.
1031. TIOSECO, Fidel L.
1032. TIU, Juan Jr., G.
1033. TOLENTINO, Angel G.
1034. TOLENTINO, Domingo G.
1035. TORRALBA, Geronimo M.
1036. TORRES, Nemesio
1037. TORRES, Raymundo s
1038. TRA, Rogelio S.
1039. TRAVISON, Rodolfo S.
1040. TRESVALLES, Isias V.
1041. TRIAS, Antonio
1042. TRIAS, Renato S.
1043. TRILLANES, Rene M.
1044. UBALDO, Placido C.
1045. UNIDAD, Reynaldo R.
1046. UNTALAN, Willie
1047. VALERA, Aniceto A.
1048. VALERO, Maximo A.
1049. VALES, Augusto L.
1050. VALLADA, Aurelio S
1051. VALLAR, Federico P.
1052. VALLARTA, Tomas Jr., L.
1053. VARGAS, Isaias V.
1054. VEGA, Abraham
1055. VELASQUEZ, Benjamin
1056. VELASQUEZ, Constantino B
1057. VELASQUEZ, Mario M.
1058. VERDADERO, Eugenio C.
1059. VERDAN, Oscar A.
1060. VERNAL, Victorio
1061. VERZONILLA, Rufino V.
1062. VIAR, Guillermo E.
1063. VIAR, Romeo E.
1064. VICTORIA, Jubert D.
1065. VIERNES, Mariano N.
1066. VILLANUEVA, Carlito
1067. VILLAR, Alfredo A.
1068. VILLAR, Raul R.
1069. VILLARINO, Leonardo
1070. VILLAROSA, Francisco M.
1071. VO, Herminio V.
1072. YANGLO, Alejandro M.
1073. YLAYA, Galileo C.
1074. YULO, Buenaventura M.
1075. YUVIENGCO, Meynardo L.
1076. ZALAVARIA, Carlos R.
1077. ZULUETA, Jose B.
The Court also observes that 57 of the petitioners are claimants identified and listed in Annex "A" of the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution, namely:
1. ABANES, Martin M.
2. ABANTO, Gregorio M.
3. ACUPAN, Emmanuel
4. AGUDO, Guillermo R.
5. ALEJANDRE, Alejandro
6. ALEJANDRE, Hilarion F.
7. ALEJANDRINO, Anselmo V.
8. AMBAL, Hermogenes R.
9. AMUTAN, Moises
10. ANDAYA, Joaquin S.
11. ARIZA, Dionisio R.
12. ATIENZA, Justo
13. BUENVIAJE, Manuel
14. BUENVIAJE, Vicento
15. CAGANAP, Julio R.
16. CAGATAN, Doroteo G.
17. CALAUAGAN, Patronicio L.
18. CELIS, Augusto
19. CENTENO, Emmanuel C.
20. COLMENAR, Baltazar R.
21. DALANON, Vicente D.
22. DATILES, Miguel A.
23. DOLOIRAS, Marcelino D.
24. DUMAGUN, Perseverando H.
25. ESPIRITU, Manuel S.
26. ESPIRITU, Rodrigo C.
27. ESQUIVEL, Arturo S.
28. FADRIQUELA, Sesenio
29. GALANG, Balbino C.
30. GUINHAWA, Narciso C.
31. LEBITA, Ricardo
32. LEONOR, Julio P.
33. LOBETA, Rolando R.
34. MAALIHAN, Pelagio D.
35. MACALALAD, Nicasio T.
36. MADRID, Ernesto L.
37. MANIGBAS, Adonis D.
38. MARCELO, Domingo G.
39. MERLAN, Montano C.
40. MORADA, Cosme B.
41. NATI, Conrado
42. OBANDO, Luis G.
43. OLIVA, Marcial B.
44. PAPA, Angel A.
45. PASIMIO, Jose R
46. POBLETE, Dominador N.
47. QUIOBO, Rogelio C.
48. RAMOS, Froilan M.
49. REMOTO, Fidel O.
50. RONQUILLO, Segundino L.
51. SANOHAN, Francisco F.
52. SARMIENTO, Silvestre
53. TOLENTINO, Amado S.
54. TUNGCOL, Benedicto
55. VERGARA, Ignacio P.
56. VERNES, Mariano N.
57. VILLANUEVA, Ernesto N.
Further, 12 of the petitioners are claimants identified and listed in Annex "C" of the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution, viz.:
1. CALAUAG, Ricardo C.
2. CRUETA, Antonio B.
3. CRUSIS, Manolito R.
4. ENGAY, Vicente
5. GARCIA, Ernesto L.
6. GUTIERREZ, Jose M.
7. LAGMAY, Wilfredo
8. MACALALAD, Andres T.
9. MANIGO, Cornelio Jr.,
10. MENDIOLA, Simplicio G.
11. ROMALES, Edgardo H.
12. ZAMORA, Primo B.
To reiterate, the Court cannot acquiesce to the plea of these petitioners totaling 1,146 because: (1) the 1,077 first-time claimants are not parties in the earlier Cadalin case, thus, they could not have been subjects of the implementation of the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution; (2) the claims of the 57 complainants listed in Annex "A" of the said resolution were already dismissed in our earlier decision due to prescription; and (3) those of the 19 complainants in Annex "C" were likewise set aside in the earlier decision, because the claimants therein were found not entitled to the claims.
Granting arguendo that these 1,146 petitioners are similarly situated as the claimants listed in Annexes "B", "D" and "E" of the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution, which were the subjects of the 1997-2001 implementation proceedings, still we cannot grant their purported claims because they belatedly asserted their claims only in the implementation proceedings via a Submission and Manifestational Motion dated July 7, 2000.46 We stress that Article 291 of the Labor Code, as amended, provides that "[a]ll money claims arising from employer-employee relations accruing during the effectivity of this Code shall be filed within three (3) years from the time the cause of action accrued; otherwise they shall be forever barred."
In the earlier Cadalin case, we discussed at length the issue of prescription. Our disquisition therein should already have discouraged the additional claimants from pursuing their stale and baseless claims. Observably, however, petitioners’ counsels, in circumvention of our rulings, resurrected the prescribed claims by labeling petitioners as similarly situated as those claimants listed in Annexes "B", "D" and "E" of the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution.
Even if we disregard the rule on prescription, still we cannot allow these alleged similarly situated claimants to recover because, as found by the NLRC, they were not able to present substantial evidence in support of their claims.47 Suffice it to state at this point that the appellate court cannot substitute its own judgment or discretion for that of the labor tribunal in determining what evidence is entitled to belief.48 We are, thus, bound to lend credence to the following findings of the NLRC:
Except for claims of the 149 claimants listed in Annex "B" of the September 2, 1991 resolution, claims of the other complainants were dismissed in the same resolution either for "lack of substantial evidence in support therefor," or for their being "beyond the competence of this Commission to pass upon." Such ruling is supposed to constitute Res Judicata (sic) here. But what the 1,297 additional complainants did is to try to re-establish their claims here through mere manifestations dated July 7, 2000 and August 30, 2001. Unfortunately for them, in her report dated November 7, 2001, Arbiter Lilia Savar explained that despite the opportunity given, these so called unauthorized claimants still failed to establish their claim (sic). Explained Arbiter Savari:
Despite the advise (sic) to file whatever evidence they may have to prove their claims, Atty. Del Mundo failed to attach in his Compliance and Manifestation even a single document of his clients showing employment with Brown & Root in the state of Bahrain. Thus, we are forced to scrutinize the thick and dusty pages of the bundles of folders in a case to make our own findings. Since the documents filed with the POEA and forwarded to the NLRC were passed upon and their evidentiary weight already decided in the NLRC Resolution dated September 2, 1991, We (sic) just confine ourselves to the other evidence which the complainants have adduced. Further considering that the case has long been remanded to the NLRC and that hearings were conducted before the several Labor Arbiters to whom the case was successively assigned, not only ample but all opportunity was given to the complainants to present their evidence in support of their claims. Since Atty. Del Mundo has not submitted proofs of their clients’ claim (sic) as directed, we have nothing to deduce except that there is none to present: the reason why their case was dismissed by the POEA and NLRC.
Clearly, We (sic) gravely erred when, despite our being handicapped by the same "lack of substantial evidence", and despite their being beyond Our (sic) competence to pass judgment on, we granted 1,297 claimants the now disputed awards in Our (sic) December 3, 2002 decision.49
We have likewise observed that, during the prolonged period that this case has been pending, most of the petitioners–the first-time claimants, the Annexes "A" and "C" claimants, and including the Annexes "B," "D" and "E" claimants–already settled their claims with the private respondents. After counter-checking the claimants’ names with the list in the dismissal orders issued pursuant to the compromise agreements, the NLRC found and petitioners’ counsels even manifested50 that only 19 complainants had not settled their claims and had, instead, opted to continue with the litigation.51
In an attempt to lend substance to the instant petition, the petitioners whose claims have already been settled now want this Court to nullify the said compromise agreements. Unfortunately, we cannot accommodate them, except for the 149 Annex "B" complainants, because the records reveal that these compromise agreements were entered into voluntarily by the claimants with the assistance of counsel, approved subsequently by the court and the labor tribunal, and settled for a reasonable and acceptable consideration. We note at this point that the (1) first-time claimants, (2) those listed in Annex "A" whose claims were dismissed, and (3) those listed in Annex "C" whose claims were set aside, are not entitled to receive anything from private respondents. Yet, by virtue of the compromise agreements executed, they were able to gain a hefty sum. The execution of these agreements, therefore, was not only in accord with Article 227 of the Labor Code, as amended,52 but was likewise in consonance with the guidelines we set in Periquet v. National Labor Relations Commission53 for valid quitclaims and waivers.
In a compromise agreement putting an end to a lawsuit, each of the parties is motivated by the hope of gaining, balanced by the danger of losing.54 Absent any palpable inequity in its terms, and there appears no such inequity obtaining in this case, the same must be recognized as a valid and binding transaction.55
Further, it is noteworthy that most, if not all, of the claimants have already received payment under the compromise agreements. They cannot therefore belatedly reject or repudiate their acts of accepting the monetary consideration under these agreements to the prejudice of the private respondents.56
Accordingly, in the NLRC proceedings conducted from 1997 to 2001, the legitimate parties are limited to the following: (1) the 149 claimants identified and listed in Annex "B" of the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution; and (2) the 752 claimants listed in Annexes "D" and "E" of the September 2, 1991 Resolution:57
Annex "B"
[The 149 claimants who should be paid their claims
totaling US$288,636.70.]
1. ABAN, Jose M.
2. ABARQUEZ, Emigdion N.
3. ACUPAN, Antonio
4. ACUPAN, Romeo
5. ALEJANDRE, Benjamin
6. ALIGADA, Wilfredo D.
7. AMISTAD, Martin, Jr.
8. AMUL, Rolando B.
9. ANANDING, Amorsolo
10. ANGLO, Antonio I.
11. ARLITA, Vicente
12. AYO, Herbert
13. BALATAZO, Silverio
14. BALOBO, Alfredo
15. BANAAG, Falconeri
16. BARBOSA, Ramon
17. BARCENA, Felix
18. BAS, Fernando
19. BATACLAN, Mario
20. BATICA, Roberto S.
21. BELEN, Enrico P.
22. BICOL, Aristeo M.
23. BICOL, Larry C.
24. BISCOCHO, Petronillo M.
25. BOBIER, Felix M.
26. BOBONGO, Dionisio O.
27. BRACAMANTE, Bayani S.
28. BUSTILLO, Pablito G.
29. CABEZAS, Guillermo
30. CADALIN, Bienvenido
31. CAGATAN, Rodolfo
32. CAILAO, Amante
33. CANDOR, Irineo P.
34. CASTILLO, Jose
35. CASTILLO, Manuel
36. CASTROJERES, Remar
37. CAYAS, Reynaldo
38. CECILIO, Romeo O.
39. CREUS, Teodulo
40. DAYRIT, Bayani
41. DAYRIT, Ricardo
42. DELA CRUZ, Ernesto T.
43. DE GUZMAN, Francisco
44. DE RAMA, Onofre
45. DE VERA, Ignacio
46. DIZON, Modesto
47. DIZON, Reynaldo S.
48. DOMINGUEZ, Antonio S.
49. EBRADA, Gilbert
50. EBRADA, Ricardo
51. EJERCITO, Antonio Jr.,
52. ERIDAO, Eduarte C.
53. ESCATOTO, Eladio
54. ESGUERRA, John
55. ESPIRITU, Eduardo
56. ESPIRITU, Ernesto
57. ESPIRITU, Rodolfo
58. ESTEVA, Nestor M.
59. ESTRADA, Benjamin
60. EVANGELISTA, Valerio
61. FRANCISCO, Olegario
62. GABAWAN, Jesus
63. GARCIA, Rolando
64. GUDA, Angel
65. HERNANDEZ, Pacito
66. HILARIO, Antonio
67. JACOB, Henry L.
68. JARDINIANO, Honesto
69. JOCSON, Antonio
70. LACSAMANA, Gerardo
71. LIRIO, Efren U.
72. LONTOC, Loreto
73. LORENZO, Israel
74. LORINO, Alejandro
75. MABALAY, Jose
76. MARANAN, Hermie
77. MARCIAL, Leovigildo
78. MARTINEZ, Noel
79. MATREO, Dante
80. MELENDEZ, Luciano
81. MELO, Renato
82. MENDIODIA, Francis
83. MILANES, Jose C.
84. MILAY, Raymundo
85. MIRANDA, Cresenciano
86. MOLINA, Ildefonso C.
87. MONDEJAR, Armando B.
88. NAZARENO, Resurreccion D.
89. OLINDO, Juan
90. OLIVARES, Francisco R.
91. ORBISTA, Pedro, Jr.
92. ORDONEZ, Ricardo
93. PANCHO, Ernie
94. PANCHO, Jose
95. PARALA, Gorgonio P.
96. PINPIN, Modesto
97. PAREA, Juanito
98. PATAG, Romeo I.
99. PINPIN, Francisco
100. POBLETE, Leonardo
101. POLLOS, Jaime
102. PONDALIS, Domingo
103. RAMIREZ, Eugenio
104. RESPALL, Lucien
105. RETANAN, Gaudencio, Jr.
106. RETENER, Tomas B.
107. REYES, Alvin C.
108. REYES, Rizalino
109. REYES, Solomon B.
110. RICAZA, Virgilio G.
111. RIETA, Rodelio Jr.
112. RIVERA, Benito Jr.,
113. ROBILLOS, Bernardo J.
114. ROBLES, Pablo A.
115. ROBLEZA, Jose
116. RONQUILLO, Quirino
117. ROQUE, Avelino M.
118. SABINO, Menandro L.
119. SALGATAR, Pedro
120. SALONGA, Edgardo
121. SAN MATEO, Numeriano
122. SANTOS, Felizardo Jr. delos
123. SANTOS, Gabriel
124. SANTOS, Juanito
125. SOLANTE, Paquito
126. SOLIS, Conrado Jr., A.
127. SULTAN, Rodolfo
128. TALATAC, Isaias
129. TARUC, William
130. TEMPROSA, Menandro
131. TOLENTINO, Bienvenido S.
132. TORRES, Benedicto
133. TORRES, Maximiano
134. TRIAS, Francisco G.
135. URSOLINO, Sergio A.
136. VALDEZ, Rogelio
137. VERGARA, Legorio
138. VICTORIA, Delfin
139. VICTORIA, Gilbert
140. VICTORIANO, Hermane
141. VILLAFLORES, Francisco
142. VILLAHERMOSA, Domingo
143. VILLALOBOS, Rolando
144. VILLALUZ, Antonio
145. VILLANUEVA, Danilo
146. VILLANUEVA, Rogelio
147. VILLARBA, Angel
148. VILLARINO, Juanito
149. ZARA, Francisco
ANNEX "D"
List of complainants without proof of employment and whose claims have been dismissed by the POEA:
1. Aalagos, Rogelio
2. Abad, Nicanor B.
3. Abanes, Andres
4. Abanes, Reynaldo
5. Abante, Eduardo
6. Abarro, Jose
7. Abarro, Josefino
8. Abelanio, Celso S.
9. Abella, Herminio
10. Abestano, Miguel
11. Abubo, Rodrigo G
12. Abustan, Jose B.
13. Aceres, Dante
14. Acojido, Reynaldo S.
15. Acta, Leowilin
16. Acueza, Eugenio C.
17. Acupan, Eduardo
18. Acupan, Reynaldo
19. Acupan, Solano
20. Adana, Manuel P.
21. Agne, Florentino R
22. Agudo, Quiterio R.
23. Aguinaldo, Manuel P.
24. Aguirre, Dante
25. Aguirre, Herminio
26. Alberto, Gonzalo Jr.
27. Alcantara, Conrado
28. Alcantara, Lamberto Q.
29. Alcantara, Marianito J.
30. Aldover, Bencio
31. Alejandrino, Eulalio V.
32. Alejandro, Benjamin
33. Alejandro, Eduardo L.
34. Alejandro, Maximino
35. Almenar, Alberto
36. Alonzo, Arnaldo
37. Aloria, Amado
38. Alvarez, Camilo
39. Alvarez, Manuel C.
40. Ambrocio, Benjamin R.
41. Amores, Carlos
42. Ancheta, Bernard P.
43. Ancheta, Teotimo O.
44. Ani, Joefrey
45. Antillon, Elino P.
46. Antipono, Armandro B.
47. Antonio, Larry T.
48. Apilado, Antonio
49. Apilado, Arturo P.
50. Apolinario, Francisco
51. Aquino, Bartolome M.
52. Aquino, Isidro
53. Aquino, Pastor
54. Aquino, Rosendo M.
55. Arangorin, Roberto
56. Aratea, Benjamin O.
57. Araullo, Arturo V.
58. Araullo, Prudencio
59. Arcaira, Alexander
60. Arciaga, Francisco
61. Arevalo, Jose
62. Arevalo, Juanto
63. Arevalo, Ramon
64. Arevalo, Rodolfo
65. Arguelles, Eulalio
66. Arica, Wilfredo P.
67. Asedillo, Jose M.
68. Asuncion, Antonio
69. Asuncion, Artemio M.
70. Asuncion, Edgardo
71. Asuncion, Rexy M.
72. Aurelio, Vicente
73. Austria, Angel
74. Averilla, Ricardo Jr. P.
75. Avila, Virgilio
76. Axalan, Bartolome
77. Babilonia, Alfredo
78. Bacal, Felimon
79. Bacani, Jose L.
80. Balbieran, Romulo R.
81. Balbieran, Vicente
82. Balitbit, Rodolfo
83. Balobo, Teodoro Y.
84. Barba, Danilo O.
85. Barro, Bernardo
86. Basilan, Juan A.
87. Batitis, Ceferino
88. Bauan, Vivencio C.
89. Bautista, Gaudencio S.
90. Bautista, Leonardo
91. Bautista, Jose D.
92. Bautista, Rostico
93. Bautista, Ruperto B.
94. Bautista, Teodoro S.
95. Bautista, Virgilio
96. Baya, Jesus R.
97. Bayacal, Winiefredo
98. Bebit, Winiefredo
99. Belir, Ben G.
100. Beltran, Eric B.
101. Benales, Emiliano Jr.
102. Benitez, Raul
103. Bensan, Perfecto
104. Bergonio, Ireneo
105. Bermudes, Isabelo
106. Bermudes, Rolando I.
107. Beron, Danilo
108. Bersamin, Benjamin
109. Bicol, Angelito
110. Bicol, Anselmo
111. Bicol, Celestino Jr.
112. Bicol, Francisco
113. Bicol, Rogelio
114. Bicol, Romulo L.
115. Billiones, Rogelio
116. Bito, Teofilo N.
117. Blanco, Fernando
118. Bondoc, Augusto
119. Bondoc, Domingo
120. Booc, Pepe S.
121. Borja, James R.
122. Braceros, Wilfredo
123. Brecino, Angeles C.
124. Briones, Eureclydon G.
125. Bruge, Amado
126. Budillo, Pablito
127. Buenaventura, Archimedes
128. Buenaventura, Basilio
129. Buenconsejo, Guillermo
130. Bustamante, Alexander
131. Butiong, Virgilio Jr.
132. Caballa, Honesto P.
133. Caballero, Delfin
134. Cabanigan, Benedicto
135. Cabatay, Moises
136. Cabrera, Hermaneli
137. Cagatan, Pedro
138. Cagayat, Joven C.
139. Calagos, Rogelio L.
140. Caldejon, Reynaldo V.
141. Calderon, Oscar C.
142. Calleja, Nestor D.
143. Calma, Renato R.
144. Camacho, Nelson T.
145. Camacho, Santos T.
146. Camana, Roberto
147. Camanag, Florante C.
148. Canda, Edgardo M.
149. Cantos, Severino
150. Caponpon, Epifanio A.
151. Carillo, Elias Jr. D.
152. Carreon, Armando
153. Castaneda, Menandro M.
154. Castillo, Benigno A.
155. Castillo, Cornelio L.
156. Castillo, Joseph B.
157. Castillo, Anselmo
158. Castillo, Joaquin
159. Castillo, Pablo L.
160. Castillo, Romeo P.
161. Catibog, Sesinando
162. Castro, Danilo
163. Castro, Prudencio A.
164. Castro, Ramo Jr.
165. Castro, Romeo A. De
166. Catli, Jaime B.
167. Ceferino, Durana D.
168. Celis, Rodolfo B.
169. Cerezo, Herminigildo
170. Celestino, Victoriano
171. Chan, Benjamin
172. Chua, Antonio C.
173. Ciabal, Vivencio B.
174. Clarete, Rodrigo
175. Coloma, Augusto
176. Concepcion, Turiano
177. Constantino, Teresito
178. Corales, Armando
179. Corcuera, Renato C.
180. Coronado, Apolinar
181. Coronel, Abelardo
182. Coronel, Felix Jr.
183. Corpuz, Leonardo
184. Corrales, Jesus M.
185. Cortemprato, Caesar
186. Corvera, Francisco O.
187. Costales, Francisco Sr.
188. Credito, Celedonio
189. Creus, Alberto A.
190. Cruz, Anacleto V.
191. Cruz, Domingo Dela
192. Cruz, Emiliano Jr. Dela
193. Cruz, Panchito
194. Cruz, Reynaldo B. Dela
195. Cruz, Roberto P.
196. Cruz, Teodoro S.
197. Cruz, Zosimo Dela
198. Cuaresma, Dionisio A.
199. Cuizon, Felimon
200. Dagondon, Fermin
201. Daguinsin, Richard
202. Datay, Crisanto A.
203. Datinguinoo, Nicasio
204. Datoon, Jose
205. David, Eduardo
206. David, Enrico T.
207. David, Fabio
208. David, Victoriano S.
209. Dayacap, Edgardo N.
210. Delloso, Joselito T.
211. De Guzman, Celerino
212. De Guzman, Romulo
213. De Jesus, Liberato
214. De Leon, Jose
215. De Leon, Pedro G.
216. De Lumban, Joselito L.
217. De Luna, Napoleon S.
218. De Rama, Ricardo
219. Del Rosario, Generoso
220. Dela Cruz, Alberto
221. Dela Cruz, Jose
222. Delos Reyes, Leonardo
223. Diata, Ernesto F.
224. Diaz, Eduardo A.
225. Diaz, Felix
226. Diaz, Melchor
227. Diaz, Nicanor S.
228. Diga, Gerardo C.
229. Dimatulac, Clemente
230. Dionisio, Rolando
231. Dismaya, Philipp G.
232. Doctolero, Benjamin
233. Domingo, Alberto Sto.
234. Doza, Benjamin E.
235. Dupa, Benjamin
236. Duran, Danilo C.
237. Duran, Gregorio D.
238. Eduarte, Renato A.
239. Eisma, Godofredo E.
240. Ello, Ardon B.
241. Ello, Ubed B.
242. Enano, Josefino
243. Encarnacion, Reynaldo
244. Enguancho, Edgardo
245. Equipano, Elias
246. Escarmosa, Felizardo
247. Escarmosa, Miguel
248. Escobar, Armando
249. Escuyos, Romeo T.
250. Espiritu, Angelito
251. Espiritu, Eduardo S.
252. Espitu, Reynaldo
253. Espiritu, Rolando
254. Espregante, Julian
255. Estanislao, Igmidio
256. Esteban, Ernesto M.
257. Estron, Melanio R.
258. Esteva, Ernesto M.
259. Estuar, Conrado
260. Estuye, Clyde
261. Fajardo, Eliseo
262. Falqueza, Porfirio
263. Faustino, Wilfredo P.
264. Fernandez, Emilio E.
265. Ferrer, Artemio
266. Figuracion, Misael M.
267. Flores, Armando F.
268. Flores, Benjamin
269. Flroes, Edgardo C.
270. Francisco, Buenaventura
271. Francisco, Manuel S.
272. Francisco, Rolando
273. Francisco Valeriano
274. Gabawan, Rodolfo
275. Gahutan, Esmeraldo
276. Galang, Cesar C.
277. Galoso, Santiago N.
278. Gamboa, Gabriel
279. Gandamon, Bernardo
280. Ganzon, Juan
281. Garcia, Andres Jr.
282. Garcia, Armando M.
283. Garcia, Eugenio
284. Garcia, Marcelo L.
285. Garcia, Patricio Jr. L.
286. Garcia, Ponciano G.
287. Garcia, Ponciano Jr.
288. Garcia, Rafael P.
289. Garcia, Roberto S.
290. Garofil, Osias G.
291. Garon, Raymundo C.
292. Gatela, Rolando G.
293. Gayeta, Avelino
294. Geron, Raymundo
295. Gonzales, Placido
296. Gonzales, Ruperto H.
297. Guanio, Rogelio D.
298. Guerrero, Martin Jr. V.
299. Guno, Alexis
300. Guno, Ricardo L.
301. Gupit, Francisco
302. Gutierrez, Dennis J.
303. Gutierrez, Ignacio B.
304. Guzman, Angelito Jr. De
305. Habana, Cesar H.
306. Hernandez, Raul G.
307. Hernandez, Reynaldo
308. Hilado, Joveniano D.
309. Hilapo, Justo
310. Hinahon, Rostito
311. Hingada, Felicisimo
312. Hipolito, Eduardo
313. Ignacio, Raul L.
314. Ilagan, Manuel L.
315. Ilagan, Renato L
316. Insiong, Conrado A.
317. Isla, Graciano G.
318. Jacob, Arnel L.
319. Japitenga, Oscar J.
320. Hicban, Cirilo
321. Honrades, Maximiano
322. Ignacio, Generoso
323. Ilagan, Felipe
324. Jacob, Expedito N.
325. Jasmin, Mario
326. Javier, Beinvenido
327. Javier, Romeo M.
328. Jesus, Primo De
329. Jesus, Reynaldo De
330. Jimenez, Carlos A.
331. Jimenez, Danilo E.
332. Joaquin, Pedro C.
333. Jocson, Felipe W
334. Jocson, Felino M.
335. Jocson, Pedro N.
336. Jocson, Valentino S.
337. Joloya, Pedro B.
338. Jose, Esteban Jr. P.
339. Jose, Raul
340. Jose, Ricardo San
341. Kabigting, Gertrudo
342. Kolimlim, Eduardo Sr. S.
343. Labay, Lauro J.
344. Labella, Emmanuel C.
345. Lacerona, Edgardo B.
346. Lacson, Jose B.
347. Ladines, Mario J.
348. Lagac, Rufino
349. Laganapan, Rodrigo
350. Lamadrid, Efren M.
351. Latanan, Gaudencio
352. Latayan, Virgilio
353. Latoja, Emiliano
354. Laurel, Wenceslao
355. Laxamana, Alfredo
356. Lazaro, Deniel R.
357. Leano, Antonio C.
358. Legaspi, Arturo S.
359. Lemos, Benito Jr. De
360. Leon, Pedro G. De
361. Liloc, Manolito C.
362. Limuaco, Gerardo
363. Lising, Ernesto S.
364. Lising, Renato
365. Lising, Wilfredo S.
366. Lontoc, Crispulo
367. Lopera, Pedro M.
368. Lopera, Rogelio
369. Lopez, Carlito M.
370. Lopez, Clody
371. Lopez, Garlito
372. Lopez, George F.
373. Lopez, Virgilio M.
374. Loreja, Bernardito G.
375. Lorico, Domingo B.
376. Loyola, Domingo
377. Luage, Dante
378. Lualhati, Antonio M.
379. Lualhati, Emmanuel Jr.
380. Lualhati, Leonides C.
381. Lualhati, Sebastian
382. Lubat, Francisco
383. Lucero, Armando
384. Lumban, Joselito L. De
385. Luna, Thomas Vicente O.
386. Macalalad, Noli
387. Macalino, Alfredo
388. Macalino, Ricardo
389. Macaraig, Arturo V.
390. Macaraig, Benito V.
391. Macaraig, Ernesto V.
392. Macaraig, Rodolfo V.
393. Macatangay, Benjamin
394. Macatangay, Hermogenes
395. Macatangay, Rodel
396. Macatangay, Romulo
397. Madlangbayan, Osias Q.
398. Madrid, Nicolas P.
399. Magat, Edilberto G.
400. Magbanua, Efren C.
401. Magbuhat, Benjamin
402. Magcaleng, Alfredo C.
403. Magnaye, Antonio
404. Magpantay, Alfonso
405. Magpantay, Ricardo C.
406. Magpantay, Simeon M.
407. Magsino, Armando M.
408. Magsino, Macario S.
409. Magtibay, Antonio
410. Magtibay, Victor V.
411. Mahilum, Geronimo
412. Malonzo, Manuel
413. Mamadis, Ricardo
414. Mana, Rodolfo
415. Manalili, Bernardo A.
416. Manalili, Manuel
417. Manalo, Angelo
418. Manalo, Aquiles L.
419. Mangahas, Leopoldo
420. Manigbas, Bayani
421. Manimtim, Rolando C.
422. Manongsong, Daniel
423. Manuel, Ernesto F.
424. Manzano, Eduardo
425. Mapa, Ricardo N.
426. Mapile, Ramon
427. Marana, Roberto C.
428. Marasigan, Nemesio
429. Marasigan, Wenceslao
430. Marcelo, Leonardo
431. Mariano, Henry F.
432. Maridable, Joel
433. Marino, Santos E.
434. Marquez, Narciso A.
435. Marinez, Ricardo
436. Masicampo, Diego
437. Mataverde, Aurelio
438. Matilla, Renato
439. Matilla, Victoriano
440. Medel, Virgillo
441. Melecio, Lolito M.
442. Melendez, Benigno
443. Memije, Rener J.
444. Memije, Reynaldo F.
445. Memije, Rodel
446. Mendoza, Avelino Jr.
447. Mendoza, Claro
448. Mendoza, Timoteo
449. Mercado, Gregorio
450. Merced, Ernani Dela
451. Mercena, Ricardo
452. Metrillo, Nemecio
453. Mimije, Rodel
454. Minimo, Gaspar
455. Miranda, Benjamin
456. Misa, FelixbertoD.
457. Modesto, Claudio Jr. A.
458. Mondido, Oscar
459. Monton, Generoso
460. Morada, Renato
461. Morada, Ricardo
462. Morada, Rodolfo
463. Morales, Rolando M.
464. Moreno, Federico M.
465. Mortel, Victorino Jr. A.
466. Munoz, Espiritu A.
467. Munoz, Ignacio
468. Munoz, Ildefonso
469. Munoz, Rogelio
470. Napalan, Ernesto
471. Narciso, Marcelo A.
472. Natalia, Reynaldo
473. Navarette, Fernando C.
474. Navarro, Pacifico D.
475. Nazareno, Florante
476. Nazario, Rizal B.
477. Negrite, Josue
478. Nepomuceno, Alfredo
479. Ng, Herbert G.
480. Nicolas, Florencio
481. Ninon, Ernesto C.
482. Nuqui, Avelino
483. Oba, Nemesio D.
484. Ocampo, Danilo
485. Ocampo, Edgardo
486. Ocampo, Rodrigo E.
487. Occiano, Antonio B.
488. Ocson, Reynaldo P.
489. Odesa, Benjamin
490. Olaso, Angel
491. Oligario, Francisco
492. Olimbo, Zosimo
493. Orallo, Benjamin V.
494. Orial, Romeo S.
495. Origines, Romeo
496. Ortanez, Danilo R.
497. Osias, Wilfredo
498. Pa-a, Virgilio
499. Paalan, David
500. Pacheco, Jesus N.
501. Padilla, Alfonso L.
502. Pagsanjan, Danilo
503. Pagsisihan, Numeriano
504. Paguio, Ricardo T.
505. Pakingan, Emilio
506. Palabrica, Leandro
507. Palo, Quinciano
508. Pamatian, Jose
509. Pan, Gonzalo
510. Pan, Porfirio
511. Pangan, Bienvenido
512. Pangan, Ernesto
513. Pasia, Francisco V.
514. Pasimio, Edilberto Jr.
515. Pasion, Jose V.
516. Pena, Angelito M.
517. Pendras, Dionisio
518. Peralta, Herminio
519. Peralta, Reynaldo M.
520. Perez, Antonio
521. Perez, Antoliano E.
522. Perez, Juan
523. Perez, Leon
524. Perez, Romeo E.
525. Perez, Romulo
526. Perez, William
527. Perino, Fernando G.
528. Pilar, Florentino Del
529. Pineda, Delmar F.
530. Pineda, Salvador
531. Pinpin, Elizalde
532. Pinpin, Wilfredo
533. Poblete, Arturo
534. Priela, Dominador R.
535. Prudente, Buenaventura
536. Prudente, Carmelito
537. Pueyo, Dante
538. Pueyo, Reynaldo Q.
539. Pulido, Rodolfo O.
540. Punio, Alejandro
541. Quiman, Federico
542. Quinto, Alfredo L.
543. Quintos, Romeo
544. Racabo, Eduardo W.
545. Rama, Ricardo C. De
546. Rama, Ricardo L. De
547. Rama, Rolando De
548. Ramirez, Fernando A.
549. Ramires, Lito D.
550. Ramirez, Ricardo G.
551. Ramirez, Rodolfo V.
552. Ramos, Alberto
553. Ramos, Anselmo C.
554. Ramos, Tobias
555. Raymundo, Willarfredo
556. Raquedan, Reynaldo
557. Ravelas, Manuel F.
558. Raymundo, Wilfredo D.
559. Recolaso, Ernesto E.
560. Redaza, Alberto
561. Rejuso, Arthur
562. Rellama, Toribio M.
563. Rellosa, Jaime
564. Remoquillo, Eugenio A.
565. Rentoza, Gerardo
566. Rey, Redentor C.
567. Reyes, Alfredo S.
568. Reyes, Amable S.
569. Reyes, Benedicto R.
570. Reyes, Gregorio B.
571. Reyes, Jose A.
572. Reyes, Jose C.
573. Reyes, Romulo M.
574. Reyes, Sergio
575. Rico, Ernesto F.
576. Rico, Fernando M.
577. Rieta, Emmanuel
578. Rieta, Ricardo
579. Robles, Leo B.
580. Robles, Ruben
581. Robleza, Rodolfo
582. Robleza, Rodrigo
583. Rocabo, Eduardo
584. Rodriguez, Antonio R.
585. Rodriguez, Bernardo
586. Rodriguez, Eligio
587. Romeo, Almonte
588. Ronquillo, Elias
589. Ronquillo, Elise
590. Ronquillo, Luis Val B.
591. Ronquillo, Reynoso P.
592. Ronquillo, Rodolfo
593. Rosales, Angel
594. Rosales, Ramon
595. Rosario, Alberto Del
596. Rosario, Generoso Del
597. Rosario, Teodorico Del
598. Rosario, Virgilio L.
599. Salvador, Carlito
600. Samparada, Jose
601. San Pedro, Ernesto
602. Sancha, Adriano V.
603. Sancha, Geronimo M.
604. Sanchez, Artemio B.
605. Sanchez, Nicasio
606. Santiago, Apolonio P.
607. Santiago, Joselito S.
608. Santiago, Sergio
609. Santos, Edilberto C.
610. Santos, Efren S.
611. Santos, Renato D.
612. Sapuyot, Miguel
613. Serquina, Alex S.
614. Serra, Dominador P.
615. Sidro, Romeo
616. Silang, Amado M.
617. Silang, Faustino D.
618. Silos, Rodolfo B. De
619. Silva, Aniceto G.
620. Silva, Edgardo M.
621. Silverio, Rolando C.
622. Simbahon, Arthur B.
623. Solano, Domingo
624. Solante, Joselito C.
625. Solis, Carlito
626. Solis, Conrado III
627. Solis, Edgardo
628. Solis, Ernesto
629. Solis, Isagani M.
630. Sotto, Eduardo L.
631. Sta. Maria, Ernesto G.
632. Stella, Vicente G.
633. Supang, Felimon
634. Tanguinoo, Peter
635. Talibsao, Maximino
636. Talusik, Felicisimo P.
637. Taruc, Fermin Jr.
638. Templo, Henry
639. Templo, Levy S.
640. Tiamson, Rodolfo S.
641. Tiposo, Leonilo
642. Tolentinoo, Arnel
643. Tolentino, Mario M.
644. Torralba, Felipe
645. Torres, Jovito V.
646. Torres, Leonardo De
647. Tuazon, Gavino U.
648. Tunguia, Augusto B.
649. Umali, Francisco
650. Unida, Simplicio
651. Untalan, Wilfredo V.
652. Valderama, Antonio
653. Valderama, Ramon
654. Valencianoo, Nilo
655. Vasquez, Edgardo C.
656. Velasquez, Elpidio
657. Vera, Nesto De
658. Vera, Wilfredo De
659. Vergara, Bienvenido
660. Vergara, Alfredo
661. Verzosa, Ramon R.
662. Vicmundo, Felicito P.
663. Victoriano, Alfredo
664. Vidallo, Teofilo P.
665. Viernez, Sabino N.
666. Villan, Jesus J.
667. Villablanco, Joven
668. Villaflores, Edgardo G.
669. Villagera, Ceferino
670. Villahermosa, Alex
671. Villanueva, Danilo A.
672. Villanueva, Elito
673. Villanueva, Leonardo M.
674. Villanueva, Manuel R.
675. Villar, Nepthali
676. Villareal, Jose V.
677. Villarino, Felicisimo
678. Villaroman, Rafael
679. Villena, Carlos
680. Vivo, Ferdinand
681. Yabut, Roberto
682. Yngente, Vicente
683. Zuniga, Oro C.
ANNEX "E"
Complainants/awardees whose claims are not supported by any documentary evidence –
1. Abanes, Rodrigo
2. Alvarez, Apolinario
3. Alvarez, Pablo C.
4. Andres, Simeon
5. Austria, Calixto
6. Austria, Salvador
7. Bagting, Vicente G.
8. Balbin, Rodolfo
9. Barrientors, Benjamin
10. Beltran, Diego
11. Bicol Felicisimo
12. Briones, Romeo
13. Buenaflor, Marianito
14. Campano, Pacifico – S. A.
15. Camposagrado, Alejandro
16. Calamba, Felipe
17. Coronel, Felix, Jr.
18. De Guzman, Roman
19. Dela Cruz, Daniel
20. Del Mundo, Pedro
21. Dinglasan, Manuel A.
22. Esguerra, Democrito
23. Espino, Carlito
24. Espinosa, Graciano
25. Esporas, Manuel
26. Fabricante, Primo
27. Ferrer, Ernesto
28. Firme, Daniel
29. Flores, Edelberto
30. Gabay, Constancio
31. Gabay, Teodorico
32. Garcia, Bernardo M.
33. Garcia, Pedro
34. Gregorio, Jose
35. Ilagan, Pablito
36. Jaro, Abraham V.
37. Jaro, Cezar
38. Jervoso, Juanito
39. Larkin, Wilfredo, Jr.
40. Leonor, Arturo V.
41. Lopera, Felipe
42. Lopez, Vicente
43. Lualhati, Juan
44. Macaraig, Romeo
45. Macatangay, Mario
46. Macatangay, Damaso
47. Manalo, Felimon H.
48. Maniaul, Enrico S.
49. Manuel, Diosdado
50. Manuel, Melchor
51. Martinez, Joel
52. Mediodia, Luciano
53. Mendiola, Manalo
54. Mercado, Luis
55. Ong, Renato S.
56. Orlanes, Eufrocino B.
57. Oway, Luis
58. Perez, Eduardo M.
59. Poblete, Seneco
60. Ramirez, Leo
61. Ranada, Marcelo G.
62. Ravelas, Vicente F.
63. Reyes, Rolando
64. Riete, Rodelio Sr.
65. Robles, Leo
66. Sanchez, Francisco
67. Soriano, Nicanor V.
68. Vergara, Pedro
69. Victoriano, Augusto
In the earlier Cadalin case, we directed the NLRC to receive further evidence as regards the claims of the Annexes "D" and "E" claimants (numbering 752). We have, however, observed that during the proceedings conducted from 1997 to 2001, these claimants, the same as the first-time claimants, did not introduce any evidence to substantiate their claims. As found by the NLRC, "[e]xcept for claims of the 149 claimants listed in Annex "B" of the September 2, 1991 resolution, claims of the other complainants were dismissed in the same resolution either for "lack of substantial evidence in support therefor," or for their being "beyond the competence of this Commission to pass upon. x x x Despite the advise (sic) to file whatever evidence they may have to prove their claims, Atty. Del Mundo failed to attach in his Compliance and Manifestation even a single document of his clients showing employment with Brown & Root in the state of Bahrain. x x x Since Atty. Del Mundo has not submitted proofs of their clients’ claim (sic) as directed, we have nothing to deduce except that there is none to present x x x."58 Not being backed by any proof, the claims of these Annexes "D" and "E" claimants should be dismissed.
Moreover, as abovementioned, these Annexes "D" and "E" claimants, except for 19, already settled their claims. Thus, the NLRC found, and we affirm:
Again, only nineteen (19) complainants listed in Annexes "D" and "E" of our September 2, 1991 Resolution have not executed quitclaims in this case. Sixteen (16) of them, represented by Atty. Del Mundo, are as follows:
1. Amado Aloria
2. Wilfredo Arica
3. Rodolfo B. Celis
4. Felix J. Coronel
5. Generoso Del Rosario
6. Pedro G. De Leon
7. Armando Lucero
8. Alfredo Macalino
9. Eduardo W. Racabo
10. Ruben Robels
11. Rodolfo Robleza
12. Dominador Seria
13. Vicente Bagting
14. Felix Coronel
15. Carlito Espino
16. Rolico Macaraig
while three (3) of them, represented by Atty. De Castro are:
1. Arturo V. Macarig
2. Leo B. Robles
3. Felix M. Diaz59
Thus, following our ruling in Periquet,60 and considering the fact that almost all of these 752 claimants with unsubstantiated claims received sums voluntarily by virtue of the compromise agreement, the Court cannot nullify the waivers and quitclaims executed by them.
As to the remaining 19 claimants who did not settle their claims, the Court affirms the following findings of the NLRC:
In her November 7, 2001 report to the Commission, Arbiter Savari stressed:
It bears to stress at this point that out of the several claims lodged by the complainants, only the claim (sic) for the benefits under the Amiri Decree No. 23 was granted. All the other claims were exhaustively tackled one by one by the Commission, First Division in its Resolution dated September 2, 1991 and after delving thru the microscopic details of their employment and the evidence they presented, all said claims were denied and dismissed.
Hence, as the issue over the other claims is already settled and put to rest to limit the claims of the remaining complainants under Annexes "D" and "E" to their entitlements under the Amiri Decree No. 23 of Bahrain. The foremost consideration hinges on whether complainants have rendered services to Brown & Root in the State of Bahrain upon and during the effectivity of the Amiri Decree No. 23.
An exhaustive examination and verification of the evidence presented by the complainants reveals that the following complainants were employed by Brown & Root International Corp. in the State of Bahrain during the effectivity of the Amiri Decree:
1. Dominador P. Serra
2. Felix M. Diaz
3. Leo B. Robles
4. Arturo V. Macaraig
Since the NLRC Resolution dated September 2, 1991 awarded the complainants in Annex "B" with benefit provided for under the said decree, the herein remaining complainants, who were (sic) similarly situated, are likewise entitled to the same benefits granted to the Complainants in Annex "B" computed and tabulated as follows:
1. Dominador P. Serra
2. Felix M. Diaz
3. Leo B. Robles
4. Arturo V. Macaraig
Since this Decision is an outgrowth of the appeal, the additional claimants, numerous in numbers, who were not complainants in the original POEA Case, are not parties to this case and cannot be treated as complainants as far as this case is concerned.
Thus, except for Dominador P. Serra, Felix M. Diaz, Leo B. Robles and Arturo V. Macaraig, who deserve the awards (sic) given to those listed in Annex "B" of Our (sic) September 2, 1991 resolution, the claims of the fifteen (15) other complainants are deemed unsubstantiated, hence, their meriting an Order from Us (sic) that said claims be dismissed. Considering, however, that BRII settled amicably the claims of all the other complainants listed in Annexes "D" and "E", and in fact, paid them U.S.$500.00 each, equity demands that the aforesaid fifteen (15) other claimants be awarded U.S.$500.00 each.61
The Court will not, however, extend a similar treatment to the Annex "B" claimants who executed waivers, quitclaims and/or compromise agreements in consideration of amounts much lower than what they were entitled to receive under the earlier Cadalin case. As mandated in our earlier decision, the total valid claims of the Annex "B" claimants is US$288,636.70.62 Settling their claims with only US$500.00, a sum grossly disproportionate to their individual claims–some of whom are entitled to more than US$8,000.00, is clearly unjustified. Thus, as to the 149 Annex "B" claimants who entered into compromise agreements for a consideration below the true amounts due them, the Court declares as null and void their respective waivers and quitclaims. But the amounts which each of them have already received shall be deducted from their claims as itemized in Annex "B" of the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution.
At this point, the Court declares and orders that all sums still due to the 149 Annex "B" claimants, and the remaining 19 Annexes "D" and "E" claimants who did not settle their claims, should be paid directly to them and not to their counsels or representatives.
Considering that this case has dragged on for several years, we deem it equitable to impose legal interest of 6% on the still unpaid sums computed from the finality of the earlier Cadalin case promulgated on December 5, 1994, up to the finality of our decision herein. We further impose legal interest of 12% from the finality of this decision up to actual payment.
As a last point, we emphasize that this case dragged on for more than two decades, not because of the complexity of the issues involved, but primarily due to the spiteful practice of petitioners’ counsel in giving false hopes to their clients despite the utter barrenness of their claims. Worse, the said counsel, particularly Atty. Gerardo A. del Mundo, misled the court and the labor tribunal by bombarding them with thousands of claimants, millions of pesos worth of claims and blown-up media attention to disguise the bankruptcy of the case. We remind Atty. del Mundo and all lawyers of the need for fidelity to the principles embodied in the Lawyer’s Oath and in the Code of Professional Responsibility. A lawyer owes candor, fairness and good faith to the Court and to his clients, and he shall rely upon the merits of his cause and refrain from any impropriety which tends to influence, or gives the appearance of influencing, the Court.63
IN THE LIGHT OF THE FOREGOING DISQUISITIONS, the appeal is DENIED. The May 31, 2004 Decision and the July 14, 2005 Resolution of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. SP No. 77272 are AFFIRMED WITH THE FOLLOWING MODIFICATIONS:
1. The compromise agreements, waivers and quitclaims executed by the 149 Annex "B" claimants, insofar as they grant them sums lower than what they were entitled to receive pursuant to the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution, are ANNULLED and SET ASIDE. However, the amounts, which each of the 149 Annex "B" claimants have already received, shall be deducted from their claims as itemized in Annex "B" of the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution.
2. The amounts still due to the Annex "B" claimants and the remaining 19 Annexes "C" and "D" claimants shall be paid directly to the claimants.
3. These sums still due shall earn legal interest of 6% per annum computed from the finality of the earlier Cadalin case promulgated on December 5, 1994, up to the finality of our decision herein, and interest of 12% per annum from the finality of this decision until actual payment.
SO ORDERED.
ANTONIO EDUARDO B. NACHURA
Associate Justice
WE CONCUR:
CONSUELO YNARES-SANTIAGO
Associate Justice
Chairperson |
MA. ALICIA AUSTRIA-MARTINEZ
Associate Justice |
MINITA V. CHICO-NAZARIO
Associate Justice |
RUBEN T. REYES
Associate Justice |
A T T E S T A T I O N
I attest that the conclusions in the above Decision had been reached in consultation before the case was assigned to the writer of the opinion of the Court’s Division.
CONSUELO YNARES-SANTIAGO
Associate Justice
Chairperson, Third Division
C E R T I F I C A T I O N
Pursuant to Section 13, Article VIII of the Constitution and the Division Chairperson’s Attestation, I certify that the conclusions in the above Decision had been reached in consultation before the case was assigned to the writer of the opinion of the Court’s Division.
REYNATO S. PUNO
Chief Justice
Footnotes
1 The listing in the petition of the petitioners’ names is not entirely accurate as there appear to be duplications and misspellings. Nevertheless, the case title herein reflects the said imprecise enumeration of petitioners.
2 This is the total number of claimants as stated in the body of the petition. Actual count, however, of the named petitioners, including those whose names have been duplicated and misspelled, reveals only the total of 2,046. Also, removing the duplicated names results in a total of 2,019 petitioners.
3 Penned by Associate Justice Renato C. Dacudao, with Associate Justices Edgardo F. Sundiam and Japar B. Dimaampao concurring; CA rollo, Vol. II, pp. 1257-1297.
4 Penned by Associate Justice Mario L. Guariña III, with Associate Justices Marina L. Buzon and Santiago Javier Ranada (retired) concurring; CA rollo, Vol. III, pp. 1722-1725.
5 Cadalin v. POEA’s Administrator, G.R. No. 104776, December 5, 1994, 238 SCRA 721, 739.
6 Cadalin v. POEA’s Administrator, supra note 5, at 740-742.
7 Cadalin v. POEA’s Administrator, supra note 5, at 743-744.
8 Rollo (G.R. Nos. 105029-32), pp. 120-122; Cadalin v. POEA’s Administrator, supra note 5, at 744-745.
9 Cadalin v. POEA’s Administrator, supra note 5, at 745-746.
10 Cadalin v. POEA’s Administrator, supra note 5, at 777-778. The decision was penned by Associate Justice Camilo D. Quiason (retired).
11 CA rollo, Vol. I, p. 160, 166-167.
12 Id. at 164-165.
13 Id. at 164.
14 Id. at 607-609.
15 Id. at 608.
16 Id. at 166.
17 Id. at 130-216.
18 Id. at 213-215.
19 Id. at 73.
20 Id. at 78.
21 Id. at 70-129.
22 Id. at 126-128.
23 Id. at 2-69.
24 CA rollo, Vol. II, pp. 1257-1297.
25 Id. at 1297.
26 Supra note 4.
27 Rollo (G.R. No. 168925), p. 351.
28 Id. at 380.
29 Rollo (G.R. No. 168923), pp. 3-96.
30 Id. at 46-47.
31 Supra notes 1 and 2.
32 CA rollo, Vol. I, pp. 77-82.
33 368 Phil. 537 (1999).
34 Surigao del Norte Electric Cooperative v. National Labor Relations Commission, supra note 33, at 550-551, citing Kathy-O Enterprises v. National Labor Relations Commission, 286 SCRA 729, 738-739 (1998).
35 Rules of Procedure of the NLRC, Series of 1999, Rule VII, Section 10, which now appears in the same rule and section of the 2005 Revised Rules of Procedure of the NLRC.
36 Rules of Procedure of the NLRC, Series of 1999, Rule VI, Section 6, in relation to Rule VII, Section 14 (Section 15 in the 2005 Revised Rules of Procedure).
37 Palomado v. National Labor Relations Commission, G.R. No. 96520, June 28, 1996, 257 SCRA 680, 689.
38 Machica v. Roosevelt Services Center, Inc., G.R. No. 168664, May 4, 2006, 489 SCRA 534, 547.
39 Aquino v. Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 149404, September 15, 2006, 502 SCRA 76, 85.
40 Sonza v. ABS-CBN Broadcasting Corporation, G.R. No. 138051, June 10, 2004, 431 SCRA 583, 594.
41 Supra notes 1 and 2.
42 Supra note 5.
43 Supra note 8.
44 CA rollo, Vol. I, p. 103.
45 Id. at 164-165.
46 Id. at 164-165.
47 Id. at 100.
48 Domasig v. National Labor Relations Commission, G.R. No. 118101, September 16, 1996, 261 SCRA 779, 785.
49 Rollo (G.R. No. 18923), pp. 403-404. (Underscoring ours.)
50 CA rollo, Vol. I, pp. 164-165.
51 Id. at 115.
52 The said article of the Labor Code, as amended, provides:
ART. 277. COMPROMISE AGREEMENTS
Any compromise settlement, including those involving labor standard laws, voluntarily agreed upon by the parties with the assistance of the Bureau or the regional offices of the Department of Labor, shall be final and binding upon the parties. The National Labor Relations Commission or any courts shall not assume jurisdiction over issues involved therein except in case of noncompliance thereof or if there is prima facie evidence that the settlement was obtained through fraud, misrepresentation or coercion.
53 In this Periquet case, G.R. No. 91298, June 22, 1990, 186 SCRA 724, we laid the doctrinal policy that:
Not all waivers and quitclaims are invalid as against public policy. If the agreement was voluntarily entered into and represents a reasonable settlement, it is binding on the parties and may not later on be disowned simply because of a change of mind. It is only where there is clear proof that the waiver was wangled from an unsuspecting or gullible person, or the terms of settlement are unconscionable on its face, that the law will step in to annul the questionable transaction. But where it is shown that the person making the waiver did so voluntarily, with full understanding of what he was doing, and the consideration for the quitclaim is credible and reasonable, the transaction must be recognized as a valid and binding undertaking. x x x. (Id. at 730-731).
54 Galicia v. National Labor Relations Commission, G.R. No. 119649, July 28, 1997, 276 SCRA 381, 386.
55 Bantolino v. Coca-Cola Bottlers Phils., Inc., 451 Phil. 839, 846-847 (2003).
56 Cornista-Domingo v. National Labor Relations Commission, G.R. No. 156761, October 17, 2006, 504 SCRA 659, 674.
57 Rollo (G.R. No. 104776), pp. 134-141.
58 Rollo (G.R. No. 168923), pp. 403-404.
59 Id. at 405-406.
60 Supra note 53.
61 Id. at 406-408.
62 Records, Vol. 1, Annex B of the September 2, 1991 NLRC Resolution.
63 Code of Professional Responsibility, Canons 10, 13 and 15.
The Lawphil Project - Arellano Law Foundation
|
